3 ms·
All of the people who published anti-climate-change studies on behalf of the oil industry also had credentials. Even people with credentials can succumb to tem
by lisper 9y ago
All of the people who published anti-climate-change studies on behalf of the oil industry also had credentials. Even people with credentials can succumb to temptation.
And I didn't say that this piece was commission by the NRA. I said that it would not surprise me to learn that it was. I'm advancing that as one hypothesis to explain the very strange too-good-to-be-true correspondence between the author's rhetoric and the classic tropes and talking points of the NRA. That might all be a coincidence, and it might be that all of the oversights and faulty reasoning are really Leah Libresco's work alone. But that would imply that Leah Libresco is incredibly stupid and a really bad statistician, and that seems unlikely to me.
- JCzynski 9y agoI know her personally, and she's a better statistician than you. Also, I've independently done a lot of the same research, going to primary sources. It's correct.
- MagnumOpus 9y agoReally? Do you also know lisper personally? I don't have a horse in the race, but if we are doing argument by authority, I would trust the CS PhD and JPL researcher more than the blogger with a PoliSci degree undergrad who dabbled in data visualisation and SPSS and thinks she is an authority.
- lisper 9y agoTo say nothing of the fact that one of the reasons I think she might be a shill for the NRA is that I don't think that she's stupid.