4 ms·
>Personally I'm a proponent of mandatory gun insurance and owner liability. That would just be a way to make people who are young, not white, live in higher cr
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
>Personally I'm a proponent of mandatory gun insurance and owner liability.
That would just be a way to make people who are young, not white, live in higher crime areas, etc, etc pay more.
Shooting something/someone you shouldn't be shooting is incredibly rare so either premiums would be negligible or they would have be be artificially high (vice tax).
Furthermore it would also be fought every step of the way by anyone who doesn't want a registration scheme since it effectively would create one.
The idea itself should have a positive impact (at least on paper) since it would presumably make high risk groups less likely to own firearms (at a statistical level) but it's pretty incompatible with something that's right. You don't need to pay for free speech insurance in case you offend someone.
- nostrademons 9y agoThat may be the intended result, if the desired effect is to limit gun violence without impinging on legitimate owners' rights to own guns. And then higher cost of guns = less gun violence = less need to own a gun = less gun violence = lower cost of insurance = the price reaches an equilibrium where the true cost of owning a gun is equal to the negative externalities it causes. At least that's the theory. It's unclear whether it'll actually play out that way, with the existence of black markets and the general inability to afford a lawyer and sue for damages within these communities.
- etchalon 9y agoWe currently have a government mandate which demands we have health insurance, which was upheld by SCOTUS. This doesn't seem like that much of a stretch.
- angersock 9y agoHow well has everybody been served by that mandate? How much of the current fuckery of healthcare and costs is directly due to the insurance complex? Hint: it's nontrivial, and in fact is a direct cause of rising costs in healthcare.
- kharms 9y agoCar insurance is also a mandate. It works well. The healthcare situation isn't because it's a mandate, it's because of inelastic demand. A situation that's not comparable to gun ownership.
- angersock 9y agoArguably, in cities without good public transportation, car insurance has inelastic demand too. Further, it's being used to do things like backdoor in ubiquitous surveillance using GPS. One also wonders what the effect car insurance has had on repair costs, for similar reasons as healthcare. My point is that adding an insurance burden onto guns isn't a clear win, unless you assume that further government intervention (by the queerly circuitous route of private-sector insurance involvement the US seems to like) is unquestionably good. It also doesn't make sense to require insure for guns that are used for target shooting a few times a year. Frankly, given the huge number of firearms and owners in this country and the rather small amount of violence they produce, it would probably be a bigger win to ask for mandatory insurance on pools, ladders, fast-food, sugary drinks, and so forth.
- kharms 9y ago>That would just be a way to make people who are young, not white, live in higher crime areas, etc, etc pay more. Except for the racial discrimination that all sounds reasonable, and racial discrimination is avoidable[0]. Car insurance costs more depending on where you live, what kind of car you have, your age, your education, your driving history, etc. I recently looked into getting a car and decided against it because cost of parking + insurance + depreciation was greater than renting every other weekend. I don't believe driving is less essential a right than gun ownership. > Shooting something/someone you shouldn't be shooting is incredibly rare A large portion of violent crime is committed with stolen weapons.[1] I believe the original owner should be liable if the weapon wasn't properly secured. From the OP: "Two-thirds of gun deaths in the United States every year are suicides. Almost no proposed restriction would make it meaningfully harder for people with guns on hand to use them." Key phrase - guns on hand. Guns are a highly effective and impulse-friendly suicide method. "Various studies of survivors of suicide have calculated that as many as two-thirds of those who reported suicidal behavior did not plan their attempt...About half of those did so within 20 minutes, and three-quarters of suicide attempts occurred within an hour."[2] Also from OP: "And the last notable group of similar deaths was the 1,700 women murdered per year, usually as the result of domestic violence." A world where a woman is beaten instead of shot because there isn't a gun in the house, or the gun isn't easily accessible is a world where that woman survives and can seek help. It's not a good world, but it's better. Imagine a gun safe that opens one hour after you put in the code. Still accessible for deliberate action, while drastically reducing the cost of impulsive violence. P.S. The racial discrimination link is a good read, check it out. [0] https://research.google.com/bigpicture/attacking-discrimination-in-ml/ https://research.google.com/bigpicture/attacking-discriminat... [1] http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-parsons-stolen-guns-20170727-story.html http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-parsons-stolen-gu... [2] https://www.bradycampaign.org/the-link-between-suicide-and-guns-impulsivity https://www.bradycampaign.org/the-link-between-suicide-and-g...