2 ms·
> The profit made in US is taxed in the US. Isn't that so? Hypothetical analogy: say BMW GmbH owned an American subsidiary (BMW Inc) that did all the US manufa
by sangnoir 9y ago
> The profit made in US is taxed in the US. Isn't that so?
Hypothetical analogy: say BMW GmbH owned an American subsidiary (BMW Inc) that did all the US manufacturing under license via another subsidiary in Panama. BMW GmbH controls the cost of the IP (design, patents, control software) being licensed to BMW Inc - this cost can be tweaked so that BMW Inc never turns a profit, and so will not pay any American taxes. All the profits will be accumulating in Panama while waiting for Germany to rework its repatriation laws.
- themihai 9y agoWell they would have to pay: - Import tax on all the products(IP, patenets, licenses etc) licensed/purchased from BMW Panama - Sales tax? So the US would get more customs and sales tax and less profit tax. Nevertheless the scheme you mentioned is meant to lower the tax paid(i.e. the import tax may be lower than the profit tax) so I fully agree that something should be done. I guess only solution would be the term "tax avoidance" to be defined, put into the trade agreements(i.e. WTO, EU etc) and governments allowed fine the companies employing such practices just like the "state aid". The issue in EU is way worse because there is no import or sales tax so using your hypothetical story BMW GmbH pays only the profit tax in Panama. Related: In Europe the operating company takes loans at high interest rates from its shell in Luxembourgh to siphon off the profits.