3 ms·
> Happens all the time, cities choose tax rates for themselves, states for themselves, and feds for themselves. You might want to re-read gps comment again, be
by sangnoir 9y ago
> Happens all the time, cities choose tax rates for themselves, states for themselves, and feds for themselves.
You might want to re-read gps comment again, because you seem to be mangling their analogy:
>Imagine a mayor in a US city giving a company a deal whereby they don't pay state and federal taxes and only pay a low municipal tax.
Gp's point is that cities don't get to override federal taxes - if they attempt it and you're dumb enough to listen to them, the IRS will definitely collect what they owe. The same goes for individual countries in the EU - they don't get to override EU law.
> The IRS isn't going to come and tell me to pay my city more in property taxes because I got an unfair abatement.
Your critique falls apart because there is no US federal law that says cities can't unfairly advantage companies inside their borders. In contrast - there are EU laws make this form of state subsidies illegal.
- kodablah 9y ago> Gp's point is that cities don't get to override federal taxes - if they attempt it and you're dumb enough to listen to them, the IRS will definitely collect what they owe. And my point is that they will also sanction, admonish, or worse the one overriding those laws regularly. If push came to shove, the IRS would toss an official in jail if they were constantly encouraging/helping people skirt the law. > Your critique falls apart because there is no US federal law that says cities can't unfairly advantage companies inside their borders Yup, it does fall apart, but more because the analogy was flawed to begin with.