3 ms·
Licensing IP is the weapon of choice for modern tax evasion. Estimating costs of goods and services is relatively easy for tax authorities, there are detailed r
by toyg 9y ago
Licensing IP is the weapon of choice for modern tax evasion. Estimating costs of goods and services is relatively easy for tax authorities, there are detailed rules and so on; but IP is so vague that it can be easily abused. It's the same story with Starbucks and so on.
> there is more than a good chance that this will not hold in the high court.
That is very unlikely. The Commission tends not to act directly unless they are absolutely certain that the case is extremely clear and they have ticked all boxes. This is because these actions have, obviously, huge political repercussions; Commissioners, at the end of the day, are politicians who have been entrusted to be somewhat above the fray and to look out for the whole continent, so they usually don't want to be accused of partisanship (there are always exceptions, of course; but the culprits tend to pay a heavy price in the end). The act itself is basically a statement that they have a great deal of proof. You won't find many people who know European legislation better than EU staffers themselves, so when they act on it, it's very unlikely they will lose a legal confrontation.
- wav-part 9y agoEC is not just disagreeing with Apple's legal team but Ireland Govt (IG). Arguably IG is atleast as competent as EC if not more. And then not to mention 3rd parties such USA Treasury. I dont know how EC can justify (in court) violating non-retroactivity traditions/laws.
- toyg 9y ago> Arguably IG is atleast as competent as EC That's why the Commission rarely acts in such a direct manner - they know they are talking to very powerful interests. But again, in most cases, when such procedures are invoked, national governments are eventually found in violation. Nobody enjoys victimizing a member state, they only do it when infractions are so egregious that they cannot be ignored. > violating non-retroactivity traditions/laws. If you don't pay taxes in 2012 and the state sues you in 2014, as long as the statute of limitations allows it, there is no retroactivity. The Commission only started to actively investigate these arrangements recently, but the relevant laws have been on the books (or rather in the treaties) for a very long time. Just because a policeman doesn't arrest you for beating your neighbour doesn't mean you're not breaking the law.