4 ms·
> You guys really should get smart ID cards like every other sane country. We should not. You don't have EU-issued ID, we don't need US-issued ID. When you d
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> You guys really should get smart ID cards like every other sane country.
We should not.
You don't have EU-issued ID, we don't need US-issued ID.
When you drop off your clothes at a dry cleaner, they give you a ticket that lets you pick them up again. They don't need an ID number that lets them correlate your dry cleaning with your Amazon purchases and your phone's location history and your medical records and your tax returns. And we shouldn't give them one.
- 794CD01 9y agoIf I did have such a number, the dry cleaner could know when I was on my way to the store and bring my clothes up to the counter so they are ready when I arrive. And they could hold my amazon purchases for me to pick up at the same time.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoWhy would I want my USB adapter delivered to my dry cleaner instead of my home or workplace? Literally none of those things require a national ID anyway. You can just give them that information, if you want to. The ID only allows to it to happen without your consent. Including all the things you don't want, like price discrimination.
- 794CD01 9y agoIf that's your preference, then instead you'd opt to have your dry cleaning delivered to your home or workplace as well.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoIn which case it no longer has any relationship with your Amazon purchases, which come from an entirely different place. And still doesn't require a national ID to implement.
- 794CD01 9y agoThere are systems like the one we use today where it doesn't have one, but that means each vendor has its own independent source of truth for things like your mailing address, delivery preferences, etc that are more convenient to maintain in only one place.
- talmand 9y agoI fail to see enough advantage in such a system to go along with that idea.
- 794CD01 9y agoI believe that's called "being out of touch".
- yahna 9y agoSo don't give them one. Doesn't mean the government should have issues identifying people when needed (for government services, for example).
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> So don't give them one. If one exists then they'll use it without your permission. Or refuse service to anyone who doesn't provide it. Which means it needs to not exist. > Doesn't mean the government should have issues identifying people when needed (for government services, for example). Any government agency is free to give you an ID card used to identify you to that agency in the future, the same as any private entity -- but then companies can't require you to have one because not all citizens interact with any given agency. And then nothing stops you from closing any account in good standing and reopening a new one with a different ID number. Correlating every interaction you have with government is not a feature. The IRS does not need to know who has applied for a hunting license or vice versa. The FBI should not have access to the list of books you've checked out from the public library. These things should all be separate from each other.
- _Tev 9y agoIt's funny how some people call for separate IDs for each govt agency and some (different?) people then use such fragmented measures as a proof of govt inefficiency. But I do think people are excessively paranoid / anti government today, so maybe just my bias is showing.