5 ms·
I think that's been an economic reality in the USA for a few years now, though also including natural gas in the tech doing the replacing. The recent EPA docume
by ZeroGravitas 9y ago
I think that's been an economic reality in the USA for a few years now, though also including natural gas in the tech doing the replacing. The recent EPA document that was intended to support coal and nuclear covered this:
“The draft report finds that since 2002, ‘most baseload power plant retirements have been the victims of overcapacity and relatively high operating cost but often reflect the advanced age of the retiring plants.’
“Overcapacity is a major cause of the turmoil in electricity markets. The report explains that because the growth in electricity demand has flattened since 2008, it is harder for ‘less competitive plants’ to survive. …
“And it doesn’t make sense to keep an uneconomic plant running when you know it’s going to keep losing money.
“In the case of nuclear power, the study notes that vast majority of the plant closure announcements blame plant retirement on ‘unfavorable market conditions.’ And the ‘most unfavorable condition is that the marginal cost of generation for many nuclear plants is higher than the cost of most other generators in the market.’
“Similarly, coal is also hurt by its high marginal cost: ‘[Coal] plants that have retired are old and inefficient units that were not recovering their operations and fuel costs, much less capital cost recovery.'”
That may be starting with the oldest, dirtiest and least efficient powerplants but it's only going to get worse for them as time goes on.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoSmall caveat: the Trump administration is looking into using a national security law from decades ago to prop up coal plants (the law provides subsidies to generators who can keep 90 days of fuel on hand). If this policy were to go into effect, it would raise rates consumers pay, very likely speeding the adoption of rooftop solar in those markets. https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/news/articles/2017-09-29/perry-moves-to-aid-coal-nuclear-generators-with-pricing-rule https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/news/articles/2017-09-29/perry...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kcorbitt 9y agoThat's kind of ironic, considering that solar plants can keep an effectively unlimited number of "days of fuel" on hand.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoThey can't though -- the next day could always be cloudy and there's a very strong chance that one day in 90 will be. So solar panels can't stock a reliable X day supply, even if over any (moderate) period of time, they have a very guaranteed supply.
- bluGill 9y agoThey can with batteries, but that is a slightly different situation. In answer to the question below, this isn't practical with modern battery technology.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoIs there a battery technology that can store 90 days worth of full-plant production (which doesn't require a second generator consuming a fuel later)? All the ways I know of on that scale actually require a second plant/turbine -- in which case, you didn't store 90 days of solar production capacity, you actually stored 90 days of the second plant's fuel, which you produced intermitently with solar capacity. (Which can still be a very good and environmentally friendly thing to do! But isn't what we're talking about as a technical point.) Ways of the second variety: - Hydro pumping - Hydrocarbon synthesis - Hydrogen separation - Compressing gasses And there's probably more that I'm forgetting.
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoThis doesn’t worry me. In fact I like the idea of coal power plants being a backup and ready to go. The more solar we have the less backup we’ll need, but it’s always nice to have a backup.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoCoal generators don't work this way. It can take 12-36 hours to ramp from a cold start. Natural gas (combined cycle turbines) can throttle up in minutes, which is what pushed coal out of the generation mix (natural gas is a perfect compliment to renewables until battery storage is cost competitive, you have to be able to fill in generation intermittency gaps with little response latency). Here's a great story [1] from the Tampa Bay Times about what happened when TECO (the local utility) didn't want to power down a coal fired boiler to take the generator out of service to clear slag from the bottom of the boiler (TL;DR several people died a horrible death from the equivalent of flowing magma). Coal is almost dead, just a bit more of a way to go. [1] http://www.tampabay.com/projects/2017/investigations/tampa-electric/big-bend-hellfire-from-above/ http://www.tampabay.com/projects/2017/investigations/tampa-e...
- Brakenshire 9y agoCoal is dead in Britain, there will be zero generation in the next few years. It was the deregulated energy industry that killed it, starting in the 80's, out-competed on price and flexibility by gas.
- ben_w 9y agoI don’t want to sound like I’m a fan of coal, but coal died in the UK before it became uneconomical: the coal miners went on strike for long enough that the government made it a strategic goal to never let striking workers be politically relevant again.
- KirinDave 9y agoA much better plan is to use an excess of solar energy to power processes that produce ethanol-based fuels and then keep a reserve of those (which by the by, is carbon sequestration at best and neutral at worst). Coal power plants are awkward and inefficient and require a lot of work just to move the fuel around. There's a reason the world worked hard to develop better fuel technologies as quickly as possible.
- MrRadar 9y agoThe oversupply in the generation market is why I've lately been confused why the coal and nuclear industries haven't been promoting electric vehicles more vigorously to drive demand for electricity. With pretty much every other electric appliance having only gotten more efficient I don't see any other way to drive significant increases in demand.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago"Utilities Should Charge Into Electric Vehicles" "The total potential market for electricity fueling American vehicles is staggering (warning: large back-of-envelope ahead).Let's just take light-duty vehicles (not heavy trucks or buses), of which there were about 190 million on the road in 2015, according to government figures. For the sake of simplicity, replace them all with a full battery-electric vehicle that gets 3.5 miles per kilowatt-hour, loses 10 percent of the power it takes as it charges and discharges, and travels 13,000 miles a year.Presto! You've basically created an entirely new center of demand for power rivaling the entire industrial sector of the U.S.:" https://www.bloomberg.com/gadfly/articles/2017-10-03/electric-vehicle-charging-infrastructure-utilities-can-charge-in https://www.bloomberg.com/gadfly/articles/2017-10-03/electri...
- dagss 9y agoWell you need to subtract what is currently burned off in refineries in those calculations it is quite significant (roughly same amount of energy for refining oil and electric cars per mile driven but only 1/5 or so in electricity and rest in burning oil products). Gasoline cars use lots of electricity...
- petra 9y agoI don't think electric vehicles lack promotion.
- MrRadar 9y agoWhen was the last time you saw or heard an ad for a electric car? If you went into a car dealership, would you expect the salesperson to recommend an electric car to you if you didn't ask?
- bluGill 9y agoNote that there is a difference between retirement and destroyed. I believe my company still keeps an old coal boiler from the 1880s connected to a generator from the 1920s in operating condition. Because this generator exists and can be started in an emergency (with 12 hours warning for warm up time) we get a substantial discount on our power. I understand that about every 5 years the power company asks us to turn it on at which point we supply power for most of the town. If you look you will see many businesses have their own generator running on the hottest day of the year - they get a discount. Because diesel generators can start on a minutes notice they get are higher on the priority list as to when they get asked to run on their own generator rather than grid power. The above isn't to say that the power company is retiring these old power plants in the same way. I would guess in some cases the maintenance required to make them safe (or emissions legal) to use might be too high and they are destroyed.
- KirinDave 9y agoIt would be prudent to have backups,but it's hard to imagine why many nuclear plants would be kept in operating condition.