4 ms·
> I'd love to take a massive dish (say, 20 foot > diameter) & see how many can be captured from > inside a neighboring building. Are you talking about acti
by pyre 16y ago
> I'd love to take a massive dish (say, 20 foot
> diameter) & see how many can be captured from
> inside a neighboring building.
Are you talking about active or passive RFID? I was under the impression that most RFID in use is passive. In that case, you'd have to transmit something to get a response, unless you're talking about camping out in an area where lots of cards are going be activated by various things other than yourself (e.g. entrance to the transit system). But even then the transmitting power of the RFID chip is proportional (?) to the power used to activate it, so something that only expects to read it from 2 feet away isn't going to blast it with enough power to be reliably read from 100 feet away, unless I'm misunderstanding how people do those long distance RFID reading records...
- Groxx 16y agoPassively camping out. Lots of (questionable) RFID uses I've seen are to unlock doors, often external ones. And if it's in a business park, it could easily be closer to 50 feet or less between buildings.
- fragmede 16y agoSo say a 5-foot range. Find a group of employees out for lunch together and I walk past the table with a backpack on. Hardly suspicious, and I've probably got most of their building access cards.
- pyre 16y agoI was responding to someone to someone talking about a 20-foot dish though. That's not something you stuff in a backpack. I was commenting on his desire to listen with a huge dish at a distance.
- sesqu 16y agoI vaguely remember an article from around the time RFID passports were a hot issue, in which researchers used multiple capturing devices and were able to square the reading distance. I don't know whether that was specific to the distance they used, the type of RFID, or even an upper limit, but it was an unbelievable improvement.
- dfox 16y agoMost applications of RFID by authentication (think door locks) use only unique ID (address) of the card and nothing else. And the communication protocol used by reader works like this: Is there anyone with address starting with 0? ... Starting with 1? Yes. Starting with 10? ... Starting with 11? Yes. ..... So you only have to listen to reader side of communication and guess the last bit.
- superuser2 16y agoWhen I first heard of this attack I'm pretty sure the solution to that is a high-gain antenna. I don't know how often that actually works, but it's theoretically supposed to.