4 ms·
Luxembourg has a 29% corporate tax rate the 4th highest in Europe. This isn't Liechtenstein, Ireland or Estonia... Unlike Ireland Luxembourg also did not hand o
by dogma1138 9y ago
Luxembourg has a 29% corporate tax rate the 4th highest in Europe.
This isn't Liechtenstein, Ireland or Estonia...
Unlike Ireland Luxembourg also did not hand out tax credits.
Shell paid less than 1 bln US in tax last year in the EU, and less than 5 bln US globally, and overall it's by far much more subsidized than Apple or Amazon, the difference being it's a European corporation.
Most of not all of the largest European corporations excel at Tax avoidance, in fact they are the ones Google, Apple and Amazon learned the tricks of the trade from, heck the EU was just fine establishing tax heavens for their own corporations and canonizing them in EU law as long as they are the ones benefiting from them.
- olau 9y ago> Unlike Ireland Luxembourg also did not hand out tax credits. This seems to be contradicted by the story itself: "Luxembourg gave illegal tax benefits to Amazon. As a result, almost three-quarters of Amazon's profits were not taxed," Ms Vestager added. She said Amazon paid four times less tax than other local companies.
- dogma1138 9y agoYou should read the actual source. Amazon paid normal tax rates on trade goods, it paid the lower tax rate on IP derived revenue such as AWS and several other digital services the deal wasn’t any different than what EU companies in Europe get including OVH. The difference is that Amazon like many other US tech companies have substantial revenue from IP and licensing while EU companies still rely on trade goods and services. This isn’t a court ruling like with Apple there is more than a good chance that this will not hold in the high court. Likely even better since Amazon didn’t get direct tax subsidies.
- riffraff 9y agoThis is the actual source http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-17-3701_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-17-3701_en.htm And it says > The tax ruling enabled Amazon to shift the vast majority of its profits from an Amazon group company that is subject to tax in Luxembourg (Amazon EU) to a company which is not subject to tax (Amazon Europe Holding Technologies) [...] the level of the royalty payments, endorsed by the tax ruling, was inflated and did not reflect economic reality. IANAL, but I am not sure why you interpret this as different from Apple's. They both depend on the arbitrariness and non-generality of a company-specific tax ruling.
- wav-part 9y agoHere is Apple's appeal. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:62016TN0892&from=EN http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX... > They both depend on the arbitrariness and non-generality of a company-specific tax ruling. Thats an opinion not a fact. The case has yet to begin in court. IMO Apple did not get any special treatment. Basically all you need is a country like Ireland where an onshore incorporated become non-resident if controlled offshore [1]. And Ireland must be not be considered as tax haven [2] by USA [3] otherwise Apple Sales International would be taxed as per USA laws whether Apple USA repatriates or not. [1] This was true until 2015. [2] IIRC Ireland must be considered tax-fair country. Obviously a more strict condition. [3] Now here Ireland enjoy the benefit of single USA-EU tax treaty.
- riffraff 9y ago> Thats an opinion not a fact sure, but it's the opinion of the EU. The same applies in Apple's case, it also is the opinion of the EU, and might be reverted in court. My comment was only about the fact that they are the same thing, there is no major difference between the Apple and Amazon case.
- toyg 9y agoLicensing IP is the weapon of choice for modern tax evasion. Estimating costs of goods and services is relatively easy for tax authorities, there are detailed rules and so on; but IP is so vague that it can be easily abused. It's the same story with Starbucks and so on. > there is more than a good chance that this will not hold in the high court. That is very unlikely. The Commission tends not to act directly unless they are absolutely certain that the case is extremely clear and they have ticked all boxes. This is because these actions have, obviously, huge political repercussions; Commissioners, at the end of the day, are politicians who have been entrusted to be somewhat above the fray and to look out for the whole continent, so they usually don't want to be accused of partisanship (there are always exceptions, of course; but the culprits tend to pay a heavy price in the end). The act itself is basically a statement that they have a great deal of proof. You won't find many people who know European legislation better than EU staffers themselves, so when they act on it, it's very unlikely they will lose a legal confrontation.
- wav-part 9y agoEC is not just disagreeing with Apple's legal team but Ireland Govt (IG). Arguably IG is atleast as competent as EC if not more. And then not to mention 3rd parties such USA Treasury. I dont know how EC can justify (in court) violating non-retroactivity traditions/laws.
- toyg 9y ago> Arguably IG is atleast as competent as EC That's why the Commission rarely acts in such a direct manner - they know they are talking to very powerful interests. But again, in most cases, when such procedures are invoked, national governments are eventually found in violation. Nobody enjoys victimizing a member state, they only do it when infractions are so egregious that they cannot be ignored. > violating non-retroactivity traditions/laws. If you don't pay taxes in 2012 and the state sues you in 2014, as long as the statute of limitations allows it, there is no retroactivity. The Commission only started to actively investigate these arrangements recently, but the relevant laws have been on the books (or rather in the treaties) for a very long time. Just because a policeman doesn't arrest you for beating your neighbour doesn't mean you're not breaking the law.
- raesene6 9y agohttp://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/100115/why-luxembourg-considered-tax-haven.asp http://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/100115/why-luxembour... suggests that the basic rate is 21%? and http://www.grantthornton.lu/online/www/navMain/publications/908/981/982/contentContainer/13464/5051/ENG/GTnewsletter_taxalert.Feb2016_2_JMH_revision.pdf http://www.grantthornton.lu/online/www/navMain/publications/... suggests the rate is currently falling Also has some other pointers about why Luxembourg is considered a tax haven...
- dogma1138 9y agohttp://www.grantthornton.lu/online/www/navMain/publications/908/981/982/contentContainer/13464/5051/ENG/GTnewsletter_taxalert.Feb2016_2_JMH_revision.pdf http://www.grantthornton.lu/online/www/navMain/publications/... It’s being reduced to 27 from 29, your figures don’t count in CIT.
- noelwelsh 9y agoOne corporation doing something morally wrong and getting away with it doesn't excuse another company for doing the same. "He did it first" doesn't work on the playground and neither should it work in corporate law.
- bmmayer1 9y agoThere's nothing morally wrong with reducing one's tax burden to the extent that is legally permissible. From Judge Learned Hand: "Anyone may arrange his affairs so that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which best pays the treasury. There is not even a patriotic duty to increase one's taxes. Over and over again the Courts have said that there is nothing sinister in so arranging affairs as to keep taxes as low as possible. Everyone does it, rich and poor alike and all do right, for nobody owes any public duty to pay more than the law demands"
- falcolas 9y agoAah, yes, those crafty poor with their Dutch sandwiches, accounts in the Caymans and Switzerland, and their tax-shelter charities. This quote sounds almost ironically similar to this quip from Anatole France: The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread.
- bmmayer1 9y agoWell there's an income spectrum in society beyond 'the rich' and 'the poor' but certainly our poorest citizens reduce their tax burden as much as possible as well. When was the last time someone working for cash under the table declared their income?
- alistairSH 9y agoWhile that's true, it's also a simplistic take on taxes. The mega-rich, including corporations, work with the government (bribery, oops, I mean campaign donations) to ensure there are loopholes in place to avoid taxes. While the average citizen can attempt to minimize his obligation, he has very little opportunity to do so. In the US, most people (about 60%) do better taking the standard deduction vs itemizing their deductions.
- jpkeisala 9y agoWhy do so many companies are there if it is not for taxes? Every large corporation regardless where they are from are try to get out of paying taxes in EU and it is great they are hunted. Many of them have been under EU tax crackdown and many more are to come.
- dogma1138 9y agoFor the same reasons as Delaware, the legal framework and establishment are favorable but there is nothing criminal in this. As for the second parts it’s every large non-EU corporation and that is the problem. These acts as well as the anti trust investigation into Google and other such affairs is a protective response to the lack of competitiveness from EU corporations primarily in Tech. Tax avoidance in the EU isn’t an oversight it’s a deliberately orchestrated and legislated ordeal which was established to favor EU corporations. Since the EU seemed to nearly skip the tech giant bubble and it’s largest corporations are primarily ancient energy and finance giants it now goes after US corporations which have subsidiaries in the EU. This is selective enforcement the EU didn’t go after Lidl which keeps much of its Tax books private it didn’t go after BNP, Shell, ING and the like all of which also excel at not paying.
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoDogma, you are insistent that the EU is biased. Yet you show no proof. Prove, or stop saying this garbage.
- Fnoord 9y ago> For the same reasons as Delaware, the legal framework and establishment are favorable but there is nothing criminal in this. What you omit is that it is favorable because there is no income tax [1]: "Delaware charges no income tax on corporations not operating within the state, so taking advantage of Delaware's other benefits does not result in taxation." European companies cannot incorporate in Delaware. If they would, they'd fall under US law. Now, if the United States of America wishes to keep legal frameworks like these intact that is mostly the loss of all of the US citizens, although also a problem for competition due to lower prices. You are deceiving when you claim Shell is paying no tax. I have a Dutch source with data saying they paid 10 billion in 2010 in The Netherlands [2]. I don't know if this fair or not, but I want to state that the EU needs to go after every company which is avoiding paying tax. That said, they should go after the biggest and easiest fish first. > Tax avoidance in the EU isn’t an oversight it’s a deliberately orchestrated and legislated ordeal which was established to favor EU corporations. Pot, meet kettle. AFAIK, no EU corporations follow the Irish-Dutch construction. Starbucks, for example, had to pay back money as well. If you want to do business in the EU, you're going to pay income tax. Simple. > This is selective enforcement the EU didn’t go after Lidl which keeps much of its Tax books private Lidl is not keeping its tax books in UK private anymore since 2014 [3]. For completion, here's a list of companies following the double Irish with a Dutch sandwich construction [4]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delaware_General_Corporation_Law#Tax_benefits_and_burdens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delaware_General_Corporation_L... [2] https://www.nu.nl/beurs/2795797/shell-draagt-10-miljard-af-overheid.html https://www.nu.nl/beurs/2795797/shell-draagt-10-miljard-af-o... [3] http://www.bbc.com/news/business-28416081 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-28416081 [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement#Companies_using_the_arrangement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement#Compa...
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoEurope excels at tax avoidance? Really? Corporate Tax avoidance became a "thing" from about when President Reagan was in office. This enables American companies to makes billions in Europe and NOT contribute to the EUs budget. Which have "socialized" programs, and this anathema to certain political types in the US.
- taysic 9y ago'....Luxembourg’s role in orchestrating tax avoidance deals for hundreds of global companies was revealed by the Guardian in 2014, raising questions about tax policy in one of the EU’s oldest member states. The case continues to hang over Jean-Claude Juncker, the European commission president, who served as Luxembourg’s prime minister from 1995 to 2013, and acted as finance minister for much of that period..... '" The point is they get backroom deals. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2014/nov/05/-sp-luxembourg-tax-files-tax-avoidance-industrial-scale https://www.theguardian.com/business/2014/nov/05/-sp-luxembo...