14 ms·
Zucktown, USA
- princekolt 9y agoHN is criticizing the article wording but completely ignoring its point. This article coupled with the other one on the dystopian reality of San Francisco[1] have me feeling completely disgusted at the current state of the tech industry. Simply put: these tech giants are making too much money. They are losing touch with the average people and simply put with reality itself. It wouldn't surprise me if that's exactly how all "evil" companies of the past became evil themselves. [1]: https://www.mhudack.com/blog/2017/10/1/san-francisco-now-with-more-dystopia https://www.mhudack.com/blog/2017/10/1/san-francisco-now-wit...
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoMaking money is not evil. Wall street makes money, pharma makes money, lawyers make money, insurance makes money, automobiles, consumer goods, real estate - all huge industries. Now that tech is being used on a massive scale of course the tech companies are making money. So what? It doesn't make sense to equate rich with evil - either for companies or for people. SF (and many cities in the US and across the world) have always had poor people. The world has always been very unequal with kings and paupers and everything in between. Now some of them are in the same town and it freaks people out.. welcome to the real world. Anyone who has ever lived in NYC has seen the same inequality.
- jonbarker 9y agoMaking money is not evil, but social class increases likelihood of utilitarianism. Being a tech elite in the valley arguably makes one more likely to be more of a utilitarian. https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/psyched/201304/the-rich-are-differently-moral https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/psyched/201304/the-rich.... Large scale usage does not increase likelihood of profit, either. There aren't any hard disk drive billionaires, for example. Also they aren't in the same town; those who are trying to make it or work in the 'supporting cast' take BART from oakland or richmond, or do extreme commuting from the san joaquin valley.
- Bartweiss 9y agoThis argument seems a little surreal. Is the take here seriously "utilitarianism is so intrinsically bad that wealth is evil because it causes utilitarianism?" Utilitarianism is an exceedingly broad category; hedonistic, rule, preference, and negative utilitarianism all recommend different behaviors. But none of them equate to selfishness or abuse of others. I mean, the article does give us "Piff’s earlier work suggests Richie might act in a way that neither a utilitarian nor a non-utilitarian would support, benefiting himself at the expense of others." But that's a completely different, contradictory argument being thrown in as though it bolsters the main point about utilitarianism. Also, it relies on a truly wild series of leaps from "people taking anti-anxiety drugs" to "psychopaths" to "rich people". (That older paper linked is setting off all my alarm bells for shitty social psych research. The second one doesn't look promising, but is paywalled. - "We derived the ethics of the rich from an online quiz" is a bad sign. - "We didn't control for education" is a problem in its own right. - PNAS is a bad sign. - 'Neutral primes' versus 'greed is good primes' is a disastrously bad sign, it's not even clear if those things work. - Human-coding of driver behavior is questionable at best. - Deriving human ethics from groups of ~100 Berkeley students is almost cartoonishly bad. My baseline here is "forking paths plus massive bias risks got us a catchy headline".)
- jonbarker 9y agoYou are biased against social psych research, as I think we all should be, but I'm not sure singling it out is the best strategy. The issues of reproducibility and 'p-hacking' among others are a big problem in a variety of disciplines right now, and there is a good synopsis of just one aspect of the problem in hard sciences here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis. For a non-paywall link to the original research this is better: http://www.pnas.org/content/109/11/4086.short http://www.pnas.org/content/109/11/4086.short
- danans 9y ago> those who are trying to make it or work in the 'supporting cast' take BART from oakland or richmond At this point BART or other mass transit access to your workplace is itself a sort of privilege, perhaps not for the tech elite who wouldn't take mass transit anyway, but for rank and file skilled employees. For many of them, mass transit is preferable to hours spent in car traffic. I'm one of those who feels privileged to be able to take BART to work. It's service workers who have often been pushed out beyond the Bay Area into mega commutes.
- Chardok 9y ago"This time around, though, that community will be bridled with union–busting and data-harvesting apparatuses sure to make even the most paranoid techno-tyrant salivate." This is what worries me the most about something like Facebook running the town. I can imagine their Zuck-net would have plenty of mining to flag "potential unionizers" and snuff them out before they have a chance to begin. Unions are really the only answer to balance the corporation's power and I fear they won't stand a chance.
- metaphorm 9y agoHN has a lot of blindspots. This famous quote comes to mind. > It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it. - Upton Sinclair
- apsec112 9y agoThis article's main topic is just "tech companies are building big offices", dressed up in some purple prose. And they're also to blame for high rents. But if they build apartments to help ease the housing shortage, that's a "company town" and we can't have that either. And Amazon is a "commandeering leech" which "suck[s] up our resources and refus[es] to participate in daily upkeep", but when Google offers Mountain View neighborhood benefits, that proves it's "seeking to wrest control of the city from its government". I suppose the next step is to blame the Google buses for being "elitist" and "gentrifying", while in the next paragraph, blaming Google for putting cars on the road and making traffic worse.... “Friedrich Spee von Langenfeld, a priest who heard the confessions of condemned witches, wrote in 1631 the Cautio Criminalis (‘prudence in criminal cases’) in which he bitingly described the decision tree for condemning accused witches: If the witch had led an evil and improper life, she was guilty; if she had led a good and proper life, this too was a proof, for witches dissemble and try to appear especially virtuous. After the woman was put in prison: if she was afraid, this proved her guilt; if she was not afraid, this proved her guilt, for witches characteristically pretend innocence and wear a bold front. Or on hearing of a denunciation of witchcraft against her, she might seek flight or remain; if she ran, that proved her guilt; if she remained, the devil had detained her so she could not get away.”
- mc32 9y agoThese people only know how to tear things down. I don't like FB or even Mark personally. But this is ridiculous and would not unfairly be characterized as sour grapes or simply not wanting progress at all to spite some good careers. Society never moves at the pace of life. It always lags --even in command economies like China's or to a degree S Korea and Singapore. Adjustment takes time. At the same time as you point out, often times it's damned if they do, damned if they don't. It's almost as if they would feel better if FB automated all the jobs away --not just manual labor low hanging fruit, but all jobs so that they would not have anything to blame on FB --except now everyone who used to work for them is now unemployed (presuming much of the industry learns from FB and also automates --in a purposely extreme example)
- countryslicker 9y ago
- moonka 9y agoThe wording makes this really hard to read.
- d_theorist 9y agoYes, it’s annoyingly over-written. Some parts barely even make sense. I also question whether the author knows what the word “capitalism” actually means.
- eru 9y agoAlas, capitalism means many different things to many different people. (As a mildly interesting example of a similar phenomenon: the pro-business libertarian / neo-liberal FDP party in Germany still proudly calls itself 'liberal'.)
- vadym909 9y agoWith an average tenure of < 2 years at these companies now, subsidized housing may force people to stay in companies longer especially if they have families. I'm not sure they can recreate Kodak/Rochester type place as there are so many rich companies vying for the same people.
- ssttoo 9y ago> With an average tenure of < 2 years ... citation needed :)
- mc32 9y agoEven if that were the case if they included temps, contractors, etc. The towns brought that upon themselves due to their aversion to growth and 1960s suburban utopia idyll that remains in their master plans.
- htormey 9y agohttp://www.businessinsider.com/employee-retention-rate-top-tech-companies-2017-8?utm_content=buffer30d08&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer http://www.businessinsider.com/employee-retention-rate-top-t... Matches my experience at FB & Apple. I spent about 2 years at each.
- Houshalter 9y agoOh Lord. A bunch of poor 19th century miners in a remote town is not the same as this at all. These are some of the richest and easily employable workers in the country living in one of the most populated regions. They wouldn't have to do this if the local government wasn't so restrictive either. These companies don't care if their employees own their own homes or not. But unfortunately big companies are the only groups with enough power and resources to push through new housing development.
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, there are a couple responses there. Obviously the mining towns are the most extreme expression of the problem, but is it not reasonable to say you might see smaller echoes of this in the tech companies' case? White-collar workers in general are working longer hours, etc., so I don't think we can say they write all the rules. But perhaps a bigger question is, what about all the people who work at Google or Facebook who are not in-demand engineers? It seems like once you've established the principle it's easier to expand it to less prestigious positions.
- trhway 9y agonews from near-by Google-town: http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/10/02/google-backs-down-from-threat-to-cancel-mountain-view-housing/ http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/10/02/google-backs-down-from... "Google has backed down from a threat to deny badly needed housing in Mountain View if it isn’t given more office space for its futuristic new “Charleston East” campus."
- cybersol 9y agoI for one welcome our new monopolistic overlords. Might I suggest cameras and tracking sensors to further optimize my luxurious company accommodations. /s
- chis 9y agoThe linked anti-union article is more interesting than the original article IMO. http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2013/07/silicon-valleys-anti-unionism-and-class-warfare.html http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2013/07/silicon-valleys... I would tend to agree with the tech-ie opinion that unions are becoming obselete in the US. Unions existed to protect workers who were unskilled and interchangeable; the endgame of tech is to automate all those jobs. But obviously I’m not a labor scholar and this is just an unfounded opinion.
- zdkl 9y agoI very strongly disagree with the "unskilled" part. I am not a labor scholar either, but unions serve to federate common interests of workers who may not individually have leverage against their employer or relevant regulation body. Because your employer in tech can afford to give you a lifestyle easily in the highest couple percentiles doesn't mean you aren't replaceable and that you won't need representation as a class of worker at some point.
- mobiletelephone 9y agoWages are high if the supply of labour is low and the employer has money for wages. If supply is low and the employer does not have money, then the job won't exist. This is why tech workers wouldn't benefit from a union very much.
- zdkl 9y agoCan you elaborate on the relation of your second clause and your conclusion? I'm not seeing how this relates to the role and nature of unions.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIt's not gonna last forever this way. Unions are not very useful for developers now, but you might want to have them already in-place by the time they become needed.
- 9y ago
- rdtsc 9y agoAnd you'd go to Zuckshop and buy Zuckbread: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_store https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_store It would be creepy having to live in a employers' housing unit. But if it is subsidized enough many would jump on it. The interview process at many of these company is already geared to bring in college graduates. So a dorm of sort would make sense. Then they could outfit them work spaces so you could live there and maybe work remotely (but only from a company provided housing unit). How about just letting people work from home to begin with so they don't all have to be crammed into one town or one building so that they can then all type on a computer? It is rather interesting I think these companies sell digital connectivity, collaboration, -- but when it comes to themselves they like to shove everyone into buildings.
- rtpg 9y agoJapan has a lot of this, but it's usually a building in the middle of a city so you're not like... completely surrounded. But your neighbors are probably from the same company.
- mercurysmessage 9y agoCan you expand on this? I've spent a lot of time in Japan, but have never heard of it.
- rtpg 9y agoMany companies have appartments to rent for their employees, especially bigger companies in things like civil engineering. They'll usually let you rent for a super low rate (like $100/month), and though obviously your salary is given with an understanding you'll stay there.
- Apocryphon 9y agoAnd isn't Japanese corporate culture, for all of its repressive and overworked ways, at least compensating its workers with guaranteed lifetime employment, pensions, etc.? Whereas in the U.S. You may be fired at any time.
- z3t4 9y agoLast time I checked, Facebook, Google et.al where not philanthropic organizations. For it to be less evil they should build the houses, then sell the properties, not rent, for below market prices.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoIt's exactly these biggest companies that should take moral responsibility and relocate / redistribute their work to various cities on the one hand, and if they want to go through with the idea of company towns, campuses etc, they need to move way out of the SF area - there's huge wads of unused space in the US, they could found their own city if need be. Probably not something very attractive to their employees, but it is one possible solution; especially if they can build it near SF, with e.g. only a 30 minute hyperloop or maglev train trip required to get to HQ.
- humanrebar 9y ago> Probably not something very attractive to their employees... I keep hearing this meme and I'm skeptical. Far more people live outside the Bay Area than inside it. Are they all poor saps who are waiting to move to Silicon Valley but haven't yet figured out how?
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago> Far more people live outside the Bay Area than inside it. Are they all poor saps who are waiting to move to Silicon Valley but haven't yet figured out how? Usually when people claim that companies should try to recreate Silicon Valley in some cheaper "heartland of America", they are talking about flyover country. And demographically, many people still in flyover country may well be poor saps who haven't yet figured out how to move to the coasts, as statistics show a steady drain of young people to the coasts or at least a few major metropolitan areas in their part of America.
- humanrebar 9y agoOr maybe they're just moving to where the money and career- building jobs are. I think the causality is at least more complex than the aforementioned meme implies.
- pault 9y agoI see this attitude from new yorkers a lot. There are only two types of people: those that live in NY and those that failed to live in NY. Because they aspire to live in a coastal metropolis obviously everyone else does too.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zghst 9y agoSuch lazy, barren journalism. Automatically slanted towards racism, Marxism, and other hot topics of the day. This didn't inform me in any way other than the author's personal agenda.
- emodendroket 9y agoIf you're clicking a link to the Baffler expecting something other than a withering critique of some aspect of modern society it's your own fault. It's not intended to be "journalism" in the sense you mean it.
- emodendroket 9y agoOn a related note, another recent Baffler piece concerning Facebook had some new-to-me information about Facebook helping to enforce blasphemy laws: https://thebaffler.com/salvos/military-messaging-complex-zakaria https://thebaffler.com/salvos/military-messaging-complex-zak...
- ashwinaj 9y agoThis is such a ridiculous impasse. Why don't the authorities do what most sensible countries do i.e. build multi-storied apartments with decent public transportation? Yes I know in the US that equates to the ghetto/projects/low income housing (which is a mindset that needs to change). As far as the bay area goes this is possible since most residents are foreigners or 1st and 2nd generation Americans who are probably more open to the idea of living in a skyscraper.
- yahna 9y agoMaybe instead of complaining about how facebook and google have the made the area popular, you should take aim at the entrenched owners who refuse to allow higher density housing to actually relieve the pressure on the market.