3 ms·
My personal data is an asset. And it belongs to me. Anyone who has my data for any purpose owes me my cut. Making this a property rights issue solves all the
by specialist 9y ago
My personal data is an asset. And it belongs to me.
Anyone who has my data for any purpose owes me my cut.
Making this a property rights issue solves all the privacy & identity issues.
- grigjd3 9y agoYou agree to give up your data in return for services. Yahoo mail, or gmail for that matter aren't actually free. You are trading your data for a service.
- specialist 9y agoNo contract may take away a person's rights.
- abraae 9y agoOn the contrary, it is commonplace for contracts to take away your rights. A common example is an arbitration clause, where you sign away your rights to use the courts to resolve disputes.
- ben_w 9y agoSome rights, but not all rights. You cannot (in any country I am aware of) contract away your right to life, nor turn yourself into a slave in exchange for your debts being forgiven. The latter used to be possible, if I understand serfdom correctly. Question is, should data rights be alienable or inalienable?
- specialist 9y agoThank you for articulating, explaining stuff better than I can.
- grigjd3 9y agoIf you're talking about what rights you should have, that's fine. Currently, however, there is no defined right in the US such that service providers like google, Facebook, etc can't make use of the data they acquire from you. If you consider data on you to be more valuable than the service provided, don't use the service.
- closeparen 9y agoI don't understand. You believe you have the right to have no records of yourself written anywhere. You believe it is impossible to contract away this right. You've given HN an individual identifier for yourself, and also furnished your political views (a specially protected category under the GDPR) to its database. Aren't all your comments proof of Y Combinator's human rights violation against you? Shall we have HN shut down and its operators jailed? Obviously this isn't the world we live in, but isn't it the one you're arguing for? Maybe you can't give permission to have data treated carelessly, but it seems absurd to say you can't give permission to have data collected at all. Opening an account with Yahoo is surely consent to let Yahoo have a record of that account.
- specialist 9y agoGuessing you don't support the right to be forgotten.
- closeparen 9y agoNo, the "right" to edit other people's memories and disappear information from the public domain is the dystopian hellscape on the first page of 1984.
- throwaway613834 9y ago> My personal data is an asset. And it belongs to me. Hm. How would this work for (say) a social security number? Does it belong to you? Does every number anyone chooses to identify you belong to you?
- specialist 9y agoAny non government entity storing data about me (PII and beyond) can only do so with my (revokable) permission and owes me my cut.
- mkempe 9y agoIn Switzerland, anyone collecting data about other people must make a public declaration of that collection, and may not keep such records about people who disagree with being thus documented ("fiché").
- beefhash 9y agoFor the curious: There's an English translation of the Federal Act on Data Protection. https://www.admin.ch/opc/en/classified-compilation/19920153/index.html https://www.admin.ch/opc/en/classified-compilation/19920153/...
- ben_w 9y agoThere is a similar law in the UK: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Act_1998 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Act_1998 Which itself is based on an EU directive: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Directive https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Directive This is to be replaced with an updated version between now and Brexit (that’s just going to add to the fun!): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regulation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regu...
- dpark 9y ago> My personal data is an asset. And it belongs to me. > Anyone who has my data for any purpose owes me my cut. It's well established in the US that you do not in fact own your data. You don't own your school records or employment records. You don't own your medical records or your credit records. In general the best you have is a right to view those records and that's only in certain cases.
- specialist 9y agoBecause Freedom Markets™?
- dpark 9y agoPretty sure it's the same across the world, really. Try getting your medical records expunged in Cuba or your search records expunged in China. I bet you have the same success as in the US.
- mkempe 9y agoMaybe you should look at free people in mostly free countries, instead of dictatorships. For instance, the EU and Switzerland.
- dpark 9y agoHave you successfully gotten Google or Facebook or your doctor to purge your records in Switzerland?
- specialist 9y agoAre you suggesting some corporations have become more powerful than our lawfully elected governments?
- dpark 9y agoI’m suggesting that “data about you” is not the same as “your data” and never has been.
- krapp 9y agoDoes it really belong to you if you have no control over it?
- specialist 9y agoSo you do understand.
- ajdlinux 9y agoI'm torn between liking this view of personal data as property and also liking the view of Richard Stallman and the FSF that "intellectual property" is a legal fiction that we ought to resist. What does it actually mean to "own" data, and is "property" the best metaphor to represent a set of personal data control rights?
- specialist 9y agoI hear ya. Pinko commie liberal me abhors the idea. Legal fictions like "property", "money", and "rights" are practical innovations that make society work better (eg more moral, greater public good). Kinda like the tech tree in games like Civilization. The books "The Mystery of Capital" and "Nonzero" influenced me a lot. Good starting points, optimistic, and more right than wrong. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hernando_de_Soto_Polar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hernando_de_Soto_Polar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Wright_(journalist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Wright_(journalist) Until something better comes along...
- ajdlinux 9y agoRMS' objection to "intellectual property" isn't an objection to the concept of property in general, but rather an objection to conflating the rights that are associated with tangible property with the rights that are granted by copyright law and patent law. The canonical example is the language of "theft" used by organisations like the MPAA to refer to copyright infringement - RMS would say that illegally copying a copyrighted work doesn't deprive anyone else of their copy of said work, unlike stealing a sandwich from someone. RMS might disagree with me here, but I think the same thing can be said in this case - we need more precise terminology that accurately describes the types of infringement when it comes to misuse of PII.
- closeparen 9y agoOkay? People signed up for Yahoo accounts so that Yahoo could provide them email, messaging, fantasy sports, and other account-based webapps. How is their possession of the records of those accounts some kind of property crime? This isn't Equifax. I'd buy a negligence argument, but there's no much to find fault with regarding possession.