3 ms·
Does everyone really need an unique digital identifier? My feeling is, "this is probably you" is good enough for nearly every transaction people will perform.
by mywittyname 9y ago
Does everyone really need an unique digital identifier?
My feeling is, "this is probably you" is good enough for nearly every transaction people will perform. And we've long had a system in place to deal with the special cases in which this is not good enough: notaries.
Financial companies need to come to terms with this fact and accept insurance against its exploitation as a cost of doing business.
For taxes and other government documents, we should all move to a tax id system, like businesses use.
- dredmorbius 9y agoAbsolutely not for each and every transaction. There are a certain set of activities for which a 1:1 association is highly preferable, though voting is about the most extreme case. For various reasons, there are both problems with trying to create a voter-ID system, political resistance to this, and relatively limited call to do so in the first place (in-person fraud is expensive, risks elsehere are far greater). Much of the remaining argument revolves around credit and risk, and around advertising and tracking. I'd argue that the first does not require single-ID tracking, and the second should under no circumstances be allowed to institute it. Much of the remaining space is national accounts types stuff: tax, pension, and medical authorities, passport/border control, some licensing (much of that at the state/local level). But yes, at the national level, there is a call for 1:1 account assignments, though those need not be unified across all services.