6 ms·
User accounts? Really? This is Yahoo we’re talking about. You really do need user accounts to run an email service
by closeparen 9y ago
User accounts? Really? This is Yahoo we’re talking about. You really do need user accounts to run an email service
- tambienben 9y agoHow much do you actually need to know about someone to serve up email to them?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- osteele 9y agoFor a consumer mail service, you to need to know enough to let them recover their account, possibly with decades of un-backed-up correspondence with and photos of since-deceased friends and relatives, when they’ve forgotten their password, and without letting someone else recover their account. This is a hard problem. (I’m expecting some idealized “solutions” from people with idealized beliefs about mass market tech skills.)
- Karunamon 9y agoYou also need a process for resolving ownership disputes. Facebook takes the tactic of having the person claiming ownership upload government-issued ID, which seems like it would be the only foolproof way to do so, yet they're constantly maligned for it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nameless912 9y agoWhy don't we just <incredibly naive solution that does nothing to help, but somehow also involves the blockchain>?
- tambienben 9y agoMost sites solve this problem with a combination of 2fA and at least one security question. Having my phone number isn't even good 2fA.
- abraae 9y agoThis is such a nasty area, with such crappy solutions (name of your first pet), that it should become a service all of its own. i.e. when I sign up with you, I can choose my own preferred vendor to handle identity recovery.
- closeparen 9y agoYou almost certainly need a password hash, and that’s (as I understand it) the main privacy worry related to the Yahoo breach.
- freeflight 9y ago> You really do need user accounts to run an email service Exactly, regardless of that companies keep asking users for a whole collection of personal data, not always making it obvious which fields are actually required because it's good business for them to get as much personal data as possible. Average users are usually unsure about a lot of this stuff and naive enough to enter their real data for fear of getting caught "lying". This happens because companies see this data as an asset instead of a liability, from the companies view not asking for that data/tricking users into giving it away means missing out on assets. But if you instead make the personal data a liability, by enforcing standards for keeping/sharing it with hefty fines, then fewer companies will go out of their way asking users for personal information they have no business asking for in the first place because it would put them in a position of liability for what happens with said data.
- throwaway613834 9y ago>> User accounts? Really? This is Yahoo we’re talking about. You really do need user accounts to run an email service > Exactly, regardless of that companies keep asking users for a whole collection of personal data, not always making it obvious which fields are actually required You literally don't need any user information to run an email service. You only need a means to identify them which could just amount to giving them a long, randomly generated password. Even the username is only necessary for the purpose of being able to identify them as a recipient, not for login itself.
- layble 9y agoA free email service.
- rightos 9y agoSure, but you don't need first name, last name, phone number, birth date or gender. All of which are asked on the signup and of which only Gender is specified as optional: https://login.yahoo.com/account/create https://login.yahoo.com/account/create On my small business we ask only for an email address, password and confirm password. Everything else is excessive. Tax obligations can be another problem which may require an address, but often have a simpler way to resolve them by simply picking the appropriate country and state off a list or even with just a checkbox for "are you in X jurisdiction which I am required to tax?". I believe Tarsnap handles it that way.
- noway421 9y agoFirst and last name at least needed for meet the email protocol. Emails shouldn't be addressed to handles/nicknames
- rightos 9y ago"username <username@yahoo.com>" is perfectly valid in SMTP last I checked. If it's a user experience thing, fine, but at least make it an optional field.
- stevekemp 9y agoThe irony of that comment being made from an account with a username that doesn't clearly identify a person..
- zentiggr 9y agoDeliberate sarcasm?
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoHow would you handle all the people with identical names? Even if you used DoB, there is a chance for a duplicate.
- cbr 9y agoYou need to collect date of birth for COPPA compliance