10 ms·
I think the issue right now is that private user information is viewed as an asset, not a liability. If we could find a way to make it more of a liability, comp
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
I think the issue right now is that private user information is viewed as an asset, not a liability. If we could find a way to make it more of a liability, companies would be less likely to collect it just for the sake of having it, and they would be more proactive in securing it.
- closeparen 9y agoUser accounts? Really? This is Yahoo we’re talking about. You really do need user accounts to run an email service
- tambienben 9y agoHow much do you actually need to know about someone to serve up email to them?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- osteele 9y agoFor a consumer mail service, you to need to know enough to let them recover their account, possibly with decades of un-backed-up correspondence with and photos of since-deceased friends and relatives, when they’ve forgotten their password, and without letting someone else recover their account. This is a hard problem. (I’m expecting some idealized “solutions” from people with idealized beliefs about mass market tech skills.)
- Karunamon 9y agoYou also need a process for resolving ownership disputes. Facebook takes the tactic of having the person claiming ownership upload government-issued ID, which seems like it would be the only foolproof way to do so, yet they're constantly maligned for it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nameless912 9y agoWhy don't we just <incredibly naive solution that does nothing to help, but somehow also involves the blockchain>?
- tambienben 9y agoMost sites solve this problem with a combination of 2fA and at least one security question. Having my phone number isn't even good 2fA.
- abraae 9y agoThis is such a nasty area, with such crappy solutions (name of your first pet), that it should become a service all of its own. i.e. when I sign up with you, I can choose my own preferred vendor to handle identity recovery.
- closeparen 9y agoYou almost certainly need a password hash, and that’s (as I understand it) the main privacy worry related to the Yahoo breach.
- freeflight 9y ago> You really do need user accounts to run an email service Exactly, regardless of that companies keep asking users for a whole collection of personal data, not always making it obvious which fields are actually required because it's good business for them to get as much personal data as possible. Average users are usually unsure about a lot of this stuff and naive enough to enter their real data for fear of getting caught "lying". This happens because companies see this data as an asset instead of a liability, from the companies view not asking for that data/tricking users into giving it away means missing out on assets. But if you instead make the personal data a liability, by enforcing standards for keeping/sharing it with hefty fines, then fewer companies will go out of their way asking users for personal information they have no business asking for in the first place because it would put them in a position of liability for what happens with said data.
- throwaway613834 9y ago>> User accounts? Really? This is Yahoo we’re talking about. You really do need user accounts to run an email service > Exactly, regardless of that companies keep asking users for a whole collection of personal data, not always making it obvious which fields are actually required You literally don't need any user information to run an email service. You only need a means to identify them which could just amount to giving them a long, randomly generated password. Even the username is only necessary for the purpose of being able to identify them as a recipient, not for login itself.
- layble 9y agoA free email service.
- rightos 9y agoSure, but you don't need first name, last name, phone number, birth date or gender. All of which are asked on the signup and of which only Gender is specified as optional: https://login.yahoo.com/account/create https://login.yahoo.com/account/create On my small business we ask only for an email address, password and confirm password. Everything else is excessive. Tax obligations can be another problem which may require an address, but often have a simpler way to resolve them by simply picking the appropriate country and state off a list or even with just a checkbox for "are you in X jurisdiction which I am required to tax?". I believe Tarsnap handles it that way.
- noway421 9y agoFirst and last name at least needed for meet the email protocol. Emails shouldn't be addressed to handles/nicknames
- rightos 9y ago"username <username@yahoo.com>" is perfectly valid in SMTP last I checked. If it's a user experience thing, fine, but at least make it an optional field.
- stevekemp 9y agoThe irony of that comment being made from an account with a username that doesn't clearly identify a person..
- zentiggr 9y agoDeliberate sarcasm?
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoHow would you handle all the people with identical names? Even if you used DoB, there is a chance for a duplicate.
- cbr 9y agoYou need to collect date of birth for COPPA compliance
- avivo 9y agoAlternatively, if it's truly an asset, can it be taxed as an asset? If I give a company a car, that is taxed. If I give a company my data which is worth more than a car, it isn't. Is it possible that current accounting/tax law can be interpreted so that these are viewed similarly?
- fny 9y agoUsing the black market as a standard, your identity-related information isn't worth enough to be taxable.[0][1][2] The more common data you give away is worth even less. Your "gift" is akin to giving away a few grains of sand to a glassmaker who provides a free grain counting service. Now let's say you dumped a lot sand that we could value at $10K. Any smart sand-counting glassmaker will claim his once "free" sand counting costs $10K, which amounts to an equal, zero-profit trade. [0]: http://www.bankrate.com/finance/credit/what-your-identity-is-worth-on-black-market.aspx http://www.bankrate.com/finance/credit/what-your-identity-is... [1]: https://qz.com/460482/heres-what-your-stolen-identity-goes-for-on-the-internets-black-market/ https://qz.com/460482/heres-what-your-stolen-identity-goes-f... [2]: http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-how-much-your-personal-data-costs-on-the-dark-web-2015-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-how-much-your-personal-...
- bendews 9y agoIt is when you have 3B records
- fny 9y agoIf one company sells anything to another company, that sale is taxed as income like any other sale. So yes, if Yahoo sold 3B records, that would be taxed, and the recipient company can choose to book that purchase as an asset on their balance sheet and will likely expense the purchase. Hell they could even choose to depreciate the value too for as long as they follow GAAP. OP mentioned his data alone, which isn't worth squat unless the transaction says otherwise. Meaning, if OP sold his data to a company for a taxable amount, he would be taxed on that income.
- bluetwo 9y agoSure, I like the thinking. In theory some of these costs will hit the errors and omissions insurance, which will drive up their costs in the long run (I know they are being absorbed by Verizon, but typically...). In turn part of the insurance evaluation would they assess the collection of the data as a risk as well as their track records in keeping it secure.
- mtgx 9y agoI believe EU's GDPR made some efforts in that direction, but I'm not sure it went far enough. We need laws that give companies incentive to store very little data on us outside of what's absolutely required for the functioning of the service. And if they do store additional info, and their servers are breached, then automatic hefty fines should be paid (right after the mandatory notification to authorities and the public). That should encourage companies to either minimize data collection or use end-to-end encryption, where most of that additional data would be stored on the client's device. This would have to exempt them from liability, and it should since the data wouldn't be on their servers if breached.
- pilsetnieks 9y agoI was about to mention the GDPR - it definitely is a step in the right direction. I don't think that it doesn't go far enough - compared to previous regulations, it is quite severe, and it already is a pain to implement as it is. If it went any further, many companies would probably not even bother and somehow do their business outside the EU, or just prepare to be fined > if they do store additional info, and their servers are breached, then automatic hefty fines should be paid (right after the mandatory notification to authorities and the public). This is already in the GDPR - you have to notify everyone affected about breaches, and the fines can go up to 20 million or 4% of annual turnover, whichever is greater.
- dx034 9y agoGDPR already does more than any existing law in either US or Europe (not sure about other countries). As every law it will be reviewed and can be made stricter. Changes are likely needed anyway as companies try to circumvent the directive with "creative" ways or incentives for users to give up privacy. But it's a huge step forward compared to the existing situation.
- natural219 9y agoI reached this same conclusion from a very different angle. If you're seriously worried about the unchecked power of monopolies, and understand the effects of Metcalfe's law, we should measure the degree of monopolization of tech companies differently than we do traditional industries. Businesses are locked in to Facebook and Google the same way that businesses were locked in to doing business with Standard Oil in the gilded age. The impossibility for regular users to leave the network makes competition de facto impossible, even if the company does not actively engage in anti-competitive behavior (in many cases, they do anyway). A tax on social software companies proportional to their network size would be an interesting proposal to solve both of these issues. It would also greatly increase the ability for 100,000 - 1,000,000 person "decentralized" social networks (like Mastodon or other competing networks) to thrive.
- specialist 9y agoMy personal data is an asset. And it belongs to me. Anyone who has my data for any purpose owes me my cut. Making this a property rights issue solves all the privacy & identity issues.
- grigjd3 9y agoYou agree to give up your data in return for services. Yahoo mail, or gmail for that matter aren't actually free. You are trading your data for a service.
- specialist 9y agoNo contract may take away a person's rights.
- abraae 9y agoOn the contrary, it is commonplace for contracts to take away your rights. A common example is an arbitration clause, where you sign away your rights to use the courts to resolve disputes.
- ben_w 9y agoSome rights, but not all rights. You cannot (in any country I am aware of) contract away your right to life, nor turn yourself into a slave in exchange for your debts being forgiven. The latter used to be possible, if I understand serfdom correctly. Question is, should data rights be alienable or inalienable?
- specialist 9y agoThank you for articulating, explaining stuff better than I can.
- grigjd3 9y ago
- ctab 9y agoThis could be a voluntary insurance that companies purchase on behalf of their users. If the company suffers a breach, they will be bound to pay X amount to their users depending on the data lost. Dress it up with a fancy badge to slap on the front of their site. Maybe a silver badge means user data is insured up to $10 each; a gold badge is up to $100; platinum up to $1000.
- dpark 9y agoSo Yahoo would have been insured for somewhere between $30 Billion and $3 Trillion in this scheme? That seems untenable. Good luck collecting from the bankrupt insurer.
- ctab 9y agoGood point, although the report states 3 billion user accounts were breached but this doesn't mean 3 billion people. I am guessing the vast majority of accounts did not contain any sensitive information. And maybe insurance isn't the right word; the risk should probably fall to the company holding the data, not a third party who would never be able to audit every single step to ensure there is no weak link.
- dpark 9y agoTrue, it wouldn't be 3 billion individuals claiming the benefit. Still the scale is so large that it would utterly bankrupt most companies to pay out for a single breach.
- hehheh 9y agoIf the cost of disclosure was a dollar a user there's pretty much no way we'd see them voluntarily tell us they were hacked. We'd have to wait until the information got out some other way.
- zentiggr 9y agoNot a perfect solution, but sure. "You're the weakest link - goodbye!" <everyone else flinches and reviews infosec>
- Jass_ack 9y agoSomeone somewhere is going to get rich
- bparsons 9y agoThis is how the civil legal system is supposed to function. There needs to be some very large class action lawsuits brought against these companies, and huge awards need to be extracted in order increase the financial risk of having shitty infosec.
- koheripbal 9y agoFor PCI Compliance purposes, at least, holding user credit card information is already seen as a liability because maintaining compliance is a cost center. That's why there's been some shift towards tokenizing transactions on the fly and directly submitting to the CC company via javascript so that shopping websites never see your CC number even when you enter it on their website - even if you're scheduling future payments. Maybe we should include other data elements under PCI or similar regulations. SSN? I imagine HIPAA has similar requirements and associated costs.
- bparsons 9y agoEven just a fragment of someone's personal information can be combined with other data points in order to commit identity theft. Other impacts may not have direct monetary damages, but could be even more devastating (ie Ashley Madison). Until the courts start clamping down on negligent handling of personal data, firms will continue to cheap out on infosec.