3 ms·
The restriction is on copyright. If a cancer cure is published in Nature then I can take the facts from it and publish it. Copyright does not apply to facts. Ot
by eesmith 9y ago
The restriction is on copyright. If a cancer cure is published in Nature then I can take the facts from it and publish it. Copyright does not apply to facts. Others can then use my publication for their own treatments, without access the original paper.
To get to your question of "public interest", one argument for Sci-Hub is precisely that:
> In her defense Alexandra Elbakyan has cited Article 27 (1.) of the UN Declaration of Human Rights "to share in scientific advancement and its benefits",
It's very unlikely that it would work in the US. I think issues related copyright ownership of scientific publications was resolved 40 or so years ago. I vaguely recall it was coupled with changed to the Copyright Act of 1976.
At the very least, that's about the time you start seeing explicit copyright statements appearing in scientific publications.
- xvilka 9y agoToo much money on stake. Publishers will surely bribe or apply pressure somehow to the judges, or anyone on their way.