4 ms·
> "What chemicals that act like estrogens are in my public water, and in what dose?" I'm not sure that's a good example. Is that information actually in the p
by eesmith 9y ago
> "What chemicals that act like estrogens are in my public water, and in what dose?"
I'm not sure that's a good example.
Is that information actually in the peer-reviewed literature? I tried looking for those numbers for Tallahassee, FL but failed miserably.
I did find https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2854760/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2854760/ which says "Predicted concentrations in drinking water were used instead of measured concentrations because few studies have measured estrogen concentrations in U.S. drinking water, and those that are available report primarily nondetected concentrations [see Supplemental Material, available online (doi:10.1289/ehp.0900654.S1 via http://dx.doi.org/); http://dx.doi.org/); see also Hannah et al. 2009]."
The supplemental information says "The consistently large MOEs and MOSs strongly suggest that prescribed and total estrogens that may potentially be present in drinking water in the United States are not causing adverse effects in U.S. residents, including sensitive subpopulations."
So that's one answer. Why go further (assuming you trust it)?
Of course, that's for estrogens, not the wider category of "chemicals that act like estrogens", but 1) what do you mean by that phrase?, and 2) is anyone measuring these values for every water system?
Public water systems do measure some values. I believe they are required to publish a report every year. Here's the recent one for Tallahassee https://www.talgov.com/Uploads/Public/Documents/you/learn/library/documents/wqr.pdf https://www.talgov.com/Uploads/Public/Documents/you/learn/li... . You'll note they don't measure the potentially large number of chemicals you mention. There are people that measure concentration levels of possible hormone disruptors, but as far as I can tell these are spot checks, and not done at a system-wide level that someone could simply look up in a published paper.
In any case, that sort of reporting information doesn't go into the scientific literature, but rather into a scientific database. Here's one, for example: https://www.waterqualitydata.us https://www.waterqualitydata.us .
I can be wrong. Which $45 paper will tell me the answer to your question, for the public water system in Tallahassee?
- fludlight 9y agoTake your $45 and send a sample of your tap water to a water testing lab that mentions the word "estrogens" on their website.
- eesmith 9y agoI looked. I didn't find any local water testing lab with "estrogens" on their website. I found a water treatment company trying to sell RO and other point-of-use systems which had pointers to reports about hormones, pharmaceuticals, and other contaminants in the water, but they don't offer estrogen testing. FWIW, $45 at http://www.ackuritlabs.com/residential-testing/residential-analysis-packages/ http://www.ackuritlabs.com/residential-testing/residential-a... gives me either an E. coli survey or a filter survey for iron, pH, tannins, hardness, and turbidity. Perhaps you can do better than I did?
- fludlight 9y agoI found a reputable company that makes a ~$1k commercial scale kit in case you want to start a testing business[1]. Also a DIY scientific discussion that goes over my head[2]. Maybe give a random water testing lab a call? If that doesn't work try calling a non-corporate medical lab. [1] https://www.thermofisher.com/us/en/home/industrial/mass-spectrometry/liquid-chromatography-mass-spectrometry-lc-ms/lc-ms-systems/lc-ms-application-solutions/lc-ms-hormone-testing-kit-water.html https://www.thermofisher.com/us/en/home/industrial/mass-spec... [2] https://www.researchgate.net/post/Is_there_a_solid_laboratory_test_that_exists_to_test_for_endocrine_disruptors_in_water_samples_taken_from_streams https://www.researchgate.net/post/Is_there_a_solid_laborator...
- eesmith 9y agoThis is far away from the point of my response, which is that the original scenario is not a good justification for something like sci-hub. Regarding the testing, I was only looking at local Tallahassee water testing companies. This was an overly strict restriction of mine. The OP has not yet clarified what "chemicals that act like estrogens" means, so it's possible that [1] of yours may be too limited in what it tests for. FWIW, your [1] does not include the "Thermo Scientific Ultimate™ 3000/TSQ Vantage™ LC-MS/MS", with which it's designed to work. I am unable to find a price for that, but it looks expensive. As I've no problem with the statement "The consistently large MOEs and MOSs strongly suggest that prescribed and total estrogens that may potentially be present in drinking water in the United States are not causing adverse effects in U.S. residents, including sensitive subpopulations.", I will not be starting a testing business, as the temptation to market to fear is too high.
- alexandercrohde 9y agoSo a lot of chemicals act like estrogens in the body (i.e. many endocrine disruptors) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xenoestrogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xenoestrogen, they are absolutely in your water, it's really a question of dose. For example, the Xenoestrogen Bisphenol A is in the water, but water only account for 3% of your average bisphenol A exposure (plus it's in the air too, kicker). But that's just technical details. The point is, without access to these articles a consumer cannot even make informed decisions on the most basic health choices.