4 ms·
>“You can’t just walk into somebody’s home and take them!” Belshe told her. >Parks responded calmly, “It’s legal. It’s legal.” Years ago in college, my friend
by komali2 9y ago
>“You can’t just walk into somebody’s home and take them!” Belshe told her.
>Parks responded calmly, “It’s legal. It’s legal.”
Years ago in college, my friend was depressed, and as a coping mechanism would sometimes write suicide notes. He'd read them and realize he wasn't quite at that point and it would help him get along. It was a process.
Anyway, somehow some of his notes were discovered, he was arrested (I still don't know the details here) and put into some weird absurd protective custody thing in a psychiatric hospital. I was allowed to see him exactly once. The one time I managed to get in he looked like shit. Bags under the eyes, light gone, just, hollow. He said they forced him to take these anti anxiety meds that make him feel like a zombie, that if he didn't take them and admit he needed medication, they wouldn't let him out. But he wasn't "earnest" enough about his treatment and so he still couldn't get out of that hellscape.
After about ten days of being unable to contact him, being stonewalled by the cops and the doctors (working with his parents, who were out of state and just as confused/frustrated), I completely snapped. I loaded my remington and 2 boxes of shells into my truck and was planning on driving straight into the lobby of the hospital and forcefully removing him. I was furious but remember having a clear plan - wasn't going to shoot anyone, figured the truck through the lobby plus a crazy fucker in a mask with a shotgun would force their hand and let him go and then we'd drive to mexico or some shit. Consequences be damned, silly fucking laws be damned, I was getting my friend out. I was tossing my gunbag into the back when I got a call on my cell from him saying he finally got out and needed a ride.
God only knows if I had gone through with it, maybe I would have come to my senses in the parking lot, I can only hope. All I know is that there was nothing more frustrating or infuriating I have ever experienced than watching him go through it and being completely stonewalled. I've had friends go to jail and I've gone to jail and that's fair, that makes sense. There's a process. There's bail. You broke a written rule and you spend some time for it. You get to talk to a judge. The judge gives you rules and you follow them and you get out.
But where he was, there was no rules. You are in at the whim of the doctor and you get out at the whim of the doctor.
I imagine the daughter felt something very similar here - where's the process? Who's the authority? Where are the rules written down and when did she agree to them? How could that daughter have protected herself and her family from some absurd hidden legalese?
- gertef 9y agoNot to disparage your suffering at all, but jail isn't always so much better. > you broke a written rule and you spend some time for it. Not true. Jail is for people accused of breaking rules, not convicted. And arrests are severely biased against certain subpopulations. > The judge gives you rules and you follow them and you get out. which generally involve sitting in jail because you can't afford bail, with a nontrivial chance of losing your job due to absence, then losing your home due to poverty. Don't argue which injustice is worse. Fight the injustice. https://brooklynbailfund.org/ https://brooklynbailfund.org/
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Jail is for people accused of breaking rules, not convicted While you make some good points, you are confusing “jail” with “pretrial detention”; while much (but not all) pre-trial detention is done in jails, that's not the only thing jails are used for; people do serve post-conviction sentences in jails, too.
- logfromblammo 9y agoMisdemeanor convictions (i.e. less than a year of incarceration) may be served in a jail. Felony terms are served in prisons. I am not very familiar with this, and it probably varies by state.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Misdemeanor convictions (i.e. less than a year of incarceration) may be served in a jail. Felony terms are served in prisons. That's a common but not universal rule; California, for instance, sends felons whose crime is not a violent or serious felony, or one that requires sex offender registration, to county jails.