4 ms·
Now perhaps we can start work on prostate cancer. Not as marketable a topic as prostate cancer. Breast cancer receives half a billion dollars more funding for
by FireBeyond 9y ago
Now perhaps we can start work on prostate cancer. Not as marketable a topic as prostate cancer.
Breast cancer receives half a billion dollars more funding for research than does the latter, despite the latter being more common: http://dailycaller.com/2010/10/05/breast-cancer-receives-much-more-research-funding-publicity-than-prostate-cancer-despite-similar-number-of-victims/ http://dailycaller.com/2010/10/05/breast-cancer-receives-muc...
I'm loathe to link to the Daily Caller, but it's a pretty neutral piece with no politics, nonetheless:
https://prostate.org.nz/2014/01/men-die-earlier-womens-health-gets-four-times-funding/ https://prostate.org.nz/2014/01/men-die-earlier-womens-healt...
- paulpauper 9y agobut the prognosis for prostate cancer is very good though (except for African Americans, in which it is markedly lower). How about lung, pancreas, esophagus, and stomach cancer But perhaps more research for breast cancer will lead to better treatments for all cancers , even if the focus on one cancer is excessive
- chowyuncat 9y agoIsn't this because prostate cancer is already far less deadly at this point? Both by rate and absolute numbers. Most men will get prostate cancer if they live long enough and we are constantly improving treatment.
- vkou 9y agoAnd more importantly, most men with prostate cancer will die of something that isn't prostate cancer.
- j_s 9y agoNot to derail the entire discussion, but what is the current best practices regarding treatment for prostate cancer? Is there anywhere to keep up-to-date on this specific topic, if it is indeed nearly inevitable?
- Ibethewalrus 9y agoread somewhere tomatoes buy my mind might be cloudy matey, also stimulate your... that's advice from my fam
- aurelianito 9y agoA dead sibling post mentioned tomatoes. It is apparently supported by some research but seems to be not conclusive. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23883692 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23883692
- bsder 9y agoSure, prostate cancer doesn't get you, but complications from urinary tract infections and complications from incontinence are just as deadly.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> Most men will get prostate cancer if they live long enough That's an understatement. According to my mother's medical school teachers, all men get prostate cancer, but it develops pretty slowly.
- stewbrew 9y agoThe problem here is overtreatment. As a male, you'll sooner or later most likely get prostate cancer. Most men die before it becomes a problem though.
- xenadu02 9y agoYour post is an example of a phenomenon known as what-about-the-men-ism. It is nearly inevitable that any article, tweet, etc that discusses women's issues will get one or more replies essentially asking "... but what about the men?" Honest question: If this were an article about leukemia death rates would you have posted about prostate cancer? Most people wouldn't because it wouldn't be relevant to the article. The only way I can see this topic being relevant is if you believe in "battle of the sexes" theories or think men are systematically victimized by society (we aren't) and want to point out this as an example. I don't know if you believe in either of those things or if you have a different explanation? Linking to DC implies an agenda but based on the principle of charity I will assume you just weren't thinking about the implications when you posted this. There are several reasons prostate cancer doesn't get the same attention as breast cancer. 1. Fewer high-profile people organizing around it and starting foundations to study it. You may wish the world worked on a slightly more utilitarian scale where we distributed medical research resources fairly according to need and impact. The reality is the squeaky wheel gets the grease. 2. Prostate cancer isn't nearly as squeaky of a wheel: a) men who get it usually get it later in life compared to women who get breast cancer. Dying at 45 of cancer is a tragedy. Dying at 75 of cancer is a day that ends in Y. b) most forms of prostate cancer are slower-growing and less metastatic; as a result even men who get it often choose not to get treatment and end up dying of heart failure or other ailments before the prostate cancer has any negative effects. In the US, the 5-year survival rate for prostate cancer diagnosis is 99%. I'm glad research is being done on prostate cancer and breast cancer at the same time; I don't see any need for an "equal" funding principle. If such rules did exist it would have to be based on # of affected people and life-expectancy. Under such a system prostate cancer would probably rank as over-funded right now.
- d33 9y agoDo you have data to back up the claims that a) prostate cancer and its consequences kill less people than breast cancer and b) that men aren't systematically victimized by society? For the latter, I'd say that this topic is inherently sex-specific and thus in a way, has to be sexist. Obviously we wouldn't be talking about prostate cancer if it was leukemia, but it is not. Discussing the survival rates across genders is a legitimate topic and it might turn out that men at more danger - apart from prostate cancer, keep in mind that men commit much more suicides [1], usually take much riskier jobs and in some countries are forced to participate in the army. As a source, I would recommend The Red Pill movie by Cassie Jaye - a woman who called herself feminist until she actually researched what masculism is about. Also, it doesn't have to be a "battle of the sexes" as you put it. Working on male health does not mean stopping research on female health - it's just that prostate cancer definitely isn't getting enough exposure. It would be great if we learned to acknowledge that we can fight for our gender's rights without shouting how the other one oppresses us. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_differences_in_suicide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_differences_in_suicide