4 ms·
This is one of the most infuriating things I've read in a while. How did our legal system end up i this quagmire?
by EGreg 9y ago
This is one of the most infuriating things I've read in a while. How did our legal system end up i this quagmire?
- jmcgough 9y agoI had to stop reading after a bit, I got so upset. Completely unbelievable that this could happen to someone.
- mschuster91 9y agoMe too. But, on the other hand, I am not too surprised given that civil forfeiture is legal in the US...
- code_duck 9y agoAnd it took at least 30 years for the media to start meaningfully questioning that practice.
- mschuster91 9y agoI believe this is because it was used correctly (i.e. confiscating the actual profits of criminals), and started to be abused after (decades of) systematic under-funding of police departments.
- code_duck 9y agoThe entire way that it works - giving police a direct, personal financial incentive to confiscate personal property with no due process, arrest or official accusation of a crime - is clearly problematic. I personally experienced and witnessed systematic, flagrant abuse of forfeiture in the late 90s in a small US state. The officers involved said they were especially interested if someone could help them locate cash rather than drugs, because they got to split it all vs. only being paid for a percentage of the drugs.
- KekDemaga 9y agoA quick note, civil forfeiture is clearly illegal under the fourth amendment but courts have moved from a literal interpretation of law to a "the law means what I think it should mean in my better wisdom"* interpretation in regards to the constitution. * See local and state firearms prohibitions, wiretapping by the NSA, title nine sexual assault courts, presidents declaring war without congressional approval, paris accord agreement without congressional approval and many other examples.
- code_duck 9y agoGood question. It is the same system that would happily take children from the parents who were caught with a small amount of marijuana and hand them over to a serial sexual abuser, so the problem is not limited to elderly.
- gertef 9y agoScams and survival of he fittest are the state of nature. It's a miracle the legal system is able to resist it even a little.
- zanny 9y agoPoliticians are not held accountable for the laws they sponsor or vote for. There is no limit on the degree laws are written to obfuscate intent / meaning or to prevent pork-barreling. Every politician is after campaign dollars to get reelected. Combine that with how the elderly are often sitting on sizable wealth while basically "giving up" on fighting battles people drag them into, and for the past several decades there has been endless lobbying by predatory sociopaths to align the law to enable this kind of behavior, because stealing money from retirees is a very easy crime to commit since they are much less likely to fight against their robbers. Its the exact same kind of predation that produces such vile amoral policy leaps as "think of the children" turning into prescribing Adderall to every other child because they are all "hyper" while making lovely profits for the doctors and producers involved, or how "tough on crime" becomes mass incarceration of nonviolent citizens for possessing a plant where they can make private prisons ludicrous profits. All you need is a tagline to distract the masses - "we don't want elders dying alone in their homes" and you can throw civil liberties right out the window to start making profits off them, the same way sociopaths use the legal system to pray on anyone they can.
- Merad 9y ago"Bad government" has become a self fulfilling prophecy in the US, and this is just one of the consequences.
- rocqua 9y agoIt reads like some of the people behind government safeguards weren't acting in good faith. Most notably the Clark County guardianship commissioner Jon Norheim. Other failed institutions seemed at least too disinterested. That includes the police (considering all of this a civil matter), and Nevada Adult Protective Services. Beyond that, many people (doctors, people working at retirement homes, etc) seem to have actively aided this scheme. In general, I'd say a combination of corruption and bureaucratic apathy / CYAism are what caused this. The solution is `more accountability' but that is difficult to do without creating more potential for bureaucracy and corruption.