4 ms·
I'm about to get back to work so I'll make this brief. My first impression is that it's a decent site design but there is too much information. First, I sugge
by photon_off 16y ago
I'm about to get back to work so I'll make this brief.
My first impression is that it's a decent site design but there is too much information.
First, I suggest you omit the "users online" and "guests online" stats, as they are going to be low until the site gets a little bit popular. For awhile, it'll appear to be a ghost town and actually repel people from using it. It's a great feature, though! Just put it on the backburner and release it when the time is right. (Or, you can extend the meaning of "online" to mean a longer time span so that the number are higher)
The font is too squished together and it impedes readability. I suggest each topic have more height to it, and more space. Definitely needs some padding in the description and the font-width (or whatever it's called) needs to be higher.
The sorting options appear to be broken, and there's no way to get back to the original view besides hitting the logo button. Make "what's new" a link to the page.
When clicking into a post, I'm confused as to what it is is supposed to be going on. I clicked on some democracy thing, and it showed the same truncated comment, and then 4 comments below. What caught my eye was a big box saying that I can't "collabrr" (which I don't even know what that entails), and a thing on the right flashing "no host".
Very confusing as to what the site does in general. "Our long-term goal is to create a unique site in which users can interact in a variety of ways to seek information, present information, or just interact in a community of unique individuals." It might hurt to hear this, but that sentence is essentially meaningless to somebody who knows nothing about the site. You could describe any number of websites that way.
Hope that helped.
- Scarface 16y agoThanks a lot photon_off, it is hard to take criticism on something that you worked hard on, but it is necessary. It is better to get told your site needs improvement rather than be oblivious. Really appreciate your time. PS the sorting tabs are not broken, they just depend on having users online using the site, which like you said is confusing if your site is a ghost town lol. Thanks again.
- photon_off 16y agoBelieve me, I know how it feels. I think the most common thing you might hear is that people just "don't get it". You have to understand that people visiting your site have zero vision of what it is supposed to do, and how they can use it. They haven't spent x hours a day for the past y days with this idea stuck in their head, nor have they loaded the page 10,000+ times. The problem is, it's kind of hard to erase your current perspective and take a fresh look at something. Impossible, really.
- Scarface 16y agoYeah it really is, but a lot of people have given me some good feedback, so at least I have a place to start. Thanks for the reassurance photon, its good to hear from someone who has experience with the same process.