6 ms·
>How does a brain, consisting of many modules, create just one person? The same way a population, consisting of many people, creates just one state? The state
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago
>How does a brain, consisting of many modules, create just one person?
The same way a population, consisting of many people, creates just one state? The state is not the people and the people are not the state, yet both exist.
- mfoy_ 9y agoI am not my neurons, my neurons are not me, but my identity is driven by those neurons. Exactly... a non-mystery. But a great example of "the whole being greater than the sum of its parts".
- booleandilemma 9y agoI think Daniel Dennett said it best: Not a single one of the cells that compose you knows who you are, or cares.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- liberte82 9y agoBut a state isn't conscious
- dpark 9y agoSure it is. A State reacts to its environment, acts in its interest, engages in rational decision making (at times), and generally exhibits self-aware behavior.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoBy what metric do you make that declaration? I submit that any empirical model of consciousness applies equally to states as it does to human minds.
- cscurmudgeon 9y agoIf complexity is consciousness, then NYC's sewer system is conscious too.
- dpark 9y agoNo one said that complexity is consciousness.
- cscurmudgeon 9y agoA lot do. E.g. Tononi's IIT.
- dpark 9y agoLet me rephrase. No one here said that complexity is consciousness. In particular, AnIdiotOnTheNet, who you replied to, did not say that complexity is consciousness. Also, tangentially, New York's sewers aren't that complex compared to even a rat's brain.
- cscurmudgeon 9y agoLet me rephrase. No one here said that complexity is consciousness. In particular, AnIdiotOnTheNet, who you replied to, did not say that complexity is consciousness. >Let me rephrase. No one here said that complexity is consciousness. In particular, AnIdiotOnTheNet, who you replied to, did not say that complexity is consciousness. Not directly. If not complexity, is it a kind of computation or something physical that makes neurons produce consciousness? Those positoins are more tough to support. > Also, tangentially, New York's sewers aren't that complex compared to even a rat's brain. What is the magic measure and what is magic threshold using that measure? What about a future city's sewer system that is complex enough?
- dpark 9y agoI’m not sure what your intent is here. “Sewers are conscious” seemed to be a reductio ad absurdum but now you seem to be arguing that complexity is consciousness. Regardless, I haven’t proposed any mechanism for consciousness to arise so I don’t have any “position to support” there.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gasbag 9y agoState is the wrong entity here. A population tends to create a culture, and a culture's interplay of ideas runs on its human network. Which is not to say that a culture is conscious either, and in all likelihood if it does have a kind of consciousness it's one that we will not be able to understand.
- skissane 9y agoSee Eric Schwitzgebel, "If Materialism Is True, the United States Is Probably Conscious", http://faculty.ucr.edu/~eschwitz/SchwitzAbs/USAconscious.htm http://faculty.ucr.edu/~eschwitz/SchwitzAbs/USAconscious.htm
- chimprich 9y ago> The state is not the people and the people are not the state, yet both exist. A state does not exist in any physical form. It is entirely a fiction, existing only in the minds of humans. Such existence it does have is not independent of the problem of consciousness so this is not the most helpful comparison.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoHow so? The state's physical form is comprised of people the way our minds' physical forms are comprised of neurons.