8 ms·
The article is seriously flawed, because it completely discounts the possibility that the fast lifestyle is the cause of the pathologies of the poor. It mentio
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
The article is seriously flawed, because it completely discounts the possibility that the fast lifestyle is the cause of the pathologies of the poor.
It mentions the oft-cited statistic that 2000 calories of junk food is cheaper than 2000 calories of vegetables. The fact is true, but irrelevant; if you are overweight or obese (as most of the poor are), you can reduce your caloric intake and increase food quality for the same cost. A few of the poor may be working dangerous jobs, but the vast majority of the poor are simply not working.
When you subject individuals from affluent (or poor, but foreign) backgrounds to US poverty-like conditions, they rarely exhibit the same pathologies. Graduate students earn very little money, but don't become obese. Indian immigrants in Jersey City, which includes guys working at fast food places, don't turn to crime, teen pregnancy [1] or exhibit the poor health that Americans do. That isn't what you'd expect if environment, rather than personal choices, were the driving factor.
[1] They do reproduce fairly early, but this is caused by different pathologies (forcing girls into arranged marriages at an early age) and it occurs even among affluent Indians.
- Unseelie 16y agoYou're discounting the argument that the fast lifestyle isn't a response to poverty, but a response to expectations of poverty. Environment as it affects someone born into poverty without examples of persons who grow out of it, rather than a grad student(really a laughable argument that a grad student is 'poor' considering the value of their education.) or an immigrant to the nation, come to find opportunity...
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe theory that people respond to expected future "poverty" [1] rather than their current circumstances is certainly harder to falsify. But I definitely dispute the assertion that people living in poor regions lack examples of people who grew out of it. It's certainly not true in the poor neighborhoods I've lived in (and currently live in). There are plenty of people who stayed in school, kept their heads down and achieved a solidly middle class lifestyle. They often remain involved with the local community, typically the church and extended family. [1] I find it very difficult to use the term "poverty" to describe the bottom 10% of Americans, seeing as all their material needs are met and they consume more leisure than any other group.
- willchang 16y agoYou can both be right: A fast lifestyle (1) is caused by expecting poverty and (2) causes poverty; but I think that Unseelie's (and the article's) point is the more significant one. In order to fight poverty, you have to give people a reason to change their expectations, without which it would be impossible to change their behavior.
- lkjhgbvbhnjmk 16y agoAnd it happens very quickly, the area I grew up was reasonably prosperous working class. Then the mines, steelworks and shipyards closed - 20 years later the majority of people growing up there are never going to have a proper job. If you see a lifetime on the dole there isn't much point in waiting until you are 30 to have kids for the sake of your 'career' at a supermarket checkout or call center.
- _delirium 16y agoIf indeed "personal choices" rather than "environment" are the main driving factor, are you arguing that somehow huge numbers of people who coincidentally make the same choices were born and raised in geographically similar areas? How else do you explain the fact that people who grew up West Virginia are much poorer on average than people who grew up in Connecticut? Some sort of genetic abnormality that makes CT residents make better choices than WV residents? Positing an environmental component (growing up in WV is worse than growing up in CT) seems more plausible.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWould you dispute the fact that children of people who practice Judaism are likely to practice Judaism themselves? If not, why would you find it unlikely that the children of people who practice a fast lifestyle might similarly repeat their parent's behavior? Some components of personality are genetic (and not just heritable), as has been demonstrated by many twin studies. But we hardly need to invoke genetics to explain the heritability of behavior.
- _delirium 16y agoSure, but that's what I thought I was arguing, since kids inheriting behaviors from their parents is one kind of environmental factor. I'm not sure I'd call it a "personal choice", given that one doesn't choose one's parents, and doesn't fully choose what aspects of one's environment to be influenced by. There's lots of room for personal choices, of course, but I think they all happen against a strong background of environmental influence---from parents, schools, media, neighborhoods, friends, business cycles, employers, natural disasters, and who knows what else---that shapes which choices are available and salient.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoYou can call it an environmental effect, if you wish, but it isn't the sort of environmental effect the article is talking about. The article claims that 'this kind of "delinquent" behaviour is a sensible response to the circumstances of a life constrained by poverty', not that poor people are repeating the same bad choices as their parents. The article claims that "Once you are in a situation where the expected healthy lifetime is short whatever you do, then there is less incentive to look after yourself." That might be true, but it is irrelevant since your lifetime is longer if you make better choices. Being overweight or obese (a major pathology of the poor) is a much greater threat to your life than crime and car crashes (environmental killers cited by the article), but your weight and exercise levels are entirely under your control. The point of the article is that what we perceive as bad choices is just a rational response to pathologies caused by environment (and they cite examples like the food we eat, the jobs we work, and the possibility of crime or car crashes), and that the choices are not the cause of the pathologies.
- billybob 16y agoClearly, everyone makes choices, which is why you have inspiring rags-to-riches stories and tragic "how did they go so wrong" stories. But a big part of your environment is your culture. The Indian immigrants in Jersey City, I suspect, still see themselves as Indian, probably grow up in stable families, and are given discipline, role models, encouragement, and expectations of achievement. Surely that makes a bigger difference than what goes on in one's neighborhood. If you live near gangs, that's one thing. If your dad left and your brother is in a gang and the music all your peers listen to says "the goal of life is to be the baddest gangster," that's quite another.
- chopsueyar 16y agoWord.
- starkfist 16y ago63% of all adult Americans are overweight or obese, graduate students included. In poor areas it is hard to swap bad calories for good, because there is no place to get good food cheaply. I don't know about Jersey City, but in Queens there are plenty of "ghetto" Indian people (for lack of a better phrase.)
- yummyfajitas 16y agoMajor statistical fallacy. You can't take the average across a group and then assert that subgroups display the same average. I don't have statistics for grad students (only personal observations), but I do have statistics showing that obesity goes up with poverty. For instance: http://www.prb.org/articles/2010/usobesity.aspx http://www.prb.org/articles/2010/usobesity.aspx
- starkfist 16y agoSure, whatever. I guess it depends on the graduate program. Computer scientist PhDs are generally fat. Kinesiology grad students are usually fit. Everyone else is somewhere in between. I am not providing a link, because I don't care.