3 ms·
There are two fallacies that come into play when an American considers Singapore. One is to look at Singapore's positive results and assume we could have the s
by gojomo 16y ago
There are two fallacies that come into play when an American considers Singapore.
One is to look at Singapore's positive results and assume we could have the same clean streets, low crime, efficient public works, growth-friendly environment with a tiny government sector if we only had the will.
The other is to look at some of the key differences in culture/population/geography/governance and thus assume we have nothing to learn from them, "comparison is meaningless".
The truth, and all interesting discussion, should come from somewhere in between. The USA is far from optimal and could learn a lot from other countries -- though we rarely look. (Indeed it's amazing how little US states like California seriously look at how other states are doing some things better.) But we'd best not cherry-pick the factoids that help our preferred side of some debate-of-the-moment.
- ugh 16y agoI should have made it clear that I don’t think that any comparison is useless. There is a whole world of already implemented policies out there, it would be stupid not to take advantage of that. It’s just that general statements about whole bundles of policies (“Look at Singapore and their policies, they brought them massive growth! We should adopt them.”) or even individual policies (“Look at France’s healthcare system! It’s working perfectly, we should copy it 1:1.”) are probably not enough. You will have to look at specific policies, their environment, the conditions under which they could succeed (or whether they did in the first place) and how they were implemented. Only then can you begin to judge whether those policies would also be a good idea for different countries.