8 ms·
As a contractor in the UK I feel like I have better pay and prospects than 90% of staff members. Not 'promotion', but more respect for my expertise and more ch
by Nursie 9y ago
As a contractor in the UK I feel like I have better pay and prospects than 90% of staff members.
Not 'promotion', but more respect for my expertise and more choice about my working practices.
'Promotion' is not something I've often observed happening in any of the software departments I've worked with of late.
It does scare me when people say things like "40+ contractors still working as engineers", as if 40 is old. I'm 40 next year and less than halfway through my working life (according to the government, obviously I'd like to retire early).
- q-base 9y agoDon't get scared by peoples labels. There is nothing you SHOULD. There are choices and consequences. If you make a good living and enjoy what you do, then why suddenly question it.
- Nursie 9y agoOh I don't, it's not so much about what I enjoy as the threat of ageist hiring practices that worries me. That said, I am moving to be more independent over time, and hope to have my own thing going within the next few years (over and above my current contracting business)
- sefrost 9y agoIs contracting in the US the same thing as contracting in the UK? The article doesn't seem to explain what a contractor is.
- Nursie 9y agoI have no idea! I get the impression that contracting in the US, at least in tech firms, is a lot less lucrative.
- jonnathanson 9y ago(Warning: this post contains personal opinions and analysis, some of which might be deemed political.) There are really two classes of 'contract work' in the US. The first class is what I'd call skilled specialists. These are your independent marketing consultants, security experts, developers, designers, copywriters, etc. These folks are usually, but not always, fairly experienced. They take up contracting or consulting as a career choice, and while they have to hustle to stay above water, they accept the hustle as the price of freedom from a corporate life. Often they work remotely. If they're strong and well-networked, they have some leeway in negotiating fees and terms for their services. The catch is that there are very few availabilities on the market for their services at any given time, and most firms don't appropriately value those services. As such, skilled specialists thrive or stumble on the strength of their reputations and rolodexes. Many of them have served for years in the corporate world, or in high level academia. They may have the ability to reeenter corporate America at will, e.g., for a client who really wants to bring them in house. The second class is what I'd call no-choice contractors. These are most often (but not always) younger workers, whom a company will hire for short term jobs, and then spit back out whenever it's done with them. Many of these workers are placed by temp agencies, or respond to open positions for fixed term jobs, and would probably take full time jobs if the jobs were available to them. This category includes seasonal hires, unskilled laborers, and skilled laborers placed at companies on short-term assignments with the vague (and usually fruitless) hope of ascending to full-time status. Skilled specialists are a much smaller pool, on the whole, than no-choice contractors. And many skilled specialists are but one wrong decision, or bad run of luck, away from slipping into the no-choice pool. If you're unfamiliar with US corporate culture, the best way to understand my distinction is to first realize that labor lost the war with capital here about 30-odd years ago. During the Reagan era, labor rights one might take for granted in Europe were effectively positioned here as socialistic, and thus cancerous to the 'competitiveness' (read: profit margins) of the firm. Wall Street and hedge funds, along with prevailing MBA management culture, have convinced us that the flexibility afforded to big firms by contracting out their jobs is necessarily a good thing. It allows them to be more nimble, and to operate with a higher degree of tactical freedom from quarter to quarter, or from year to year. More important, if not all important, is that a contract labor force is better in the short run for returning shareholder value. This line of reasoning is very attractive, but almost too attractive. What we have now is a system, and a culture, that treats more and more jobs as holes to be filled, and which treats individuals not as prospects to be groomed, but as cogs to be worked hard and replaced when worn out. We have also traded strategic thinking for tactical thinking, and we no longer understand the difference. But that's a rant for another time, perhaps. :)
- maxxxxx 9y agoI used to do contracting in Germany and the US. In Germany there was an understanding that you have a higher risk and therefore a contractor should make more money than an employee to compensate for that risk. In the US most companies view contractors as cheap labor and pay their employees more. No idea how general this is. It's just my personal experience.
- Nursie 9y agoThanks, I had the impression it was something like that. In the UK a lot of the best people are contractors. A lot of the awful ones too, mind!
- jondubois 9y agoI've done contracting in Australia, UK and The Netherlands. Australia and EU are great for contracting. There are some really well paid London software engineering contracts (often paying higher than EU ones) but most are for big finance firms and they often want people to have a finance background so it's harder to get in. Also from my experience, UK contract recruiters tend to be more picky about having an exact technical skill match. Australian contracts are the easiest to get. Some pay ridiculously well. I did an indefinite rolling contract that paid the AUD equivalent of USD $650 per day, $13K per month. It wasn't particularly challenging either. I later travelled to other countries where software engineers were treated like factory workers so the country definitely matters.
- Nursie 9y ago>> I later travelled to other countries where software engineers were treated like factory workers It's not far above that in a lot of UK places, particularly the SME space. Maybe I should have tried contracting in Aus when I lived there!
- s73ver_ 9y agoWell, for one, there's a difference between contracting as a professional, and contracting as a driver for Uber, etc.
- ghgfhgfhn 9y agoMy thoughts exactly - I have literally never seen promotion happen in 15 years employment. I have approximately 0% chance of moving into management naturally within an organisation. Software developers are treated as highly paid secretaries - secretaries do not get promoted no matter how long they serve (which I also think is wrong). To move into management I will need to take lots of courses in my own time and push recruiters to give me a shot and then once I'm in an interview I need to be able to talk like a demon to convince them to give me a shot. There is very little upward mobility for a software engineer in the UK outside of big-name firms. So I'm going contracting, where I atleast get a little respect and my market value (approx 2x full time employement salary).
- Swinx43 9y agoI agree with your assessment of being a contractor in the UK. I work as an IT contractor in the UK as well and have been a permanent employee before that. Permanent members of staff seldom get the same money as skilled contractors and have to put up with a lot more restrictions around holiday and work life balance. I would equate a contractor in the UK to being the equivalent experience of being a consultant without the politics and drama that comes with it. I have worked for almost a decade as a consultant in different countries and much prefer being a contractor to that. Promotions seem to normally equate to more responsibility with a meagre if at all pay increase for permanent members of staff. People forget that there is only 1 CTO in an organisation, not everyone can ever get to that level. Most get stuck in middle management hell doing unfulfilling jobs.
- 201709User 9y agoAlso permanent guys get to support contractors' code, which adds an insult to an injury.
- zimpenfish 9y agoOn the flip side, contractors have to sort out the mess that permanent guys have made.
- Nursie 9y agoAnd that's why we get the good money...
- maxxxxx 9y agoUnfortunately for every qualified contractor you have 20 clueless people hired from some body shop who make a mess of things. Good contractors are a rare breed.
- Nursie 9y agoEh, so are good employees are in the UK. I've been contracting five years, and the state of software engineering seems woeful in the small and medium sized countries of the UK.
- rovek 9y agoThis is my experience in the UK. After a little under a decade in SWE I've consistently seen contractors grossing about 3x the salary of full time employees, with little prospects of "promotion" for engineers without changing employer.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> contractors grossing about 3x the salary of full time employees I dunno where you're seeing that but in the circles I move in, no-one is getting even 75% of 3xEFTE. More like 45-50% of 3xEFTE. (EFTE = Equivalent FTE. Obviously new FTEs cost a lot less.)
- sefrost 9y agoCentral London contractors can have daily rates of 400/500 easily. That's an equivalent salary of £90k+
- 201709User 9y agoMinus pension, minus insurance, plus accounting expense. So deduct a few grand.
- richardknop 9y ago600/700 is not unusual in London (several of my friends are on daily rates like that). Plus you can expense a ton of things as part of business costs.
- zimpenfish 9y agoIf you're into the weird or obscure fintech stuff, you can easily double those.
- richardknop 9y agoOr some enterprise nonsense like Ab Initio, Siebel, SAP etc.
- walshemj 9y agoYes when I worked for BT full time in my divison (systems Engineering) there might be 20 possible promotions from MPG2 to MPG 4 every 18 months. As my boss said getting on the short list meant that the company thought you where good enough but with say 600-800 potential candidates for promotion the competition was brutal I knew better developers than me who just gave up