3 ms·
>> “We do not need as much computational power as the brain has, because our algorithms are (will be) better than that of the brain.” > I hope you can see afte
by visarga 9y ago
>> “We do not need as much computational power as the brain has, because our algorithms are (will be) better than that of the brain.”
> I hope you can see after the descriptions in this blog post that this statement is rather arrogant.
The brain does more than computers: the brain builds its internal structure all by itself. When was a computer able to evolve from a bunch of transistors laying on the table? Also, it uses very little energy and is resilient for 80-100 years, compared to the computers of today, its apples and oranges.
> Show me the Hubble images of the computronium Dyson swarms. If it takes less than a century to go from the first transistorized computers to superintelligence, and superintelligence is as prone to run amok as Bostrom/Yudkowsky think, signs should already be visible from Earth.
What if the AGI will prefer to build virtual worlds and societies of virtual agents instead of grand space domination ? Even humans prefer games to reality nowadays (or a large percentage of us do). If we're part of such a sim, then it would explain the lack of external signals from extraterrestrial aliens or AGIs.
The probability that AGI will appear and create amazing simulations is much larger than that of picking up signs of life in the vastness of space. Also, by replacing physical with sim we can do all sorts of things such as use less energy, recover from any accident, hack our own brains/minds, even immortality.
- icc97 9y agoThe $24M per year (23MW) for the electricity for the Tianhe-2 was quite shocking. This is against the 13W that the brain uses: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/thinking-hard-calories/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/thinking-hard-cal... So the brain has a million times more the processing power and uses a million times less power.
- JacobiX 9y ago>> So the brain has a million times more the processing power and uses a million times less power. A commodity smartphone is millions of times more powerful than all of NASA's combined computing in 1970 and more energy efficient. A factor of 10^6 is maybe achievable with a specialized quantum computer in the mid-term future ?
- icc97 9y agoThe post speculates 2037 - 2080. So yes similar timescales from the 70s til now.
- ss248 9y ago>the brain builds its internal structure all by itself >when was a computer able to evolve from a bunch of transistors laying on the table These two statements are not really connected. Brain builds its internal structure in a sense, it changes with learning for example. But brain did not evolve by itself. It's all thanks to the force of evolution. So it boils down to the question: "Can we do better than evolution?", so we need to understand what evolution is. It's just random mutations that make organism better than it was before. If these random mutations make it worse, organism gets lower chances of survival and usually just dies. Essentially, evolution is a method of design by brute force. And brute force works, if you have a lot of time, but it's common sense that intelligently designed algorithm can do a lot better. So we can answer the question now with "Yes, most likely we can do better."