3 ms·
Google is more a conduit of news rather than a gatekeeper. FB is both a gatekeeper and a conduit to news as well as a news producer (since it pays or underwrit
by mc32 9y ago
Google is more a conduit of news rather than a gatekeeper. FB is both a gatekeeper and a conduit to news as well as a news producer (since it pays or underwrites some orgs to produce news for it).
That said, I think The Atlantic is wrong in placing blame on Google when they themselves engage in questionable journalism (clickbait as well as often biased news-source).
There is no way we're going to come up with something "objectively truthful" because, news as it exists today is not about facts. It's journalism and journalism has always been about putting a slant on things --quoting unauthoritative sources ("man named Joe claims," etc.) loose factchecking, and more. All to sell more news (packaged with ads or for subscriptions, where you don't want to alienate your subscriber "base".
This is an attempted landgrab by establishment news orgs to corner what is news. They want to be the only sanctioned sources of news and punish alternative sources --using an obvious outlier to promote their pov.
- forapurpose 9y ago> There is no way we're going to come up with something "objectively truthful" because, news as it exists today is not about facts. It's journalism and journalism has always been about putting a slant on things --quoting unauthoritative sources ("man named Joe claims," etc.) loose factchecking, and more. All to sell more news (packaged with ads or for subscriptions, where you don't want to alienate your subscriber "base". I look at it much differently: Nothing is perfect, no news source, no politician, no text editor, no scientific theory. They all fail our ideals but some are a lot better than others, some are a little better, and as others have pointed out in this discussion, an essential skill is to differentiate between them and also to assume the uncertainties of imperfection and to read critically. To throw together all journalism as 'imperfect' is like throwing together all science, from the theory of evolution to latest upload to arXiv, as all a failure because it's imperfect. Yes, read Darwin critically, but don't conflate his work with everyone else's. The more I accept inevitable human imperfection, the more I'm amazed by people like Darwin and by organizations like the NY Times, which cranks out a very good, very difficult product on an amazing schedule. That they and others accomplish all of that under the constraints of humanity is truly amazing to me. > The Atlantic is wrong in placing blame on Google when they themselves ... We're kind of stuck with ideas from hypocrites, at least until the great AI awakening - and if it's strong AI, hypocrisy might be the first sign that it's working.
- mc32 9y agoI think the Atlantic wants it's cake and eat it too: >The problems with surfacing this man’s group to Facebook users is obvious to literally any human. So it's obvious to any human, yet people aren't good enough to differentiate fake from real news. >Most people who joined the group looking for information presumably don’t know that the founder is notorious for legal and informational hijinks I mean, the author is picking and choosing anecdotes to make a point in order to further their agendum. On the other hand I agree with you but it's irrelevant to the authors' point. The author, I would posit, is not really interested in sourcing better news (it's not impossible, for example, for 4chan to have the best info on a particular issue (via a contributor) while The Atlantic may have none. But they are arguing a 4chan should not be surfaced at all --not that 4chan should be better scrutinized and only surface accurate information. It's an underhanded and opportunistic attempt to delegitimize non professional journos and build a moat around the "profession".
- justin66 9y ago> That said, I think The Atlantic is wrong in placing blame on Google when they themselves engage in questionable journalism (clickbait as well as often biased news-source). They're hypocritical but they're not wrong.
- eighthnate 9y ago> That said, I think The Atlantic is wrong in placing blame on Google when they themselves engage in questionable journalism (clickbait as well as often biased news-source). The atlantic and the rest of traditional media just wants google to link their clickbait stories. It's ultimately all about money. > using an obvious outlier to promote their pov. As per usual. I wonder how the atlantic would like google to us the outlier ( rolling stones UVA story ) to ban all traditional media. At the end of the day, this guy has to write something so that the atlantic would pay him. So he just went to his normal story. The guy is no more informed than the rest of us. He just gets paid to write silly stories.