16 ms·
Guacamole – A clientless remote desktop gateway
- makmanalp 9y agoAgh, I so want this to be good. With remote desktop, I think one thing that makes a product in this area stand out is how it handles delay, packet loss and bandwidth issues. There's a ton of stuff re: adaptively changing quality and keyframe frequency, sending delta updates for parts of the screen, compressing the data, and doing all this without pegging the cpu at 100% etc etc. Teamviewer and Nomachine NX are two examples that I use a ton that seem to have most of this stuff figured out, whereas their competitors seems to work in theory, whereas in practice they are bloated, they lag, they make my computer fan go crazy, etc. Another thing is ease of connection through NAT/firewalls, though for that this seems to shift the burden on the server setup.
- wpietri 9y agoHuh. Does anybody know what the good clients use as a transport? E.g., are they UDP-based? A quick skim of the docs suggests that this only uses HTTP and Websockets, which I understand are TCP-based. The only browser thing I know of does an unreliable transport is WebRTC, but that currently isn't supported: https://glyptodon.org/jira/browse/GUAC-815 https://glyptodon.org/jira/browse/GUAC-815
- marktangotango 9y agoYou http to the quacamole server, that server runs quacd that handles vnc, rdp to the desktop you want to reach. It's a proxy essentially.
- niutech 9y agoScreenCat (https://github.com/maxogden/screencat https://github.com/maxogden/screencat) is using WebRTC, but it is currently Mac-only.
- leni536 9y agoI had good experiences with x2go [1]. I also tried winswitch, as I remember it worked well too [2]. Both support the NX protocol. About NAT/firewall zerotier[3] solves most of my issues. [1] https://wiki.x2go.org/doku.php https://wiki.x2go.org/doku.php [2] http://winswitch.org/ http://winswitch.org/ [3] https://github.com/zerotier/ZeroTierOne https://github.com/zerotier/ZeroTierOne
- wiz21c 9y agoX2GO is extremely reliable for me. But speed is not good compared to teamviewer (which had a lot of stability issues on linux when I tested it 3-4 years ago)
- glenneroo 9y agoStill having lots of instability issues with teamviewer on Linux, mostly tested on Ubuntu boxes.
- CoreXtreme 9y agoI ran into Double NAT issue with Teamviewer once. Oh boy! that was so hard to figure out.
- XorNot 9y agox2go is great. I desperately want to see VirtualGL integration in it though so you can run egl compositors with local rendering (since GPUs on VMs are still uncommon). The other thing RDP is amazing at that I haven't seen Linux do well at all is resuming local sessions remotely and vice versa - with RDP it feels integrated, with x2go you're back to just transferring frames.
- CodeWriter23 9y agopcANYWHERE for Windows had this all figured out in the late 80’s. They hooked GDI and transported the API calls wherever possible. It worked awesomely over a 56k modem. Then the guys involved sold to Symantec, and they let it go fallow, EOLing it in 2014 after 7 years of no updates.
- bitwize 9y ago> pcANYWHERE for Windows had this all figured out in the late 80’s. They hooked GDI and transported the API calls wherever possible. RDP does the same; the early revs were basically GDI over wire. Later versions would have extensions/hax to transport the DirectX stuff (did they just ship framebuffers? I dunno).
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoThen why is it always compared favorably to X over network, which does exactly the same thing (sending graphics primitives over the network, although these days mostly having to throw over complete frame buffers because everything wants to draw itself)?
- bitwize 9y ago1) RDP has better compression. 2) When times changed, RDP adapted, X did not. No one uses those old graphics primitives anymore, and X's network protocol failed to keep up with the new reality of client-side rendering. So now that protocol sucks for remoting GUIs.
- ghostly_s 9y agoYep. For many applications, RDP on a LAN is literally indistinguishable from a local session. Sadly, nothing I've tried on the Linux desktop comes close to this performance. One of the few areas where the Linux desktop is 15 years behind.
- rkeene2 9y agoTo add to this a bit, another area where the "X ecosystem" didn't keep up is with toolkits. X11 is a very asynchronous protocol, but this is difficult to work with for toolkits so they synchronize most things, making it slow over high latency links (but unnoticeable over low latency links, like UNIX domain sockets on the local host).
- voidmain0001 9y agoAbout 12 years ago I deployed Windows Terminal Server in a corporate environment, and used PXE boot on the client computers to start a basic Linux distro that then launched the 2X client to access TS. Right now I'm creating a reference document for a VDI deployment using VMware/Citrix/TS. I've briefly looked at the NoMachine client by installing it to a Win10 computer, and the performance of NoMachine is worse than RDP to the same computer over the same link. Since you're happy with NoMahchine do you know of any optimization techniques for it?
- makmanalp 9y agoHmm - I haven't really administered Nomachine myself (we have an enterprise installation on one of the clusters at work), so I can't really help you there unfortunately, but only to say that it doesn't often crash or hang for me, and the delay is quite low enough over wan that using the GUI / mouse works almost perfectly, both on OSX and windows.
- cat199 9y agoRDP is pretty darn fast (at least when I last used it ~10y ago) I think the attraction to NX for linux users is that it is still way better than VNC.. and both of which are pretty much the only consistently functioning / packaged server options for most distros without fiddling..
- pixelcloud 9y agoI've been using XRDP for a while now. Works extremely well.
- markbnj 9y agoI've been a nomachine fan for a few years now, use it to access my linux work laptop from my windows gaming desktop. It has some minor irritations but on the whole it handles this use case quite well. I'll definitely be giving guacamole a shot though.
- sjellis 9y agoTeradici PCoIP is proprietary, but absolutely, amazingly good. It is licensed by various thin client and Virtual Desktop Infrastructure products, like AWS WorkSpaces. RDP is also really effective. I use both, but Teradici is the one that made me abandon my local Windows VMs.
- wesm 9y agoI'm sorry to be pedantic but can you add "(incubating)" to the title of the post?
- el_duderino 9y agoPrevious discussion from 2016: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11744430 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11744430
- victor106 9y agoDoes anyone here know how can I access my vpn connected work laptop from any computer outside for e.g:- my home laptop?
- Cyph0n 9y agoTeamViewer should work fine. Minor grammatical note: "e.g." means "for example", so the phrase "for e.g." does not make sense. I used to make the same mistake quite a bit!
- abraae 9y agoI'm not so sure about that. The leading "for" stands on its own without the e.g. e.g., with some additional punctuation: I like to run for the bus. I like to run for, for example, buses, cars and airplanes. I like to run for e.g. buses, cars and airplanes. A little tortured but possibly valid.
- jlgaddis 9y agoAny HN'ers happen to use Guacamole in order to gain access to Linux hosts (via SSH, of course) from an iPad? I'd be interested in hearing about how it works. Alternatively, I'd take recommendations for an SSH client for the iPad that supports public/private key pairs and connecting through a bastion/jumpbox/etc. (a.k.a. the "ProxyCommand" SSH client directive).
- jitl 9y agoGuacamole is awesome! I highly recommend it. I used Guacamole + a 1st gen Chromebook as my laptop for several years of college work in 2012-2014. Tasks that worked well: - writing code in IntelliJ - editing in Adobe Illustrator - working in the terminal - basic CAD in Sketchup Tasks that I’d wait to do at home on my desktop: - drawing, especially in Photoshop - 3D work in Maya - sound-latency sensitive work like MAX
- gjvc 9y ago"a couple" rather than "several" to be clear -- let's not exaggerate how long it's been around!
- hnlmorg 9y agoSince we're nitpicking: 2012-2014 can potentially be three years. The definition for "several" is relatively flexible since it's an approximate quantity. However what is agreed upon is that it has to be at least more than a couple, which three is. So I'd argue the GP's post is valid as it is.
- mihaifm 9y agoGreat tool indeed. To be honest even web browsing works just fine with it, as long as there is no animations to display. I use it to get around my firewall at work, which seem to block anything apart http/https. If anyone knows a better solution than guacamole, let me know :)
- pnutjam 9y agoI run a PC at home with x2go. I use it to surf the web among other things. Images are fine, video will stutter, sound generally works fine. I used it for years with only a 1mb uplink, although I now have 10mb.
- pnutjam 9y agoyou need a client, but the phython client can be unpacked and used without installing (portable) on windows.
- nsxwolf 9y agoI’ve yet to find a good solution for remoting to a Mac from a Windows machine. Chrome Remote Desktop almost fits the bill, but I cannot get meta key bindings to work properly. I will give this a try. Hoping it is good.
- jitl 9y agomacOS has VNC and Remote Desktop servers built in; Ive never had issues with the functionality of either, although there are some security concerns
- rcarmo 9y agoApple’s Remote Desktop protocol is VNC with extra features, not RDP.
- nsxwolf 9y agoAlso a "good" solution to me means the connection is established via some cloud mechanism, and doesn't require me to open a bunch of ports on my firewall. And VNC on Mac has always had miserable usability for me - updates paint slowly from the top to the bottom of the screen, can't see my text in real time when I type.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoHave you tried NoMachine?
- cwyers 9y agoThe demo is a little weird. They open up VLC on Windows, but only to show off how it renders waveforms for an MP3. Is that a use case that people have for remoting into their PC?
- matchu 9y agoThey're demonstrating Guacamole's ability to handle simple animations smoothly. Music visualizers are a solid, familiar example, despite not being a super-common use case for remote desktop.
- solomatov 9y agoDoes anybody know whether it supports advanced features of RDP which allows very low latency and low bandwidth.
- jitl 9y agoThere’s 2 parts to any connection in Guacamole: Your remote <———> guacd (RDP) guacd <———> the browser (custom protocol) In my experience, Guacamole works very well with windows RDP servers, and feels very fast. Certainly faster than X11 or VNC remoting on the same hardware.
- asadlionpk 9y agoI have analyzed the websocket traffic and I think it does support those. It's very fast when used with RDP as compared to vnc.
- hardwaresofton 9y agoEveryone keep in mind that Guacamole has been around a long time -- I think it's just started being incubated by Apache, that's all. Here's a walk-through from a year ago: https://www.reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/4vdujw/guacamole_for_dummies/ https://www.reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/4vdujw/guacamole_f...
- nodesocket 9y agoShameless plug -- founder of https://commando.io https://commando.io here. We offer a product similar to Guacamole (agentless/clientless) SSH access to machines which is web based. We unfortunately only support SSH though. We have an iOS app as well so you can execute commands on servers on the go or from bed -- BedOps :-).
- jcrites 9y agoBeautiful! I've been looking for something like this and hadn't heard of Guacamole. Where I work, it's standard for developers to work using a "cloud desktop", i.e., a remote machine hosted in the cloud that's used for personal development with a very production-like environment [1]. When accompanied by a powerful laptop it's all most engineers need. However, client and server software for various protocols like RDP and VNC on various platforms is still a pain. It'd be great to have a simple and easy way to provide viable remote access built directly into servers -- from any client device with no prior setup. I'm glad to have come across this. I'm curious how Guacamole's HTML5 rendering compares to solutions like the Ace editor when used to render terminals and text areas. At a high level, it looks like Guacamole is based on RealMint which uses the HTML5 canvas tag, whereas Ace manipulates regular text elements to effect styling. I'll have to experiment with them. [1] And for that reason I was amused to see the following on the Guacamole home page: "Keep your desktop in the cloud: Desktops accessed through Guacamole need not physically exist. With both Guacamole and a desktop operating system hosted in the cloud, you can combine the convenience of Guacamole with the resilience and flexibility of cloud computing."
- Razengan 9y ago> it's standard for developers to work using a "cloud desktop" Personally I prefer something like Apple's iCloud Drive; your files are downloaded locally and made available offline, letting you work on them with any device, even after it's disconnected from the Internet. This lets my data stay mine, encrypted on my local storage, individually manageable and tag-able like all regular files, included in Time Machine etc. backups, and available even if iCloud Drive goes down. For example, although you cannot compile full Xcode projects on iPads (yet), I can take code from them, edit it in Swift Playgrounds on my iPad, and copy it back into iCloud Drive for continuing on my iMac.
- Razengan 9y agoEdit: That is not to say having access to a full desktop system from any device isn't desirable, but I do prefer my files to remain available on local storage.
- 9y ago
- m3kw9 9y agoAny reason why they presented it on windows 2000?
- jagger27 9y agoIt looks like Windows 7 with the Classic theme.
- turbohedgehog 9y agoCan it do virtual desktops like a VNC server can?
- edoceo 9y agoThis this is so cool! I've been using for years, even made a nice auth-hack https://github.com/edoceo/guacamole-auth-http https://github.com/edoceo/guacamole-auth-http
- CSDude 9y agoWe had a project that can control qemu, xen, vmware and hyperv, Guacomole handled them all, and we integrated it easily, it supports both websockets and regular http polling, both works fast enough and nice
- justinjlynn 9y agoAny chance your integration code is available?
- e9 9y agoI wish I had this years ago. To do VNC and get around firewall/NAT issues I actually created port forwarder through Firebase. It surprisingly worked great https://github.com/rb365/fireport https://github.com/rb365/fireport I might try to make it work with Guacamole, web UI is definitely better than installing VNC client.
- nameless912 9y agoI don't read many things that make my eyes go wide and my mind to be filled with "what in the actual fuck"s. This is one of them.
- nurettin 9y agoWhy didn't you use a dynamic DNS client? A lot of domain name providers have them.
- djhworld 9y agoYou could just use ngrok for this https://ngrok.com/ https://ngrok.com/
- godzillabrennus 9y agoReminds me of what http://Browserling http://Browserling has had for enabling access to browsers for their customers for years.
- alea12 9y agoHow do we pronounce this?
- candiodari 9y agoI was making a cloud product a number of years back and wrote a similar product for my then employer. For VNC and SSH it's pretty easy to do in Javascript and can be quite reliable (much more so than telling customers how to connect using their own software - big difference in support). Even full-screen games were doable. It provided something similar to phpvirtualbox + a screen where you'd (if properly authenticaed) just get access to your virtual machines just by going to a particular tab. Had a list of your VMs on the left, click on one, and a javascript starts up and gets a VNC javascript (started out with flash, swapped it out for a javascript one) That said, this doesn't work as well as people here want it to. There is a significant cost to running in the browser (keyboard for instance, pressing CTRL-W will definitely generate a "wtf" moment a few times). But the speed and the fact that I couldn't do significant protocol development (VNC has something like 7 variations on protocol, integrating those into websocket is more than just encapsulating them if you want it to work well), means that I couldn't use the most efficient protocols. This meant that effectively there were resolution limits that weren't too high. Lastly, javascript adds (a lot) of latency. It isn't much, and it sort of stays below 200 msec or so. But you'd be surprised how incredibly irritating it is to work with just 20msec extra latency. It's barely tolerable. For server admin work, sure (even then it's irritating). For constant development work, it's very irritating. And full-screen games were doable because generally they would lower resolution and have other sources of lag. So they actually worked better than things like Eclipse and Visual Studio. Also they make you much less likely to hit browser keys. Especially old full screen games worked really well.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoGreat idea. I hate the name. Name should have something obviously incommon with the feature/purpose.
- Zhyl 9y agoAre there any apache projects that do this?
- nl 9y agoThe Apache webserver is so-named because it is a-patchy webserver (based on the NCSA webserver). They like their pun names..
- hanoz 9y agoIf a server can be likened to an avocado, this enables people to expose its insides by removing the hardened outer layer, then trash the kernel and mash the rest to a pulp?
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agointeresting...but that's quite a stretch IMHO!
- joefarish 9y agoA couple of useful articles for setting up a secure Guacamole environment: •Enabling Duo Dual / Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) for Guacamole Docker https://www.cb-net.co.uk/linux/enabling-duo-dual-multi-factor-authentication-mfa-for-guacamole-docker/ https://www.cb-net.co.uk/linux/enabling-duo-dual-multi-facto... •Using Let’s Encrypt with an NGINX Docker Container (plus bye-bye StartSSL!) https://www.cb-net.co.uk/linux/using-lets-encrypt-with-an-nginx-docker-container-plus-bye-bye-startssl/ https://www.cb-net.co.uk/linux/using-lets-encrypt-with-an-ng...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- patrickaljord 9y agoPlease don't use vimeo, it's terrible for people with slow connections (no 144p) and for people with fast connection there is no 2x speed mode to save time. Use Youtube or a service with similar feature.
- thecrazyone 9y agoNot sure why you're being down voted. I find the youtube experience superior to vimeo's
- wccrawford 9y agoAlso, they've made it pretty clear they're about art, and they love to remove things that aren't. Like tutorials, or game recordings. Though it does seem they started letting video game captures again, they still have the "creative expression" language. https://vimeo.com/blog/post/new-upload-rules https://vimeo.com/blog/post/new-upload-rules
- sp332 9y agoVideo game companies are getting increasingly strict about taking down videos, so Vimeo is probably just trying to avoid that hassle.
- monkpit 9y ago> Video game companies are getting increasingly strict about taking down videos... Source?
- nameless912 9y agoNintendo just geared up on this hardcore yesterday. A lot of other game studios have been getting worse too.
- mikewhy 9y agoNintendo have always been Nintendo about this sort of thing.
- zbraniecki 9y agoLike all Apache projects it seems like it's very well documented for engineers who work with it, but not really explained for newcomers :) Does it log in into its own session or takes control over an active session on the machine? My use case is this - My parent is using Ubuntu and in case she reports a problem, I'd like to be able to log into her session, share control over the mouse pointer so that she can show me what she's doing and I can also navigate around to uncheck the checkbox or sth like that. Is Guacamole the right solution? If not, anyone knows a good one?
- rkangel 9y agoThat's entirely down to configuration on the target. Guacamole is just an in browser client, so it depends how the server is set up. For VNC, if your server is set up using X11VNC then you will be logging into the existing session, whereas if you set it up it TightVNC or Vnc4Server (can't remember what's in the Ubuntu repos) then it will be a separate session.
- zbraniecki 9y agohmm, I thought guacamole has both server and client. The target machine is Ubuntu 17.10 on Wayland. Not sure if X11VNC will work with that :(
- bitwize 9y agoRDP dude. Or something like GoToMyPC. Open-source solutions for things like this are generally developed as infrastructure, or a basis for future work. Proprietary solutions are built for people to actually use.
- sandos 9y agoSearching for guacamole on github combined with recently updated shows a lot of unrelated repos. Apparently there is a github tutorial which uses a guacamole recipe, which makes searching for related things hard. I was trying to find an updated docker image for example.
- joncampbelldev 9y agoGoogle tends to be better than most in-site search, especially github. "guacamole docker" returns a whole page of helpful resources (github, dockerhub etc)
- gkya 9y agoClientless is a confusing term. The client seems to be served at an HTTP endpoint as a one page JS application.
- bitwize 9y agoWe're living in the age of the serverless Web, not to mention the meaningless technical term.
- dawnerd 9y agoI used it for a while in a docker container on my unraid server and it does work but is quite buggy still. Often will freeze up and require a restart.
- JustinAiken 9y agoI've been using it with the FileZilla docker in unraid; works but buggy describes it pretty well.
- dalore 9y agoOk, anyone offering it as a service? Would be nice to have a low power laptop just to connect to a high powered guacamole instance, with IDEs and development tools installed. Able to snapshot etc.
- marktangotango 9y agoI was wondering this too. I've been considering implementing a frontend "as a service" with it and charging something like a $10 annual fee. My use is I have a restrictive firewall at work to circumvent, would anyone else find a hosted quacamole solution worthwhile?
- manigandham 9y agoSimilar: https://www.paperspace.com/ https://www.paperspace.com/ https://aws.amazon.com/workspaces/ https://aws.amazon.com/workspaces/
- shadoxx 9y agoI'm gearing up to offer this as a service by the middle of next year. However, I have a couple fully functioning proofs of concept that I need people to test. If you'd like to get in on it, shoot me a PM.
- marktangotango 9y agoThere is no pm here?
- asadlionpk 9y agoHi, I would like to try this.
- niutech 9y agoIsn't the Desktop as a Service what you need? If yes, check out OVH Virtual Cloud Desktop (https://www.ovh.co.uk/cloud/cloud-desktop/ https://www.ovh.co.uk/cloud/cloud-desktop/) or Amazon WorkSpaces.
- saycheese 9y ago"Thanks to HTML5" - what specifically in HTML5 enables this?
- matteuan 9y agocanvas, for example
- have_faith 9y agoWhat happens if you use Guacamole to log into a remote machine, and then use a browser on the remote machine to use Guacamole to control the initial client machine?
- lr4444lr 9y agoSounds like the premise for a Douglas Hofstadter book.
- rsp1984 9y agoQuestion with the risk of sounding very stupid: I get that you don't need to install anything on the controlling machine, but what about the controlled machine? I suppose you need to install some kind of software there? There needs to be some kind of access control, no? I didn't see anything on the website though. Which utterly obvious piece of the equation thing am I missing?
- mjpa 9y agoIt does say... "once Guacamole is installed on a server" so one would guess you do need Guacamole installed on the controlled machine...
- emsy 9y agoYes, you need a remote desktop server like VNC or RDP (or an SSH Server if you want a SSH session)
- mjpa 9y agoSeems I'm the idiot then, missed the "gateway" bit... so this basically sits between something providing VNC/RDP and makes it accessible with just a web server?
- rplnt 9y agoI don't think that's enough, according to the video at least.
- emsy 9y agoUsually, you need an RDP client and a remote RDP server. In Guacamole, the "RDP client" part is handled by the Guacamole server. The HTML 5 frontend that users see is not a fully fledged RDP client, but merely a display and input device for the Guacamole server, which is the actual RDP client.
- emsy 9y agoWe've used Guacamole in production with a custom frontend. It's nice to work with and most problems I've encountered were covered in the old forums on SourceForge. For anyone planning to implement a custom frontend I'd recommend using WebSockets exclusively. We've had trouble with XHR based connections.
- SadWebDeveloper 9y agoAre we going back to dumb-machines (aka Thin Clients)? Seems like half the comments here are for people working entirely "on the cloud".
- intrasight 9y agoI wouldn't say "going back" - the smart crowd never left them ;)
- alexc05 9y agoI am really getting tired of programmer's "cute names for things". I recently went through training on adobe experience manager and literally every single internal technology was named for something that had no bearing on what it actually did. Felix, Sling, Jackrabbit ... I just did a quick google on the AEM tech stack and got the following choice quote which I feel perfectly illustrates the meaninglessness of Apache's naming "Apache Felix is to Apache Sling what Equinox is to Eclipse." what does any of that mean or do?! I'd very much prefer if the named Guacamole the "Apache clientless remote desktop gateway"
- vijaybritto 9y agoGuacamole is way easier to remember than Apache Clientless Remote Desktop Gateway. Also while seeking help it's a lot less characters, so people wouldn't be annoyed by typing.
- lojack 9y agoOr, worse yet, what it’d turn into.... Apache CRDG
- guhidalg 9y agoDid you forget the /s ? My eyes must be deceiving me. When I hear Apache Guacamole, I'm thinking of Native American / Mexican fusion food.
- davidkuhta 9y agoIt could also be intended to conjuring up imagery of yourself relaxing on an island in the Caribbean drinking a margarita, eating chips and Guacamole. A gateway to a clientless, remote, desktop getaway.
- ams6110 9y agoDisagree. Just because the name is longer doesn't mean it's harder to remember, because "Apache Clientless Remote Desktop Gateway" is much more descriptive. Like GP, the trend over the last decade or so to use meaningless names for tech products is one of my biggest annoyances. Occasionally something gains such enough popularity that it doesn't matter ("Google") but in most cases these names are only meaningful to the people who work with these products every day and for everone else it's alphabet soup.
- swypych 9y agoThey are trying to create a brand, something catchy that will be remembered. "Apache clientless remote desktop gateway" just does not have the same ring to it.
- yebyen 9y agoApache Guacamole is at least 1000 days old, according to the top comment on this post which was made 500 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11744430 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11744430
- gressquel 9y agoCitrix has a html5 client. I think it just transfers png files
- danellis 9y agoIs it Apache Guacamole because it was a holey guacamole?
- mxuribe 9y agoYeah, TeamViewer is certainly decent enough, but I'm always looking for other open source remote desktop access mechanisms (especially now that my current day job is pretty restrictive with the laptops they issue us). I had never heard of this Apache Guacamole, but will certainly give it a try!
- daddykotex 9y agoHere is an interview at Software Engineering Daily with Mike Jumper: https://softwareengineeringdaily.com/2016/06/27/apache-guacamole-and-remote-desktop-with-mike-jumper/ https://softwareengineeringdaily.com/2016/06/27/apache-guaca...
- sp332 9y agoCan you copy and paste text out of it? Can you drag & drop files into it? Can you print to a local printer from the remote session?
- Rickasaurus 9y agoCan you control all of these things with permissioning via an auth server of some kind?
- jasonellis 9y agoYes on copy and paste, though you have to use a text box in the browser window (a menu on the left side) to mess with the clipboard. It's not ideal, but it's possible. I cannot remember drag & drop files off the top of my head, but I seem to think no. Not sure about local printer.
- DrPhish 9y agoPrinting is enabled by they system generating PDFs that the browser automatically downloads. It actually works pretty slick. File drag-and-drop can be set up via a couple of different mechanisms, and isn't easy to get going, but works fine once you have it going.
- joncrane 9y agoHow well does it scale to many simultaneous users? I am using this for a side project. We have training classes where sometimes 10-20 students connect to Windows servers using RDP. At times we get a weird key sticking/lagging bug. We haven't figured out how to fix it; we think it's a JVM memory issue but we're not sure.
- shiftpgdn 9y agoI want to throw in a thumbs up for Guacamole. I deployed it two years ago to allow us to demo our software for big enterprise clients who can't easily install things on their office computers. I can rapidly deploy an Azure Server 2012 VM set to kiosk mode with our software installed in under a minute. Enterprise clients can then login from anywhere and get a fast controlled demo of our software. A few months ago I also threw out our crappy old Citrix deployment and replaced it with Guacamole. When hurricane Harvey hit we had 50+ engineers working remotely without a single hiccup. It was a lifesaver.
- voidmain0001 9y agoIf your environment is MS Win, may I please have more detail on how you threw out Citrix. Guacamole is not providing multiple sessions to a single computer, rather that's the functionality of a broker such as Microsoft Terminal Server (termdd.sys) which allows for multiple sessions connected to the console of a computer, likewise for Citrix. For your 50+ engineers to work remotely, they would have had to have been connected to 50 unique computers via the Guacamole Server, or you still have a Citrix server and Guacamole has replaced the Citrix ICA client... [The web application deployed to the Guacamole server reads the Guacamole protocol and forwards it to guacd, the native Guacamole proxy. This proxy actually interprets the contents of the Guacamole protocol, connecting to any number of remote desktop servers on behalf of the user.|https://guacamole.incubator.apache.org/doc/gug/guacamole-architecture.html https://guacamole.incubator.apache.org/doc/gug/guacamole-arc...]
- shiftpgdn 9y agoOur Citrix deployment was ONLY connection brokering. Engineers here work on 12-40 core desktops with 64-256GB of local ram. Unfortunately the workload isn't suited for VDI.
- exikyut 9y agoHuh, I'm very curious what it is you're doing. On the one hand I immediately think of CAD, but that hates remote desktop solutions. The only thing left is mass client simulation/networking simulation, but you just said virtualization won't work for your use case.
- Jass_ack 9y agoNow that logo is something ugly
- faragon 9y agoGuacamole is "clientless" at following cost: ("SS": Session Server (where the session is running), "GS": Gateway Server (where the protocol translation is performed from RDP -or VNC- to custom HTML5), "WC": web client) - At SS, compress images using the RDP -or VNC- protocol. Cost: CPU, RAM, and RAM bandwidth, because of desktop render, delta analyzer, image compression for the RDP -or VNC- protocol, image-specific compression (e.g. RLE in if a old protocol is negotiated), lossless compression ("bulk"), encapsulation, bandwidth/frame control, transfer. - TCP transport between the SS and the GS. Cost: LAN traffic. - At GS, decompress the RDP -or VNC- protocol in the "gateway" server (bulk lossless decompressor, and image decompressor -e.g. RLE for basic protocol negotiation-). Cost: mainly CPU. - At GS, compress the the images in a format suitable for the web client. Cost: mainly CPU. - Send the images via websocket from the GS to the WC. Cost: WAN traffic. - Decompress and render the images in the web client. Cost: client CPU and RAM. Then, you have to dimension how many GS you need per SS, routing between the WAN the GS, how do you balance both the SS and the GS, high availability setup, etc. TL;DR: data is compressed and decompressed twice, because of the protocol conversion, involving extra latency because of more time for compression/decompression and more hops.
- z3t4 9y agoFor VNC there's https://github.com/novnc/noVNC https://github.com/novnc/noVNC
- geonnave 9y agoThe video demo of this tool is fantastic! It is a simple "showing by doing", that also gives a show while showing (pun kind of intended).
- placeybordeaux 9y agoWow the install looks like a pain in the ass.
- userpass 9y agoI've tried it. It is.
- kisstheblade 9y agoIt wasn't difficult, two dockers and a mysql db. Unfortunately it didn't actually work, the vnc lib segfaulted. Just use nomachine, it's worth it. Clients for all os:es.
- kisstheblade 9y agoTested this, installed the docker versions (which should "just work"). The vnc library segfaulted immediately, didn't work. How can this fail even if they have built docker images with presumably the correct libraries?
- niutech 9y agoOlder thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8166388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8166388