3 ms·
This isn't news, it's gossip. ~200 instead of ~1500 means the bootstrapping is a little off schedule. It's stories like this and the attitude that they're imp
by colechristensen 9y ago
This isn't news, it's gossip. ~200 instead of ~1500 means the bootstrapping is a little off schedule.
It's stories like this and the attitude that they're important which gets us very destructive behaviors like putting production quota ahead of quality. Production misses are news when they're for substantial cause. Like a 10% miss for an S or X might be news.
- abakker 9y agoYes, but it is news for investors. Missing productions goals as a startup is different than missing production numbers as a public company that is arguably quite overvalued. It matters because if it effects their share price, that can have important downstream effects on their eventual ability to execute (e.g. secure more loans). Edit: I am not trying to say that Tesla should be punished, but am specifically addressing that it is, in fact, news.
- colechristensen 9y agoIt is especially not news for investors. It encourages terrible behavior when people focus on this sort of dumb number. Projecting problems and solutions at the beginning of production is more or less impossible. Valuing a company based on the accuracy of what is litte more than random noise makes you a bad investor, making it a headline news story makes you a bad editor. It's only news if it shows an _actual_ problem instead of showing what it actually shows ... which is random chance pushing around production scaling schedules.
- jryle80 9y agoIt's news because Tesla projected to have delivered 1,500 Model 3 by end of 3rd quarter. They missed that milestone. Simple as that. I wouldn't read too much into this myself. Scaling production is hard. Regardless, it's an important metric that speaks to Tesla's ability to deliver, at least short term.
- bisRepetita 9y agoAre you saying one should not value a company based on what they're saying? Then in Q2 when they wrote "Based on our preparedness at this time, we are confident we can produce just over 1,500 vehicles in Q3", then we should not believe them. So why do they bother saying this? If they got an uplift then, they get punished a bit now, that's fair, life goes on.
- sjwright 9y agoThe only question is how this affects the ongoing production ramp-up. A relatively short delay on the delivery of a thousand cars is barely a rounding error to the underlying business case, and won't have any lasting consequences once they've ramped up production to full speed.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt's not news investors should give a great deal of importance to, but it is news aimed squarely at investors, by Tesla itself.
- prostoalex 9y ago> Valuing a company based on the accuracy of what is litte more than random noise makes you a bad investor Some investors will value on random noise, and some other investors will figure this out and capture the mispricing, if there's any.
- lafar6502 9y agoSo why bother about Tesla at all? It’s all hot air...
- prostoalex 9y agoSignificant portion of TSLA float is short https://ycharts.com/companies/TSLA/short_interest https://ycharts.com/companies/TSLA/short_interest and that's before we get into the options activity, so any whiff of news usually impacts those side games in a significant way. There's a strong incentive for either side to overblow a piece of news that fits their agenda.
- refurb 9y agoIf Musk hadn't promised 1500 units, then you're right, it wouldn't be a big deal.
- utopkara 9y agoYield is a real mass production problem, not an imaginary one. You can verify it with your local manufacturer. For new products, new facilities, and new production methods scaling up the production often requires engineering breakthroughs.
- kec 9y agoHow is being ~80% under quota not news? Such a large miss means that either Tesla is being unrealistically optimistic about their production capability, or they have serious production problems.
- sowbug 9y agoBecause "~80% under quota" isn't a meaningful way to assess the schedule slip. They're still a few weeks/months off from mass production of the Model 3.
- colechristensen 9y agoThere are something like half a million Model 3 preorders. They just started production, 200 or 1500 – both are but a rounding error compared to the actual full production rate. (order of 10k/quarter) It's something like criticizing someone for running 75 feet instead of 400 in the first 45 seconds of their third marathon because they had to re-tie their shoes.
- refurb 9y agoWell considering sometimes tripping up in the beginning of a marathon can mean you lose the race, I'd say it's a very important number.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- colechristensen 9y agoThen what isn't an important number? Is everything worth a headline? How do you select what is and is not noteworthy or important for an investor or news consumer? Why is Tesla missing it's Model 3 targets at the very beginning of the production run (hundreds of cars) more relevant than the Model S and X productions exceeding targets by "several thousand"? Looking at the first two columns of WSJ tech page that lists that article ... articles are on (Apple, Tesla, Google, Facebook, Goldman Sachs/Bitcoin, Uber). Looking at that list of companies, would you guess that WSJ's editors are pushing the most relevant and important information, or the information their readers want the most? One is gossip, the other is news. People gravitating towards the news they want to see and news producing information tailored for their audience is the greatest force of evil in the 21st century. Popularity drives every news outlet to the bottom until you can't tell the difference between TMZ and WSJ. Where do I go if I want to read actual news instead of the business gossip column?
- dogruck 9y agoIt's not a "story" -- it's an investor relations press release.