4 ms·
Actual source: http://ir.tesla.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=1042449 http://ir.tesla.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=1042449 OT: Sad how difficult it was to
by modeless 9y ago
Actual source: http://ir.tesla.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=1042449 http://ir.tesla.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=1042449
OT: Sad how difficult it was to find this. The media avoids linking to primary sources. For example, Engadget's 3 paragraph article contains no less than 5 links back to engadget.com and not a single mention of this source.
- colechristensen 9y agoThis is a press release which was likely delivered to wsj et al through a wire service they pay to deliver them piles and piles of press releases. Nobody quotes those as sources because nobody but news organizations that pay for them has access to them. A press release is also a rather bad primary source unlike, say, a research paper or a blog post.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe text on the Tesla website mentions https://globenewswire.com/ https://globenewswire.com/ Anyone can setup a real time account for free. Also the WSJ article pretty clearly used the press release as a source, so mentioning that is a separate issue from whether it is a good or bad source. (unless you think the WSJ called Tesla and verified specific facts like "4,820 Model S and X vehicles were in transit" vs "The company said 4,820 vehicles were in transit at the end of the quarter")
- utopkara 9y agoThe newswire is the distributor of the press release. It is equivalent to Tesla emailing all major news outlets; just more convenient and reliable. In short, Tesla is the source.
- dilemma 9y agoThe press release was created to provide information to news organizations. It is extremely odd to say they are not good sources.
- parent5446 9y agoIt's a first-person source, coming from the company itself. Thus it's inherently biased toward the company and not the best source. This is as opposed to when the news article itself is a primary source, which is achieved by a reporter actually reporting what is happening in-person at the source of the event. Of course, in this case it's a bit hard, since the only insight into Tesla's production goals is what they report externally, barring leaks and whatnot. A press release from the company is pretty much the best we can get. But just because it's the best doesn't mean it's necessarily good.
- dilemma 9y agoLike your second paragraph expresses, a press release id from the company itself is the absolute best source on their production numbers.
- parent5446 9y agoAnd as the very last sentence of my second paragraph says, "just because it's the best doesn't mean it's necessarily good". Your original post says "it is extremely odd to say they are not good sources".
- unepipe 9y agoYou do realize that Tesla is a publicly traded company, and what you are saying (that they would misrepresent production numbers) would be securities fraud. They publicly stated their goals: https://www.forbes.com/sites/alanohnsman/2017/08/02/tesla-stays-in-the-red-but-sticks-with-rapid-model-3-production-plan/#6671009c6e47 https://www.forbes.com/sites/alanohnsman/2017/08/02/tesla-st...) They did not reach their goals. No need for paranoia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securities_fraud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securities_fraud
- parent5446 9y agoWhere did I say that they misrepresented their production numbers, or committed securities fraud? In any case it's not paranoia. No matter what the law is, a press release is a first-party source. It is inherently biased toward the company. By no means should it be compared to an independent source, such as a report from an auditor or independent regulators.
- dx034 9y agoPress releases are usually free. Companies use third party providers to ensure that every investor/subscriber receives information at exactly the same time. Paying for company publications is extremely uncommon. For a public company I'm not even sure if that wouldn't be illegal. You can still pay for premium services (via Bloomberg, Thomson Reuters, etc) but subscribing to company news releases can be easily done by just visiting a company's investor relations website.
- prostoalex 9y agoWSJ content management system might be print-first and Web-secondary.
- Stratoscope 9y ago> Engadget's 3 paragraph article contains no less than 5 links back to engadget.com and not a single mention of this source. That's Engadget's house style. They forbid external links the the body of an article, only allowing links within their own site. The best you can hope for is a single hard-to-find link at the end. They've done it this way for years. It sucks. It's one of the reasons I never read anything on Engadget except by mistake.
- toephu2 9y agoI found it quite easily in a few clicks actually. I too wanted to see the original so I just googled "tesla ir", clicked first link, then at the bottom of the page I saw 'Recent Releases' and clicked 'Tesla Q3 2017 Vehicle Deliveries and Production'
- unepipe 9y agoThe comment was clearly critiquing Engadget's journalism (lack of original source citation). The comment was not regarding the quality of Google's search engine results for given keywords.