4 ms·
I think we're basically in a worse version of the Android fragmentation / device support issue. At least with Android, Google is forcing manufacturers to have
by kelnos 9y ago
I think we're basically in a worse version of the Android fragmentation / device support issue.
At least with Android, Google is forcing manufacturers to have a minimum security patch lifetime. There's no one in a position to require or enforce that among the tens (hundreds?) of thousands of home/SOHO routers models out there.
I expect we'd maybe be able to get some of the big players (Netgear, Linksys, D-Link, etc.) to agree individually to support products with security updates for X amount of time, but it's still dicey. I used to work for one of them[0], and often the people internally who own the products don't even know enough about the software running on them to even be aware of security issues. They're entirely at the mercy of the outsourced software firm for that. The margins are low enough (and price competition high enough) that you're not going to see much effort without consumer support. That is, consumers being actively willing in large numbers to pay more for a more secure product (so, that's not happening).
If we could go by a model where everything was based on a third party, like OpenWRT or LEDE, and if the appliances could auto-update in-place from the upstream package repositories (nothing run by manufacturers or the software integrators), then that might work, but the manufacturers would have a hard time supporting it, as I'd expect there to be a lot of random breakage.
I'm not sure there's a great solution here. Savvy consumers will pick a brand that has a strong track record with security (perhaps buying SMB or enterprise-grade products), or will flash 3rd-party firmware that they can maintain and upgrade themselves. The masses are pretty much lost and dependent on a commodity industry that has little incentive to pay close attention to security, and a lot of incentive (in the form of cost and pricing pressure) to ignore all but the worst security problems.
[0] This was 2004-2009, so things may have changed, but I'm not expecting much.
- wmf 9y agoIf we could go by a model where everything was based on a third party, like OpenWRT or LEDE, and if the appliances could auto-update in-place from the upstream package repositories (nothing run by manufacturers or the software integrators), then that might work, but the manufacturers would have a hard time supporting it, as I'd expect there to be a lot of random breakage. Yep, I'm enjoying my OnHub.
- the8472 9y ago> At least with Android, Google is forcing manufacturers to have a minimum security patch lifetime. There's no one in a position to require or enforce that among the tens (hundreds?) of thousands of home/SOHO routers models out there. ISPs bundle routers with their contracts. So if their customers get attacked through hardware that they supplied they will have at least some incentive to put pressure on the upstream manufacturers.