4 ms·
"cannot delete messages" Well, notmuch doesn't delete messages itself by design. But you can delete messages by other means, using tags to designate the messa
by pmoriarty 9y ago
"cannot delete messages"
Well, notmuch doesn't delete messages itself by design. But you can delete messages by other means, using tags to designate the messages you want deleted. This really doesn't seem to be a big hurdle.
"cannot have copies in multiple folders ... no notion of folders"
I hear people talking about notmuch and folders a lot, and I can understand why if they're still using other clients to access their mail -- clients that can't deal with mail using just tags. But if you've moved completely to using notmuch, then using tags only and forgetting about folders seems like the way to go.
"cannot apply a tag to an individual message without passing by the threaded view first"
If you have the message open, you should be able to apply a tag to it using (notmuch-show-add-tag).
That said, I have my own gripes with notmuch:
Notmuch doesn't have scoring, it doesn't have BBDB integration, it has no way to get arbitrary message headers from elisp, it only indexes a handful of headers, it can't do regex searches of everything.
- usernam 9y agoIf you're using IMAP, deletion is a thing. I often get people sending me huge stuff I have no intention to keep or sync. I need to be able to sync the deletion flag. This is a one line change I did myself and used for a long time, but it doesn't get merged because as messages are currently indexed by message-id, tagging a message for deletion might involve more than one actual underlying message. I also use folders as a mean to exclude useless stuff from syncing. Spam is the most glamorous example: I do not sync spam. I was able to get spam to be moved in/out according to a tag, but only with afew, and again with other issues involved. Doable, but again, ... Also, notmuch in emacs is very much thread oriented. But with email, I found the behavior very annoying. People will mail you in response to a 1yr old message, and notmuch will happily bring and show the thread from something which is completely unrelated. I found myself switching in/out of tree mode too often, and then just gave up. I actually enjoyed (and still enjoy) Gnus much more. It's just more efficient for large message volumes. It shows you what's _new_ by default, which notmuch doesn't seem to get right.