3 ms·
I like it but there are some major questions: 1. What kind of stem cells do you get from bone marrow pluripotent? 2. Do we know how long samples last in cryo-
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
I like it but there are some major questions:
1. What kind of stem cells do you get from bone marrow pluripotent?
2. Do we know how long samples last in cryo-preservation? Eg. is there any example of a 60 year old stem cell that was able to actually seed something biologically functional?
3. Is there a roadmap for some system that tells the user how and when they would request their cells to be used? Or is it just based on when their hypothetical doctor says they need to collect them?
4. Assuming you donate at 30 and live till 90, you are paying ~$17,000 to store these cells. What kind of likelihood do you see on getting $17,000 worth of value out of storing these. Asked another way:
If I was 90 and had a two stem cells in front of me at the stem cell market one that was free and was 90 years old and one that was 17,000 and was 30 years old, would the 30 year old one be worth the 17,000? Or do we know yet?
- markkat 9y ago1. There may be few pluripotent cells in what we collect, but the majority of stem cells collected are multipotent (mesenchymal and hematopoietic lineages). 2. We haven't been cryopreserving stem cells for 60 years, so that is impossible to know. However, there is evidence that bone mesenchymal stem cells can be stored for more than 20 years: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22280954 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22280954 In my own experience, I have used cell lines that were stored more than 30 years, and primary cells stored more than a decade. Evidence suggests that the freezing and thawing process have the greatest impact, and that time in liquid nitrogen does not. 3. Once collected, you have a dashboard where you can log in and see/request your cells. We are working on rejuvenation therapies that employ these cells, so such a roadmap might develop should we have success. 4. I would not venture a guess.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoThanks, great answers.
- estroz 9y agoIn response to answer 2: how do you account for the risk of storage invalidating stem cells after 60 years, if you've only experienced useful 30 year-old cell lines? Put another way, why would I pay $7,000 if neither you nor I knew if my cells would still be useful to treat disease when I'm 80, assuming I stored them at 20? Do you have a method of propagation in intervals, ex. thaw, expand each set of cells every 10 years, and re-freeze? You mentioned in an above comment[0] that you'd need a clinical trial to have the legal ability, so perhaps not? [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15386671 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15386671
- markkat 9y agoWe aren't propagating at intervals currently. However, it's something that could be done; batch samples could be set aside for that purpose alone, also, one control sample could be divided and tested every 5 years. It's an interesting question: if I culture my cells after 20 years, then preserve them for 20 more, is the viability higher than 40 years of preservation alone? Thanks for the question.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]