3 ms·
I'd love to know how can you provide such proof or what you would expect as proof. We've advertised for a senior programmer position for months and had very lit
by gambiting 9y ago
I'd love to know how can you provide such proof or what you would expect as proof. We've advertised for a senior programmer position for months and had very little local(national) uptake. Almost nothing. Then we hired someone from abroad, but 99% because they were one of few people who actually applied.
Does that mean that we could never ever fill this position with a local person? How do you prove that?
What makes it more complicated is that it's extremely easy for someone to say "just offer 2x the salary and someone will come" - and that's probably true, but it's extremely ignorant of other market factors in the area.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> We've advertised for a senior programmer position for months and had very little local(national) uptake. Almost nothing. Then we hired someone from abroad, but 99% because they were one of few people who actually applied. What pay are you offering for the role? > What makes it more complicated is that it's extremely easy for someone to say "just offer 2x the salary and someone will come" - and that's probably true, but it's extremely ignorant of other market factors in the area. It is easy to say that when labor law isn't favorable to importing labor from other countries, which as a US citizen I am in favor of. If your business can't support a wage that attracts talent without importing someone from another country, perhaps that's a problem with the business fundamentals. As a citizen of my country, my fellow citizens are my primary concern, not someone's business. We all have our ideals that have been shaped by our life experiences.
- gambiting 9y agoThis might be a surprise, but there are your "fellow citizens" who run a business too, it's not an "us vs them" issue. >>What pay are you offering for the role? Any answer to that would just trigger a reply of "just pay more" which I don't believe is the answer to the problem. Mostly because in a finite labor pool there's always going to be a shortage and a bidding war will lead to anyone knowing what a keyboard looks like being worth 6-digit salaries.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> This might be a surprise, but there are your "fellow citizens" who run a business too, it's not an "us vs them" issue. This is not a surprise, but also, it doesn't provide a pass to want labor at below market clearing prices. You have listed a role, and it has gone unfilled for quite some time; you are not paying enough, but do not like the market conditions that allow for the scenario to play out. If you truly believe the salary you're offering is competitive for the role, I encourage you to continue to list the role until you fill it. Employers have become accustom to cheap labor over the last decade; now that the labor market has tightened, it will take them some time to adapt to the conditions. [1] [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-06/it-s-boom-times-for-recruiters-as-u-s-job-market-tightens https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-06/it-s-boom...
- KGIII 9y agoTongue in cheek; Masters required, Ph.D. preferred, 10 years experience in Rust, must be willing to relocate, 7 years experience with Windows 10 required, generous salary starting at $60,000/year. Not too long ago, I was helping a friend find a job and was a bit startled by some of the requirements. One that really stuck out was needing a few years of experience in a Java version that was still in the beta phase. (I think it was 8.) I don't know if it's an HR issue, a communications issue, or what... I'd speculate that it is intentional, so that they can claim they can't find local talent and justify hiring from abroad. Call it a hunch... I'm not sure why companies are so against training, but I suppose that's a topic for another thread.
- Apocryphon 9y agoThe aversion of modern tech companies, and companies in many industries besides, to training new hires is mind-boggling. I suppose in the startup world the lack of resources to do so is in part justifiable. So resources end up being poured bidding for the few qualified senior engineers instead. Or lobbying to continue to be able to hire from abroad.
- mfoy_ 9y agoSame thing at my company. We've been trying to fill out our team roster for the better part of a year and ended up hiring from overseas to find the talent and relocate them to the region. To be fair, we didn't have zero local interest, but the applicants we did get were a fairly interesting parade of awful.