6 ms·
What? You're phrasing something that you don't actually know as a fact that you know? That's called lying. You recognize it by learning to not lie and deceive p
by drivebyacct2 16y ago
What? You're phrasing something that you don't actually know as a fact that you know? That's called lying. You recognize it by learning to not lie and deceive people as a child.
Not sure what else to tell you. If you're passing off knowledge you pulled out your ass and are getting called on it, maybe you shouldn't do that. If it's speculation or if you're trying to be helpful but don't know for sure, then phrase it that way. Or if you can't take the criticism just keep your nose out of it.
I don't understand where the disconnect is to be honest.
- spiffytech 16y agoSpeaking a mistruth and lying are not the same thing. I sometimes think I'm telling the truth, but my facts are wrong. I'm not trying to deceive. I'm not just pulling things out of my butt, either. For example, I spend a lot of time researching new technologies, but rarely have the time to become proficient with them. This is very similar to the kind of learning you may do in a classroom; I've never made an electromagnet, but thanks to my physics class I can tell you about them. Sometimes I say something incorrect. Sometimes someone with more experience disputes my claims and I don't have the knowledge and experience to rebut them, or to know if they're really right. Modern society is founded on feeding off of each other's knowledge and experiences; if we all spoke only about what we knew very well, and first-hand, we'd say all very little. I'm humble enough to admit when I'm wrong, but I'm trying to be wrong less often. It makes me look incredible.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoI guess I still don't understand what you're looking for as an answer. Logically there are only a few paths to "be wrong less often". 1. Become an expert in everything. 2. Stop talking about the things that you're unsure of. 3. Preface the things you're unsure of with "I'm unsure, but I think". If you're worried about looking incredible (and not in the good connotation) because you are saying too many things along the lines of "I think..." then stop doing it or learn to be confident that your expertise in the places where you have it will shine. What others paths are there here for "be[ing] wrong less often"? Am I missing some hidden deeper question at play here?
- Robin_Message 16y ago4. Get better at generalising knowledge and reasoning to new areas. When you get it wrong, look at why. Were you missing a crucial fact? Then how could you have found that fact out, and other facts like it. Is your reasoning faulty? Get better at reasoning. Did you make an unfounded assumption? Check your assumptions better. Did you ignore something without good reason? Don't. Is their something special about working in this field? Learn that stuff. Are you expected to have background knowledge? Grab some of that. ... I guess that's really a solution to 1 though.
- spiffytech 16y agoI do preface things I'm unsure of as you suggest, but sometimes I'm wrong about things I am sure of. I'm trying to figure out whether this is a problem with my definition of "sure of", whether I just need to do more research and get more experience on topics in general before talking about them, or whether there's some indication I may not know what I'm talking about that I just haven't found yet. I'm asking in the hopes that other people have solved this problem for themselves, and could say how.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoIf you were misinformed or were just simply plain wrong (aka you thought you knew something as solid fact) then... you were wrong. Life goes on. I mean, if this is happening a lot, you properly need to question the threshold at which you consider yourself having "known" something, or you need to read more closely, but being wrong isn't the end of the world.
- nollidge 16y ago> I'm trying to figure out whether this is a problem with my definition of "sure of" I should this is obvious. If you're "sure of" false things a lot, obviously something is going wrong. Try not to be so sure of things.
- Twisol 16y agoI generally try to source everything I say, if it's beyond a certain amount of common sense or complexity. Just the act of looking up sources before hitting that button (and often in the middle of writing the post) help me catch most of my mistakes. At least, I haven't been called out on a mistake very often. If I can't source something, I usually clearly note that in some way.
- Jun8 16y agoCalling it lying is going overboard. Sometime what happens is that people overgeneralize from the domain they know to domains they don't. Engineers, because we are problem solvers, are especially prone to do this, whenever we are given a problem, we like to offer a solution.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoI feel like I'm repeating myself in my replies and I do apologize, but I feel that there is a distinction between outright making something up, asserting assumptions as false and being wrong. I think that if you preface something with "I think...", you're disclosing the fact that you are unsure or are making an assumption and that that falls outside the realm of this discussion, generally.
- spiffytech 16y agoDisclosure works in the situations when one is unsure of one's facts. The question extends beyond that situation, though. When you say something wrong that you were sure of your credibility is damaged at least as badly as if you said something you were unsure of. I appreciate the advice of disclosure that you and many others in this topic have given, and I will definitely be more arduous in disclosing when I am unsure of something, or just plain stay quiet. I would, however, still like to address not speaking incorrectly when I'm sure of my facts.
- Robin_Message 16y agoIt's not lying. For some people "fact you know" is not a well-defined category. If you are smart and good at inferring stuff, and you know some facts, then maybe you can go further. Maybe you can provide insights. You can certainly appear more knowledgeable than you are (you aren't, you're working things out as you go along, which isn't guaranteed to be correct.) What it is unfortunately is intellectually arrogant. I saw a great comment from roel_v (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1535064 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1535064) about this (reproduced below). If the benefits are working out for you (you look smart, you're right often enough) then great. But if you keep getting called out, and you're worried about that, then you need to equivocate more. You also need to become more aware of the unknown unknowns. It's all very well knowing some things, and guessing others, but you also need to know what you actually know and what you don't, otherwise you'll not only look stupid, but at some point you'll also do something really dumb too. "95% of legal chatter amongst technical people on the internet is meaningless to lawyers ('meaningless' as in 'jibberish', 'flux capacitor'-style nonsense) - because the fundamental assumptions and reasoning methods are so vastly different"
- logic 16y agoYou don't understand, yet feel qualified to attribute his problem to a character flaw. Interesting. It appears you may have the same problem as the original poster.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoI didn't mean to suggest that he is a compulsive liar or is a bad person, but I think it's deceitful to pass assumptions off as facts. I don't know whether he is specifically referring to making things up (which I see as deceitful and thus lying), asserting assumptions as truth (which I see is a gray light), or simply being wrong. Being wrong is one thing. If I tell you 2+2=5 and you tell someone else thinking that it's a fact, then you aren't acting intentionally in your deceit. If you just start making assumptions on your own and assert them as truth, I feel like that takes a certain amount of effort in a dishonest direction.
- gregwebs 16y agoBy your own logic you are a liar. Fortunately most dictionaries disagree with you. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/lie http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/lie http://definr.com/lying http://definr.com/lying To safely call a statement a lie according to all definitions it must be false, but more importantly it must be said knowing that is false (having an intent to deceive).
- drivebyacct2 16y agoI feel like I differentiated between making stuff up, being unsure and simply being wrong. The 'lying' is mostly an attribution to making things up or asserting assumptions as fact which I still would consider deceitful. edit: I may not have differentiated that as well as I had thought in my original post. In another comment on this comment level, I tried to differentiate between the various types of "being wrong" and/or their causes.