5 ms·
This series is rather spoiled by the author's determination to trash Galileo's reputation. While he definitely has a point about simplistic, hagiographical acco
by mannykannot 9y ago
This series is rather spoiled by the author's determination to trash Galileo's reputation. While he definitely has a point about simplistic, hagiographical accounts of Galileo's contributions, especially those that present geocentrists as being blind to the obvious, he goes on about it at length, introducing some rather weak and self-serving arguments along with the valid ones.
- mcv 9y agoI don't see this as spoiled by any kind of determination to trash Galileo's reputation. Pointing out the reality of Galileo's situation is exactly the point, and to people who believe Galileo's fairy tale, of course that's going to hurt his reputation. This account is actually more careful and nuanced than other accounts of the Galileo trial that I've come across. Another possibly useful insight into Galileo is that he ridiculed Kepler for suggesting that the planets would have elliptical orbits. Galileo could never make his heliocentric model fit the observations, and meant he couldn't convince anyone that it was correct, because it wasn't. Kepler basically saved heliocentrism by proposing a model that worked, and Galileo mocked him for it, because he found non-circular orbits as ridiculous as others found his heliocentric model. Galileo did a lot of important other work, but in the past his role in proving the heliocentric worldview has incorrectly been painted as unrealistically saintly. He was about as wrong as he was right, and he was self-centered and careless.
- Iv 9y agoI am careful about Galileo. You see a lot of Catholics trying to rewrite history by presenting the Galileo trial as a simple scientific debate where Galileo lacked proofs of his hypothesis. Actually I find it very suspicious that the author of this article skips the trial altogether. We have the minutes. We have the judgement. Even if Galileo was an ambitious asshole Ith political afterthoughts, one important fact remains: The Church used the literal interpretation of the Bible to contradict a scientific theory. This is the main point and the main problem of the Galileo trial and why it is significant. Galileo deserved opposition in a debate, not condemnation in a religious tribunal. It happened and the blame is solely on the dogmatism of the church. From this point, science diverged more and more from religious teaching and stopped seeing the church as an ally.
- mcv 9y agoI haven't seen any Catholics yet trying to rewrite this history. I have seen atheists correcting incorrect beliefs about this period of history. I'm protestant and not a fan of the RC church hierarchy, but I do care about an accurate representation of history, and the Galileo trial is muddled with fairy tales and misinterpretations, because people don't know the context. But whatever your religious beliefs are, Galileo did lack proof. His model was wrong. His idea was correct (though originally from Copernicus, of course). But without proof, and without a correct model (which Kepler later provided) there was no way at the time they could know it was correct. There was simply no scientific basis yet to accept it over the existing geocentric model. The RC Church's position on science was not homogenous. Various officials have said that if an interpretation of the bible ever conflicted with verifiable observations, then clearly the interpretation of the bible must be incorrect. Obviously not everybody agreed, but heliocentrism did have its supporters within the church. It was not considered heresy until Galileo made his position impossible and alienated his biggest fan (pope Urban). In any case, Galileo's theory here, his model, was simply incorrect, and they knew it. There was a solid scientific basis to contradict it. They did pile on a bunch of other accusations, but that's primarily because he angered the wrong people. Galileo did receive opposition in debate. His problem is that he didn't accept it. He wanted everybody to accept his model, despite the lack of a scientific basis for it.
- Luc 9y ago> But whatever your religious beliefs are, Galileo did lack proof. His model was wrong. You know who else lacked proof? It didn't bother you just as it didn't bother the inquisition. Maybe try using the same standards for those theocrats as you apply to Galileo.
- Sharlin 9y agoThe whole point is that geocentricism wasn't just dogma, it also happened to match observations. It was the null hypothesis, if you will, and Galileo failed to disprove the null hypothesis.
- mannykannot 9y agoIf the author had left it at that, it would have been a better series.
- hyperpape 9y ago"Galileo was fully aware that if his wished to cash in then he had to get his priority claim in tout suite....Now he had hit the jackpot and needed to cash in fast. He bunged his principal discoveries together in book form....his ego inflated by his recent successes....the sycophantic cheers of [Galileo's] high powered fan club....Beguiled by his silver tongued friend Barberini gave Galileo permission to write and publish a book....it is safe to say that he got stamped on for his hubris....Galileo was never the fearless defender of scientific truth or freedom of speech that his modern fan club like to present him as. He was an extremely egotistical social climber with an eye on the main chance, his own undying fame" I think it's safe to call this an attack on Galileo's reputation. It does match my fuzzy understanding that the story we got in elementary school was not that accurate, but on a personal level, it's pretty mean spirited. In particular, to modern ears, it's pretty jarring to hear a man convicted over scientific arguments described as being "stamped on for his hubris".
- jhbadger 9y agoExactly. It reminds me a lot like the defenders of the Soviet Union's house arrest of the dissident Andrei Sakharov -- the argument was, "He should have known what the reasonable limits of criticism of the government were. And the authorities didn't shoot him or anything the way they would have done in Stalin's time, so they were being quite reasonable".