2 ms·
Well, the difference is boilers are old, and Powerwalls are new. People always discount risks from old things and emphasize risks from new things. Thus, the ris
by smsm42 9y ago
Well, the difference is boilers are old, and Powerwalls are new. People always discount risks from old things and emphasize risks from new things. Thus, the risk of being successfully ruinously sued for boiler manufacturer, if they follow accepted industry practices and something goes wrong, are known, priced in and probably not very high. The risks of the same for manufacturer of a system that has no precedent, no established industry practices and no experience of running it into home environment for decades is much higher. And if something goes wrong, the first question that will be asked would be: why didn't you create a monitoring system?
And, also, whoever made old systems has no option for remote internet monitoring. If they were designed today, the option would probably be added.
> You should not need an Internet connection for anything essential in your home.
You don't need it. Tesla does. And you need Tesla if something goes wrong, thus by extension you need it too.
> Certainly not for something that is marketed to take your "off the grid".
You can really be "off the grid" if you can maintain this system for decades. Can you? How many of average citizens can? Given the newness of technology, you'd probably will go to Tesla for fixes within couple of years for this or that thing, and will repeat that several times over the next decade (if it keeps working). You can manage that loop without internet connection, but the fact is you and Tesla are working together for the life of the product, so why make it harder? You can design the system that works Sneakernet-style, but why?
- sametmax 9y ago> Well, the difference is boilers are old, and Powerwalls are new. People The legal and perception issues are a good point. Annoying, but I get it. > And you need Tesla if something goes wrong, thus by extension you need it too. No, what you mean is that they can get away with it, because among their customer base, more people don't care that people that do. > And you need Tesla if something goes wrong, thus by extension you need it too. Trying to get "off the grid" rarely is extreme to the point that you cut yourself from civilization completely. It's ok to have external help from time to time. It's just that your daily operation should not depends on it.