3 ms·
I don't know of any data that isolates the energy cost of transport and storage of cash. Transactions are tricky, you could use the salary of the worker for the
by layoric 9y ago
I don't know of any data that isolates the energy cost of transport and storage of cash. Transactions are tricky, you could use the salary of the worker for the 5-15 seconds (or however long the handling/counting of cash takes) and equate that to cost of electricity.
Given a retail worker might cost a business $.03 per minute, you are looking at 1c per transaction. Now let's look at BTC. At 9GW when I looked at it, it was processing ~4.5, lets say 5, transactions per second. A kilo-watt-hour (kWh) of electricity will wholesale for 6c. If we are doing 5tx/s, that's 18000 in 1 hour. 9GWh to do 18000 transactions
(9,000,000,000) / (3600 * 5)
Gives us, 500 kWh per transaction, at 6c gives us $30 per transaction.
You might be able to argue subsequent cash handling might take a few minutes per transaction handles, but even so.
So given cash transactions save at least $20 per transaction, cost of transport and storage IMO would be negligable. These costs drop further with something like credit card transactions.
The two biggest problems I see with BitCoin and most PoW currencies (and I'm going to single out BitCoin) are;
1. BitCoin has a maximum transaction speed well below what is required for a world (or country/more localised) enconomy, 7 Tx/s doesn't cut it. VISA apparently does well over 1000+.
2. As mining gets harder, and as the network tries to reach the theoretical transaction speed limit, energy usage grows even more out of control.
9GW is such a massive amount of electricity at the moment. Even as solar + wind + storage becomes cheaper to build and capacities grow, it'll still be a huge amount of electricity and there usage by the BitCoin network will only grow. This is more electricity usage than the state of NSW in Australia _generates_ most of the time. That powers the residential and commercial electrical needs of a 1st world state with 7.5M people.
I think the more cheap power that is available to currencies like BTC, they'll keep using more and more with diminishing returns.