3 ms·
That's absolute nonsense. I shouldn't need to phone home for my electricity to work, it's functioned just fine for a hundred years without Internet access. If
by colechristensen 9y ago
That's absolute nonsense. I shouldn't need to phone home for my electricity to work, it's functioned just fine for a hundred years without Internet access. If you can't build a self-contained system to handle a home-level amount of electricity, you shouldn't be allowed to participate in the market.
- ukulele 9y ago> If you can't build a self-contained system to handle a home-level amount of electricity, you shouldn't be allowed to participate in the market. What if you can do it, but you're not certain of all the possible modes of failure over a decade of use in people's garages?
- DannyBee 9y ago"What if you can do it, but you're not certain of all the possible modes of failure over a decade of use in people's garages? " You aren't serious, right? This is not a new thing to be thinking about. You should be certain of all the possible modes of failure over a decade of use. Otherwise, as the comment said, you shouldn't be allowed to participate in the market. This isn't new secret whizbang technology. The only major difference is battery type. If Tesla doesn't know enough to know what may happen there over a decade of use, ...
- ukulele 9y ago> The only major difference is battery type. That's the part to be worried about.
- new299 9y agoI can understand the reticence in this situation. Lithium Ion batteries are dangerous. When they fail, they can release a lot of energy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAZ62tUtc0w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAZ62tUtc0w The PowerWall seems to be impressively safe: https://electrek.co/2016/12/19/tesla-fire-powerpack-test-safety/ https://electrek.co/2016/12/19/tesla-fire-powerpack-test-saf... But I can still understand a desire to keep in constantly monitored.
- lucaspiller 9y agoI'd like to know what sort of monitoring Tesla does before arguing either way. If they are actively monitoring for devices that are about to catch fire, and if so will call the fire department to come to your house, and your neighbours to evacuate, then sure it makes sense - but I assume they are just monitoring 'usage analytics', and the fault detection could work just as safely by shutting off the device and prompting the user for action, as another comment suggested. It's the same with their cars, although having a constant connection to HQ allows faults to be diagnosed quicker, I'd rather it just show a check engine light and go to a dealer (oh wait...).
- greglindahl 9y agoWell, the standard for the car is that they'll phone the owner a couple of minutes after an accident.
- PinguTS 9y agoBut to maintain a functional safe state, you do not need Internet access. If you need Internet access to maintain a functional safe state, then you are doing it wrong. There is also no reason at all to make availability depending on Internet access. Especially, when you are providing a solution that is intended for a self-contained, self-sufficient use case: "Make" power, store power, use power.
- new299 9y agoI'd totally agree under most circumstances. However, putting a large number, of potentially very dangerous Lithium Ion batteries in peoples home is a new and novel application with potentially fatal consequences. I guess the risk is that there's some unknown failure mode, such as after X hours of continuous discharge there's a higher possibility of thermal runaway etc. Being able to disable a unit, or deploy an updated firmware seems valuable in those situations. At least, this is how I imagine it would be sold to management and users.
- 9y ago