3 ms·
> Wouldn't the obvious answer seem to be to provide certainty factor estimates where varying degrees of evidence are available? The uncertainty involved in his
by jcranmer 9y ago
> Wouldn't the obvious answer seem to be to provide certainty factor estimates where varying degrees of evidence are available?
The uncertainty involved in history is rarely quantifiable. How would you go about attaching a number to, say, the probability that Jesus existed? Where such quantifiability is possible--dates in radiocarbon and demographic estimates come to mind--you in fact do see estimation ranges from historians.
> Anyways, I've rarely ever seen historians qualify their data points.
Having read a few archaeological papers out of curiosity, yes, these data points are often qualified where prudent. This is much less the case in popular history books, but it's worth noting that popular science books are equally egregious in omitting such details.
> Unfortunately humility is only for the scientists, and because they can't escape the same consequences of uncertainty when drawing conclusions from data (i.e. statistical significance).
Let's not put scientists on some holy pedestal here. Having read science papers as well, I can tell you that scientists are quite bad at being humble and qualifying their results with limits of uncertainty.