5 ms·
It is naive to think this battle wasn't going to eventually come to Cloudfare or the Internet as a whole. The US has some of the most extreme laws on allowing
by slg 9y ago
It is naive to think this battle wasn't going to eventually come to Cloudfare or the Internet as a whole. The US has some of the most extreme laws on allowing free speech and there is still plenty of stuff that we don't allow. Humanity has decided there are just some things that shouldn't be said or shared. Child porn is the most obvious example. Once you go from 100% free speech in which anyone can say anything to disallowing a single thing, you have to start defending where that line is. I don't think that is bad. I also think it may be a dangerous thing for the technolibertarians in our community to continue pushing for 100% free speech as if it is an ideal state because it doesn't account for how negative speech can silence the speech and infringe on the rights of others.
- pfortuny 9y agoThat is what the judicial branch of the State is for: if someone has a problem with some kind of content, he can go and denounce it. The other possibility is just chaos and vigilante justice. Which is what the CEO of Cloudflare did.
- slg 9y agoThe idea that the owner of a business can not set any rules above the bare minimum legally is a little silly. Do you think an expensive restaurant should be able to deny service to a guy who comes in shirtless even though it is completely legal for him to walk around like that? Is that vigilante justice? Both the legal system and businesses need to draw lines. We can't pretend those lines don't exist or that 100% free speech is some ideal natural state. Once those line are drawn it is only natural for there to be debate about them. I think frequently debating and reassessing those lines is healthy.
- pfortuny 9y agoAs long as you let the people know in advance, before the contract is written, that you are willing to do so. As the Cloudflare CEO explained, that is not the case in this instance.
- chris_wot 9y agoThere is nothing in the Cloudfare ToS that state that if they find the content objectionable that they can terminate the service. https://www.cloudflare.com/terms/ https://www.cloudflare.com/terms/ The only way they can terminate the terms is: "Cause for such termination shall include, but not be limited to: (a) breaches or violations of the Terms of Service or other incorporated agreements or guidelines; (b) requests by law enforcement or other government agencies; (c) a request by you (self-initiated account deletions); (d) discontinuance or material modification to the Service (or any part thereof); (e) unexpected technical or security issues or problems; (f) extended periods of inactivity; (g) you have engaged or are reasonably suspected to be engaged in fraudulent or illegal activities; (h) having provided false information as part of your account; (i) having failed to keep your account complete, true, and accurate; (j) any use of the Service deemed at Cloudflare’s sole discretion to be prohibited; (k) use of fraudulent payment methods; and/or (l) nonpayment of any fees owed by you in connection with Cloudflare.com and associated Services."
- ballenf 9y ago> ... but not be limited to: ... Meaning "and anything else we forgot to include or think of later," so "woke up pissed off at you" is a valid reason for termination under that clause. To to mention that "j" is broad enough to include pretty much any content-based decision.
- mcbits 9y ago> Do you think an expensive restaurant should be able to deny service to a guy who comes in shirtless even though it is completely legal for him to walk around like that? If the restaurant benefits from special safe harbor exemptions to food safety laws because they have so many customers from all walks of life that they supposedly can't spare the resources to play hygiene police while serving everyone on time, then no.
- hsod 9y agoI assume you're referring to copyright laws and safe-harbor provisions. But aren't copyright laws another way of suppressing free expression? It seems contradictory to say that it's not ok for Cloudflare to suppress the free expression of Nazis while implicitly supporting the suppression of the expression of file sharers, remixers, and other violators of copyright who want to use Cloudflare. Furthermore, you seem to be arguing that the explicitly political expression of Cloudflare's CEO should be suppressed using the power of the state (by suggesting that it should open them up to legal liability).
- mcbits 9y agoI wasn't referring to copyright laws. If someone in the "move bits from point A to point B" business wants to make it their responsibility to suppress activities that are legal, purely on ideological grounds, then they should also shoulder some responsibility for the activities they're facilitating that actually are illegal and actively harmful. I mean, priorities! Otherwise they should stick to moving bits from point A to point B, cooperating with lawful orders when required.
- hsod 9y agoYou mean beyond taking it down after it's reported? Surely they already do that. Are you suggesting that in order for them to be allowed to turn down Stormfront's business they must take on the legal obligation of actively screening all their content for illegal material? I don't see the connection or justification.
- 13years 9y agoYet child porn is clearly a criminal act. Producing the media material would make you complicit. Kinda like if you went along with bank robbers to rob a bank, video tapped it and never reported it. You would be complicit of covering up the crime. I believe this distinction separates child porn from free speech. Also, like yelling `fire` in a building is not a speech issue, it is a property rights issue in that you cause damage to the owners of the property.
- Zuider 9y agoYelling "fire" in a crowded theatre is likely to cause people to stampede in panic which can lead to persons being trampled to death.
- 13years 9y agoProperty rights covers damage to people as under property rights you own your self. The point is that it can be prosecuted, but not on the grounds of speech. https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-time-to-stop-using-the-fire-in-a-crowded-theater-quote/264449/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-tim...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yock 9y ago> Humanity has decided there are just some things that shouldn't be said or shared. The thought of this terrifies me. It invites the absolute worst kind of collectivism.
- wallace_f 9y agoYes, particularly with controlling what can be said, especially political speech. It's kind of crazy that we finally agreed that the government doesn't have the right to unfairly treat two gay dudes who want to get married, but now if someone doesn't want to serve them the cake the government can force you to. No matter how righteous either act, we just traded one form of tyranny for another and made no progress in understanding the importance of the lesson. When can we just agree that telling you what to think should have never been a legitimate role of government in the first place? It is a concept fundamentally and completely opposed to democracy and individual liberty.
- AgentME 9y agoIs it a similarly-terrifying tyranny when the government forces restaurants to serve black people?
- wallace_f 9y agoYou know I can appreciate some good snarkiness like this; but to be fair, governments almost always sell tyranny to the people in the name of moral righteousness. I guess what it comes down to is what you fear more: tyranny or some racist people with restaurants.
- Joeri 9y agoAlmost everyone would agree at least some things should be illegal to express or share, like child pornography or calls to physical violence. Human rights end at where someone else’s rights begin. It’s obvious following from this that perpetrating physical violence on the innocent is wrong and must be stopped. But what of people who glorify, encourage or publicly plan to do such a thing? Do you always have to wait until people translate toxic words into toxic actions?
- jihibdokd 9y agoA rather ignorant view of history. Lookup US obscenity law and case history. Child pornography is an easy example, 80 years ago it was any pornography, or even obscene literature, joyces Ulysses was once banned. On general speech has only gotten freer, to think we now are at the precipe and speech won't be even freer is naive, provincial, and arrogant. Interacial kissing was once provocative, sodomy illegal as recently as 2003, and now depictions of transexuals is edgy. That anyone thinks its okay to limit speech, the midwife of thought -- its a debate going back to the State sanctioned murder of Socrates for 'corrupting the youth', 'making the weaker argument the stronger', and 'profaning the gods' -- its sad hilarious but those we are educated know such views are on the wrong side of history even if good people like Socrates are murdered along the way. Let's see if I even share my speech here, I'm regularly shadow banned for no reason.
- slg 9y agoThis is exactly the type of belief I was talking about in my last sentence. All speech is not equal. That may be a hard truth for some to accept, but it is the truth. Once your speech starts to infringe on the rights of others it is no longer deserving of protection. Your rights are not more important than the rights of your fellow citizens. I don't understand why libertarians don't agree with that. I thought the whole point of the government was to protect the rights of the individual.
- louithethrid 9y agoAnd deep down everyone has that feeling, that his gut feelings should be the judge of that. The problem starts, when people project there wish to control the lives of others upon some vague enough person as power.
- hitekker 9y agoFor most of its followers, Libertarianism is a means to an end, a label that can be shed and worn repeatedly, a justification rather a-way-of-life. Other People need the help of government? They should stop being lazy and put their faith in the free market. My folks need government help? Well we deserve it, give it to us, right now, don’t delay, don’t you have a heart? Compared to the members of communist, conservative and other demanding and identity-integral idealogies, libertarians are far smaller in number and altogether weaker as an independant political force.