4 ms·
> Just as the US Patent Office problematically gave out patents in the past for computers doing simple things... the office seems prepared to give out patents o
by dahart 9y ago
> Just as the US Patent Office problematically gave out patents in the past for computers doing simple things... the office seems prepared to give out patents on "using machine learning in obvious and expected ways." Companies like Google and Microsoft are seeking to acquire, and in some cases have acquired, patents on "fundamental machine-learning techniques," Nazer writes.
I find myself in a weird situation. Patents are a drag, and they're misused and wasteful, etc. etc. But it feels like the author here isn't acknowledging or appreciating what patents are intended for or good for.
We can't say patents are bad because there are obvious uses of a technology. Patents protect the people who develop the technology, not the competition who wants to use it for free after it works.
The issuing of a patent doesn't depend on how obvious the use is, it depends on how obvious the actual solution is. And deep convolutional neural nets trained using backprop or adversarial networks, these things are not obvious. They are even counter-obvious, for 30 years people knew about them and claimed they wouldn't work.
Again, I know and agree that bad/stupid patents are being issued, and that trolls who don't develop tech are siphoning money, and all that.
But when someone invents something that works, the patent system is supposed to apply a drag force on everyone else using it, that's it's intended function. And sometimes, maybe not that often these days, but sometimes it actually works as intended and deserving people get to see their work come to financial fruition.
- grantwu 9y agoThe patent in question is a patent on the obvious use, not the underlying method. "Deep convolutional neural nets trained using backprop or adversarial networks" is not the thing being patented here. "Using deep convolutional neural nets trained using backprop or adversarial networks to solve a specific problem" is what's being patented. The article argues that the known techniques aren't being applied in a particularly novel or interesting way.
- dahart 9y agoI agree, and yes that happens. But the author concluded based on one example that the whole system is bringing down a whole industry. I didn't title the piece, Joe did. And in the article he argued "the [patent] office seems prepared to give out patents on using machine learning in obvious and expected ways." That is not and cannot be the criteria for or against issuing patents.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI used to feel that way. Unfortunately we've reached the point where patents have so damaged and corrupted our industry that none of us can write any software free of patents. If someone wants to annihilate you with a patent suit, theoretically they can. Unless you have a patent portfolio. They are the ultimate anti-individual-programmer. Which is another way of saying they're a threat to hacker culture. You can argue that hacker culture had its day in the sun, and that the world should move forward. But it's important to be clear to yourself that the culture that built the internet and so many of the tools we now enjoy for free is being thrown under the bus. E.g. see Mike Pall's statement on LuaJIT: http://lua-users.org/lists/lua-l/2009-11/msg00089.html http://lua-users.org/lists/lua-l/2009-11/msg00089.html I cannot guarantee LuaJIT to be free of third-party IP however. In fact nobody can. Writing software has become a minefield and any moderately complex piece of software is probably (unknowingly to the author) encumbered by hundreds of dubious patents. This especially applies to compilers. Are you sure you want to live in a world where people can't legally write and release LuaJIT for free without its users facing legal ramifications? Same deal with machine learning. What will the LuaJIT of machine learning be?
- dahart 9y ago> You can argue that hacker culture had its day in the sun, and that the world should move forward. I don't want that, I want more hacker/maker culture, not less. I also want to figure out how to fund my own hacker/maker habits, but that's a separate topic. ;) Patents do seem to be getting more toxic, but I base that on media reporting and stories of patent trolls, and not stats on the economy or number of lawsuits. So I'm curious to know more about the health of the system from a statistical perspective. Ultimately I don't know what the solution is, and I might change my mind, but right now I don't feel like nuking the patent system is the right answer. But I do wonder if something like disallowing patent sale or transfer would help -- a company can only have a patent if the person who did the inventing worked for them at the time. They can keep it if the inventor quits or dies, but they can't sell it. Maybe something like that would stop the shell companies?
- sillysaurus3 9y agoWell, from a game theory point of view, look at it like this: You can't meaningfully execute on patents (enforcement nor acquisition) unless you have resources. Those resources tend to come from companies that programmers work for, not individual programmers working at home. So if you want more hacker/maker culture, your position would seem to run counter to that goal, no? I love playing devil's advocate too, but there are situations where it's not quite so easy. If you feel that the hatred for patents is an overblown concern, I suppose it would be best for the people in this thread to post stories about how patents have materially affected their lives and their work. There are plenty. Even lacking that, though, the core argument is that you need money to be able to do anything patent-related. Most hackers don't have these kinds of resources. And since patents can be used against them, advocating for patents leads directly to the disenfranchisement of hackers. EDIT: One thing that makes it difficult to see the kinds of statistics you'd like to see: Chilling effects. When patents hang over us like a specter, you'll never see how many ventures are aborted before they're even started due to fears about patents.
- betterunix2 9y ago"Patents protect the people who develop the technology, not the competition who wants to use it for free after it works." Equally true of people developing pure math, but math is not supposed to be patentable (except for algorithms apparently).
- dahart 9y ago> Equally true of people developing pure math, but math is not supposed to be patentable (except for algorithms apparently). Yeah, exactly, and this is why software is getting more contentious, right? Software is pure math, and it's also method and apparatus. The patent system was designed as a line between concepts and physical inventions, but software perches right smack on top of that line.
- betterunix2 9y agoSoftware is very clearly on one side of the line and software patents actually depend on that. On some level it comes down to this: does the patent cover a particular representation of an algorithm, or all possible representations? I think the former is very clearly not what software patents cover as it would imply that just compiling your code or using a different programming language would leave you in the clear. If it covers all possible representations, then it really covers only a method or "concept," not any particular apparatus (the hypothetical apparatus you might use is just a detail of the concept that the patent covers; in any case, software patents are almost never specific about what sort of computer you will use, so it is not clear what "apparatus" is being described).
- dahart 9y ago> in any case, software patents are almost never specific about what sort of computer you will use, so it is not clear what "apparatus" is being described Well yeah, that's what I meant about it being on the line. The patent system was designed before computers, and it clearly was built with the idea that physical things people built, and mathematical ideas people imagined, were two separate categories. With computer software, there's no distinction. I really can build a physical machine that does things using only mathematical ideas. The patent system wasn't designed to see that possibility.
- lsiq 9y agoPatents are state enforced monopoly rights, let's be clear about that. In what circumstances do we want to have monopolies doled out, even timed ones? Even in the classic image of the sole inventor who does something shrewd but ends up with nothing because he didn't patent it; is it really the best outcome to have this one person get rich while lives are lost and technological progress of society slowed because the monopoly pricing imposed is prohibitive for all but the wealthy? The best scenario for a patent is as a subsidy for inventions that could not or would not exist without very substantial capital investment. Software methods by and large do not fall in that category.
- guelo 9y agoLuckily if I'm going to use a hammer for some job I don't have to go check to see if someone holds a patent on using the tool in that specific way. It makes some sense to patent the invention of the tool but not the use of the tool in the ordinary ways that it is meant to be used. There are thousands of types of data that can train a neural net. We shouldn't allow whichever company happens to be the first one to use it on some specific type of data to hold a monopoly on using this important new tool in that fashion for the next 15 years.
- dahart 9y ago> Luckily if I'm going to use a hammer for some job I don't have to go check to see if someone holds a patent on using the tool in that specific way. If you buy a hammer at Home Depot, the patent system doesn't affect you directly. (But it might affect the price of hammers.) If you make hammers and sell them, you might get a cease and desist from the owner of the hammer patent. If they have a valid patent, then you don't have the legal right to produce hammers for sale without licensing the hammer. If you build a homemade hammer and don't sell it, nobody's going to know or care or sue. > It makes some sense to patent the invention of the tool but not the use of the tool in the ordinary ways that it is meant to be used. Again, ordinary use is not the criteria, and it can't be. The idea is to protect the investment of the inventor. Don't forget that I agree the system is unhealthy. But if I spent a trillion dollars to invent warp drive, the use case is obvious, travel far in a short amount of time. You don't get to steal the solution just because everyone has the problem. > We shouldn't allow whichever company happens to be the first one to use it on some specific type of data to hold a monopoly on using this important new tool in that fashion for the next 15 years. I completely agree that the patent in the article is crap-tastic. You shouldn't be able to monopolize things you didn't invent, and you shouldn't be able to monopolize things that are too easy to invent. But if someone truly invents something useful, works hard at it, invests time and money, then - according to the patent system - they should get to monopolize it. That's the point of protecting the inventor. (*and btw, the problem is the rich people & big companies are the ones with the time & money. I agree with others here that that is bad.)
- stupidcar 9y agoThe problem is twofold: Firstly, when bad/stupid patents far outweigh the good, then the net negative effect renders any positive effect meaningless. Secondly, the complexity of modern engineering means any individual invention is worthless by itself. If a lone inventor has an idea for a cool smartphone feature, they cannot practically bring it to market, because building a smartphone is too difficult and capital intensive, and requires licensing myriad other patents, mostly owned by incumbent vendors with no interest in allowing another competitor emerge. This means that, even if every patent in an area is "good", a patent thicket[1] will nonetheless emerge in a field following a major breakthrough, as core and ancillary techniques are patented. A handful of large, dominant vendors come to monopolise the market, new players are locked out, and progress slows to molasses for the following twenty years. Only when these core patents begin to expire can progress start again, until some new major breakthrough is made, and the entire process repeats itself. Through this lens, the rise of patent trolls makes sense. Faced with impenetrable, monopolised markets, individuals and smaller players are incentivized to engage in parasitic behaviour, gaming the patent system to extract what value they can, since actually using their patents to compete is either impossible or impractical. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent_thicket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent_thicket
- dahart 9y agoAgreed with all the above. I am honestly curious - is there evidence that we're at the point where patents are a net negative? I hear a lot of strong opinions, but I am ignorant of meaningful data. In my experience, the patent thicket is today's corporate strategy. The large companies I've worked for have undertaken a broad patent-everything strategy as a defensive way to turn any competitive claims into a game of patent tennis.