9 ms·
Catalan referendum: 'Hundreds injured' in Catalan clashes
- freech 9y agoHow does voting (on anything) not qualify as speech?
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoSomeone made a point recently that the past 50 years really have been a golden age of democracy (possibly the only 50 in history) That during the 19C there was much more semi-democracy with strong authoritarian governments in Europe, cracking down on what we would call democracy (1816,1848 etc) The point was that it is fairly easy to slip back.
- wav-part 9y agoFairism is not something you build a stable society with. The individual (usually wealthy) vs majority was the canary.
- pjc50 9y agoEh?
- wav-part 9y agoWhat we see in todays world is lot of disagreements. Why ?. Because neither side has consistent interpretation of (social) contract. Why ? Because its subjective which is result of fairism. I am not really a good writer. I hope that clears it up. If not just ask.
- sbmassey 9y agoWhat do you mean by "fairism"? Presumably not the Urban Dirctionary definition: http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Fairism http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Fairism
- wav-part 9y agoThe popular example would be "fair taxation". And catalonia ref is not fair for other spaniards.
- rasjani 9y agoAuto corrected fascism to fairism maybe ? Ruling party in Spain was started by Franco's people.
- rasjani 9y agoDownvoted for pointing a typo and a possible reason for using that word? Manual Fraga was serving as part of Francois Spain politics and started PP. Thus some people do consider the roots of the party as fascist. Sorry for pointing this out
- unixhero 9y agoI've never understood the word canary. What do you mean with it, in this context?
- wav-part 9y ago> I've never understood the word canary. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/canary_in_a_coal_mine https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/canary_in_a_coal_mine > What do you mean with it, in this context? The pouplar reason given for the anti-success taxation, is that its fair. Because they agreed to the social contract. But its highly disputed by those taxpayers. Such disputes are canary/early-signs of fair/subjective contracts. Catalonians vs Spaniards is the other.
- bad_user 9y agoI feel sorry for the injured in this Catalan referendum, but in my opinion this referendum has nothing to do with democracy. First of all a country's constitution is sacrosanct and that constitution not only gives the people their power to vote, but also says that the country's territory is indivisible. If the Catalan people want to change that, then the referendum should involve all of Spain's citizens, having as much rights at this point over Catalonia, as the people living there. I've said it repeatedly here, so here it is again: I'm getting the feeling that people don't know what a democracy is. A democracy isn't only about the freedom to vote. What happened in Turkey for example isn't democracy, even if a majority is in support of the current administration. The right to vote means nothing without liberal freedoms or without the indivisibility of the territory. In other words, you can't have an "independence" referendum without involving all the citizens. That's not democracy, but a war declaration.
- pjc50 9y agoIs this opposition to secession retroactive?
- beejiu 9y agoThen I suppose you don't know or understand the history of every modern state in existence (including the United States).
- kiliancs 9y agoSelf-determination of peoples is a jus cogens law and a cardinal principle in international law. It's part of the UN's Charter and it's enshrined in many international treaties subscribed by Spain and by the European Union. The Spanish constitution recognizes the right to self-determination inasmuch as it explicitly enshrines the international treaties that define it. Spain has always defended that this right to self-determination is confined to colonies because it would otherwise conflict with the also very important principle of territorial integrity. However, the International Court of Justice explained in its Advisory Opinion of 22 July 2010 regarding the case of Kosovo that “the scope of the principle of territorial integrity is confined to the sphere of relations between States”. Thus, even unilateral declarations of independence do not conflict with the aforementioned principle: “general international law contains no applicable prohibition of declarations of independence“.
- pjc50 9y agoMyself I'd say it was the narrow window between the end of the Berlin wall and the fall of the WTC. A dozen years.
- musage 9y ago> it is fairly easy to slip back Indeed. https://twitter.com/CataloniaHelp2/status/914131859654639616 https://twitter.com/CataloniaHelp2/status/914131859654639616
- droopyEyelids 9y agoExample of the crackdown on voters. They seem completely nonviolent to me, even in the face of a disproportionate response. https://twitter.com/OwenJones84/status/914427797753430017 https://twitter.com/OwenJones84/status/914427797753430017 https://twitter.com/ZabMustefa/status/914406611375894528 https://twitter.com/ZabMustefa/status/914406611375894528
- NaliSauce 9y agoIt seems like even the local firefighters and police stepped in: https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/914472762030379012 https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/914472762030379012 https://twitter.com/catalannews/status/914453409453023232 https://twitter.com/catalannews/status/914453409453023232 What a violent mess.
- SuddsMcDuff 9y agoWatching this it's easy to see a clear path toward civil war. If this continues, I wouldn't be at all surprised to see the army step in & impose peace until such time as the situation can be resolved peacefully. I would bet good money that Spanish generals are dusting off old contingency plans as we speak.
- fcanela 9y agoThe woman was not injured by police: she had an accident with the stairs going to vote. There are videos with the attack to the police. At the end, there are violent people with the pacifist voters and not professional policemen too. EDIT: Evidence asked, here it is https://youtu.be/wmLTRluQm94 https://youtu.be/wmLTRluQm94 EDIT 2: I was asked for source about the women and people manipulating pictures. Two sources here: https://twitter.com/arb149/status/914401352230621184/video/1 https://twitter.com/arb149/status/914401352230621184/video/1 http://www.larazon.es/espana/difunden-en-twitter-imagenes-falsas-de-agresiones-policiales-MM16381814 http://www.larazon.es/espana/difunden-en-twitter-imagenes-fa...
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 9y agoI've seen no evidence of violent people attacking police. Edit: well that is evidence - not a huge surprise that things have now escalated when you have an armed force shutting down an election.
- Joeri 9y agoIf this were happening in russia, the EU leaders would have loudly condemned the human rights violations. The silence from them now is shameful.
- 5_minutes 9y agoI didn't think of that, but that's a very valid point reg. Russia.
- johnchristopher 9y agoBelgian prime minister and various major Belgian political figures (some being separatist, some not) have already condemned the use of violence. See https://twitter.com/CharlesMichel/status/914455311553040384 https://twitter.com/CharlesMichel/status/914455311553040384 Edit: to be fair, the twitter accounts of Macron, Merkel, lepen and others are silent.
- notspanishflu 9y agoIf this was happening in Russia, nobody would say nothing because there is nothing to say. German police in the last G20 (Hamburg) was more violent, for example.
- Mithaldu 9y ago> German police in the last G20 (Hamburg) was more violent, for example. Not even remotely.
- Grue3 9y agoRussia does murder separatists in Chechnya and Dagestan literally every day. Clearly you aren't aware of that because nobody loudly condemns it.
- 5_minutes 9y agoIndirectly, the Spanish reacting with brute force will just help the Catalans -- as they're proving their point.
- pjc50 9y agoIndeed. If the situation can be de-escalated without more than one or two people getting killed, then the situation will probably return to the status quo. If it escalates to live ammunition in the streets, then Catalonia will have its martrys and its independence.
- csdreamer7 9y agoMy thoughts exactly. Spain just gave a very good reason to Catalans to secede.
- severino 9y agoAs a Spanish (not from Catalonia), I'm totally ashamed about what my government is doing to address a political issue.
- tomjen3 9y agoThis is basically what we are used to seeing from the middle-east, and from before I was born: South Africa. I don't remember the boycot, but I do remember my parents of talking about it. What, if anything, can we do similarly to apply pressure to Spain? What exports are they depended on? What start-ups are Spanish? Edit: Downvoted for being against beating up people who are trying to vote? Really HN?
- LoSboccacc 9y agoLucky you for having an absolute moral compass that immediately recognizes who’s right and wrong in the conflicts around the world
- 627467 9y agoI don't get the point of the violence used to stop the ref. The ref is illegal. The hypothetical declaration of independence is illegal, invalid and likely never accepted by anyone (not in Europe not in the world) why the use of violence to stop the ref game? This whole situation is senseless from both sides but it is obvious who is the side willing to use violence.
- slim 9y agoPolitics are above law. Laws don't matter. The only thing that matters is power of the masses. If the Catalans are determined, laws will be changed
- vkou 9y agoThe Declaration of Independence was also an illegal, treasonous document. The point of violent suppression of this referendum is optics. Those that fear and despise self-determination don't want to see a referendum result supporting succession. Even if the referendum is meaningless, that result will be used as justification for later actions. The EU may not endorse an independent Catalan today, but it is more likely to do so if there is a clear message that Catalan wants it.
- MrPatan 9y agoBecause the PP, the party in power in Spain, will get political benefit out of conflict in Catalonia, the bloodiest the better. If by any chance a Catalan terrorist group appears, that's the next several elections sorted. PP misses ETA, the Basque terrorist group. If you're thinking that's stupid and can backfire on them big time, well, I didn't say they were smart.
- faragon 9y agoThe European Union sides with the Spanish Constitution, supporting the rule of law, against the regional nationalist revolt [1]. Also, it seems that Russian "hackers" are helping the rebels [2]. [1] https://elpais.com/elpais/2017/09/15/inenglish/1505463613_515431.html https://elpais.com/elpais/2017/09/15/inenglish/1505463613_51... [2] https://elpais.com/elpais/2017/09/28/inenglish/1506588970_026442.html https://elpais.com/elpais/2017/09/28/inenglish/1506588970_02...
- adambyrtek 9y agoThis is from BBC which is generally considered a reliable source. Even if the referendum is illegal, it doesn't justify violence against peaceful protesters.
- faragon 9y agoOf course there are injured people, including policemen. If you start a revolt, you can expect problems. What do you expect, peaceful anarchy? Police is acting after a Court order, ensuring the rule of law.
- johnchristopher 9y agoWhat does Spain gain from using violence ? Can't they just ignore the results on the basis it's illegal ?
- faragon 9y ago"Spain"? The police is acting after a Court order from Barcelona (main city of the Catalan region), not from the central Spanish Government. Edit: I can not reply to more comments, as it seems I have a limit of 5 comments per day. "Thanks", Hacker News. To the reply to this comment, I would reply that Courts have to apply the Law. I.e. it is not "optional", so if a Court sends the police to stop an illegal action, it is not arbitrary, but a duty. In Spain Courts and Goverments are separated, i.e. the Court is not acting because of central Government orders.
- notspanishflu 9y agoI usually see HNers stand against fake news, and post-truth, but here I am watching secessionists brigading Hacker News scot-free.
- subway 9y agoAs are the unionists.
- pjc50 9y agoThe events are actually happening are they not? Please can we distinguish between "I don't agree with the politics expressed here" and "the reporting describes events which didn't happen, or misdescribes events that did"?
- walshemj 9y agoIts also been boycotted by the opposition and was rushed through using dubious mesures by the ruling party
- notspanishflu 9y agoI'm repeating myself but... The only source for BBC quoting "hundreds injured" is what secessionists say, they don't contrast that number. There was a change in BBC news after Brexit, trying to weaken the common European position.
- yxhuvud 9y agoSigh, English media have always been very sceptical against Europe. That is nothing new.
- sbmassey 9y agoThe BBC, though in lamentable shape in many ways, is not usually considered a Fake news source. Do you have any links to English language reports that are less biased from your standpoint?
- 9y ago
- jostmey 9y agoThis appears to be one of those cases where the government is going against its own people. I guess it is up to the people to make sure their voice is heard and to replace a government that does not serve them.
- adriand 9y agoOnce again I think Canada has set an example for the world with how to do this properly: permit open and peaceful votes on secession (e.g. of Quebec), treat the issue as something to be resolved politically and not with the use of force, and pass legislation to deal with the matter that: - mandates that the secession question on the ballot be clear and unambiguous; - requires a clear majority to be considered valid; - mandates the involvement of all provinces and First Nations in negotiations following a vote in favour of secession; - and stipulates that secession, if it proceeds, would require an amendment to the constitution. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarity_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarity_Act
- ritchiea 9y agoI believe the problem is Quebec has a poor economy and figured to lose out economically and in subsequent trade deals if they became independent. Catalonia on the other hand is ~20% of Spain's economy and ~15% of the population so on the national level there is an interest in keeping Catalonia as part of Spain against the wishes of the Catalan population. Canada has leverage if Quebec wishes to secede, Spain doesn't have leverage with Catalonia.
- smallnamespace 9y agoSpain definitely would have leverage with Catalonia if it acts (acted?) in a responsible and sane manner -- Catalonia's economy would take a huge hit if it doesn't achieve international recognition or EU membership, and Spain can influence that quite a bit.
- VHRanger 9y agoA quick googling would show you Quebec is also 20% of Canadian GDP and 15% of Canadian population. Quebec moreover cuts off maritime provinces from the rest of Canada
- slededit 9y agoAt the time of the referendum Quebec was subsidizing the rest of Canada through equalization payments. More recently they've been on the receiving end but that has not been true for most of its history.
- dgut 9y agoThe referendum was ruled illegal by the courts. If we are going to allow all old tribes of Europe to become their own state, there wouldn't be much left of Europe. The nation-state and standardization is a European invention and a successful one. The case for an independent Catalonia isn't on strong grounds either. This is no small issue, and Spain is responding accordingly. The message has to be clear: Spain isn't going to split and we aren't going to allow tribalists/nationalists to act freely. They are using rubber bullets to disperse the crowds, that's not exactly a crime against humanity as some seem to suggest here. Having lived in Spain for some time, I can say police there is awesome. That is, friendly and laid back. Once I was caught smoking marijuana in my apartment (the neighbors called the police because of the loud music) and they made a couple of jokes and left. Back in Norway, they'd be angry & taken me to the police station.
- alanfranzoni 9y agoThe referendum is illegal. Let them vote, then ignore the vote. What's the point in blocking it?
- notspanishflu 9y agoThe sovereignty of Spain falls on all Spanish citizens. If you allow a referendum on such topic in a part of Spain, it doesn't matter the result because you're accepting implicitly that a part of Spain can rule over the whole.
- dguaraglia 9y agoI'm kind of confused by this statement: so you are saying that Catalonia taking a referendum on what they themselves want to do, is imposing on all Spanish people, but Madrid commanding the repression is not imposing? I don't want to start a flamewar, but that looks like a bias you might want to reflect on.
- notspanishflu 9y agoMy statement is in the Spanish Constitution, I don't know why you're confused.
- richardwhiuk 9y agoThe relevance of that being?
- sbmassey 9y agoThat doesn't seem to address the point made in the comment you are responding too - if the referendum is illegal, then why not just make the point that it is illegal clear, and ignore the result, rather than attempting to shut it down violently?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- markvdb 9y agoClearly, identities (Catalan, Spanish, religious, atheist, ...) are very much layered, personal, and they fluctuate with time. How to reinvent the nation state (whether the Catalan, the Spanish or any other one) to take that into account seems to be a largely unanswered question. Any good reading recommendations on that? Surely, there must be creative solutions! Maybe information technology can even help technically underpin progress in this area? P.S. Good luck to all the Spanish and Catalan people that treat their neighbours with respect. I hope for a peaceful solution.
- csdreamer7 9y agoThe pro-Spain arguments here in this post are really poor. The only two good arguments that on their face are worth looking at are: Catalan's pop is evenly split on the issue and local officials are pushing it to gain power. Spain was baited-they took it, and now Catalan's secession movement has international sympathy. For abit of context of how something this is handled here in America. In 2015 the US Supreme Court temporary blocked a Native Hawaiian non-profit from counting votes in what lower courts called a private election (that the Supreme Court said used public funds granted to that non-profit). The issue plaintiffs were suing the non-profit over was it was excluded only to what they considered 'Native Hawaiians'. They wanted to establish a Constitution for Native Hawaiians for self governance. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/u-s-supreme-court-blocks-vote-counting-hawaii-election-n470401 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/u-s-supreme-court-block... http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2016/08/29/15-17134.pdf http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2016/08/29/15... The organization later dissolved from what I read in the Supreme Court's opinion on sanctions. I had trouble finding more info on it. From what I can tell the courts barely cared except for the issue of using public money for a racially exclusive election. This story reminded me of it so I thought it would add to the debate.
- kgwgk 9y agoA more similar situation would have been the Hawaiian government organising a binding vote to secede from the US in 48 hours (while maintaining the US citizenship!). I guess the SCOTUS involvement would have been more intense in that case.
- csdreamer7 9y agoTechnically the state was involved. They were sued along with the non-profit in violation of the US Constitution and the Voting Rights Act. You can see this info with the SCOTUS brief I linked.
- kgwgk 9y agoIt was involved in a tangential way, doesn't seem comparable.
- mercer 9y agoSo by all means explain to me how I'm being overly simplistic (because I feel that I am), but while our brains like to ponder the complexities of this situation, can't we at least conclude that it's a bad thing that physical, state-backed violence is used to prevent people from doing something that isn't in any way physically violent (and in fact a rather admired 'action') in itself? I mean, hell, it's quite possible that even if an overwhelming majority of Catalonians vote for secession (which I hear is not even likely to be the case?), reality will get in the way. At the very least even the worst-case scenario, in my opinion, does not justify physical interference in a non-violent process. But again, honestly please correct me if I'm missing something blindingly obvious.