3 ms·
> in 1989 there wasn’t a computer that could do this in near real time Does this hold even if we consider the fastest computers, like Crays? A '89 Y-MP could d
by fulafel 9y ago
> in 1989 there wasn’t a computer that could do this in near real time
Does this hold even if we consider the fastest computers, like Crays? A '89 Y-MP could do 2.7 GFLOPS or about 333 FLOPS per NTSC "pixel" in each NTSC field. Smaller computers of the era might be more economical for the required processing power, maybe one of the Thinking Machines SIMD MPPs?
- userbinator 9y agoThe demoscener in me disagrees with the statement entirely. ;-) From the article: It requires 3 inputs, the first video, the second video being turned to, and a typically solid color/image that represents the back of the page This effect probably doesn't require that much processing power since all it needs to do is switch (up to) twice on each scanline, from the pixels of A to "back" to B; the switching points themselves can be calculated straightforwardly since they vary linearly. Making the "back" itself be another video doesn't add much extra processing. Here's a visual schematic of one frame halfway through the effect (- = first video, + = second video, b = back): ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ---------------+++++++++++++++ ---------------b++++++++++++++ ---------------bbb++++++++++++ ... ... ---------------bbbbbb+++++++++ ---------------bbbbbbbb+++++++ ---------------bbbbbbbbbb+++++ ---------------bbbbbbbbbbbb+++ ------------------------------ As a rough guess, it's probably doable in around a dozen extra calculations per scanline, which in NTSC is slightly less than 64us. Assuming (a very generous) 100 clock cycles for those calculations, and hardware which has a video mux so the software doesn't have to copy the pixels, that turns out to require... slightly less than 1.6MHz. Of course, if your hardware doesn't have a mux and you need to copy the pixels between various buffers, then the requirement goes up around an order of magnitude... but probably still doable on something like a 33MHz 386.
- mattnewport 9y agoYeah, my thought reading the article was that an Amiga would probably be capable of this effect. I feel like I've seen it some old demos in fact.
- Theodores 9y agoCompletely. When do you think it was that Silicon Graphics added the capability to have not just one but two video inputs at the same time? That is a crucial feature needed for the page turn. Real time video effects at 50/60 fps broadcast resolution was not easy. The signals would have been component analog, not digital, with everything having to be synchronised. I doubt that the SGI O2 would have had the chops for this task and that was a latter day model costing proper workstation money, supposedly with the I/O for animation etc. So why would you spend real money on an SGI as used by moviemakers 'deskside workstation'? Back then electronics based solutions effectively worked on every pixel in parallel, not a pixel at a time, as per CPU style graphics. So changing things wholesale on an image, e.g. brightness and contrast, is instant. Back then a CPU would need to do a lot of work and could not manage the instant refresh. In broadcasting back then a 1U rack of kit would cost a lot of money no matter what it was. A clock could cost $100000 and not even tell the time on the front of its rack-mount enclosure. So it would not have been a problem to spend $$$ on another piece of kit.