5 ms·
The A380 has four engines in total, and can easily tolerate the loss of just one in normal flight. Adding more engines has been a basic way to increase reliabi
by CydeWeys 9y ago
The A380 has four engines in total, and can easily tolerate the loss of just one in normal flight. Adding more engines has been a basic way to increase reliability since the beginning of the field; it's not just modern aircraft engineering. There's no other part of the airplane behind the engines either, so nothing to be hit by debris.
What amazes me more is that the newest twinjets are now considered reliable enough to fly six hours away from the nearest landing strip -- that's how far they can coast on the single remaining engine if necessary!
- inamberclad 9y agoIt's not really coasting. A transport category aircraft is required to have enough power to continue climbing if it loses an engine, so it must also have enough power to maintain level flight indefinitely (barring fuel consumption, oil leaks, or mechanical damage from an engine failure)
- CydeWeys 9y agoI meant to say "cruise", if that makes more sense.
- KGIII 9y agoIf it is any consolation, I knew what you meant. Otherwise, you'd probably have said something like glide and the glide ratio of the big planes isn't very good. Out of curiosity, I just checked for the A380 and the best guess is 15:1, so it does glide better than I expected, but still not that far. Google tells me that it'd glide ~130 miles if it had a starting altitude of 45,000'. That's better than I expected.
- katastic 9y agoAccording to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gliding_flight#Aircraft_.28.22gliders.22.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gliding_flight#Aircraft_.28.22... The 747-200 also has a glide ratio of 15:1. I can't tell if that's amazing, good, or average. A sailplane can have up to 60:1! That's pretty impressive! According to this: A "clean A320" has 17:1. Neat. https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/14814/could-a-commercial-plane-like-airbus-a320-glide-with-no-working-engines-from-110 https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/14814/could-a-c... Something I never knew was this: >As someone said above, you have to remember, pretty well all descents are done with the thrust at idle. So I imagine the glide ratio is pretty important for all-purposes of flight and not just when engines go out.
- KGIII 9y agoYou descend at just about the stall speed. It's pretty close to the slowest the individual plane can go before losing lift. I believe the term for coming in with no lift, purely gliding, is called dead stick. A Cessna 172 is worse, for comparison. I believe they are just 9:1. I guess it improves if you stop the prop entirely. I assume it is less drag.
- tyw 9y agobest glide (converting altitude into the maximum distance) speed is quite a bit higher than the stall speed and found at the lift/drag max. minimum sink (converting altitude into the maximum time) is usually found about halfway between best glide speed and stall speed. http://learntoflylv.com/drag%20curve.gif http://learntoflylv.com/drag%20curve.gif
- leoc 9y agoObligatory Gimli Glider: https://www.damninteresting.com/the-gimli-glider/ https://www.damninteresting.com/the-gimli-glider/ http://www.gimlicommunityweb.com/history/gimli_glider.php http://www.gimlicommunityweb.com/history/gimli_glider.php .
- jaclaz 9y agoAlso (older accident): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Airways_Flight_9 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Airways_Flight_9 >Ladies and gentlemen, this is your captain speaking. We have a small problem. All four engines have stopped. We are doing our damnedest to get them going again. I trust you are not in too much distress.
- FabHK 9y agoThat must surely top the list of most awesome pilot announcements (and, simultaneously, best British understatement).
- lloeki 9y agoFinesse gives you two things: Quite directly, from ground altitude, a range within which to look for a place to land. As you mentioned the impressive finesse of gliders gives you more room, but gliders won’t generally be flying as high as cruising powered planes. Combined with speed, a timeframe within which you have to observe, orient, decide and act. Here, both top speed and stall speed give you some hints, and within which there’s a best speed where finesse is optimal. You can imagine how it’s very different between an A320 and a glider, the former for which time runs quickly, you have to decide where to go in as few minutes as possible, the latter for which decision time brought back at a human thinking time scale makes it less stressful but you have to keep cautious of your goal for a longer stretch of time. Obviously that’s without counting on soaring, which A320s can hardly benefit from (I suppose they can but would largely not move up and certainly not turn since it would would incur too huge drag).
- FabHK 9y ago> ~130 miles That's statute miles (or 111 nautical miles or 205 km). It's quite impressive, really.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoIt's been done in real life for the A330. 120 km from a starting altitude of 10 km to Lajes Airbase in the Azores. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Transat_Flight_236 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Transat_Flight_236
- dominotw 9y ago>A transport category aircraft is required to have enough power to continue climbing Can a plane takeoff with just one engine ?
- hlandau 9y agoYes. Twinjet airliners must be able to take off if one engine fails at or after V1.
- FabHK 9y agoWhich, incidentally, means that twins are quite powerful - a twin has 100% more engines (thus, power available) at takeoff than needed, while a quad has 33% more. Thus a twin has 50% more power than a similar 4 engine. At least conceptually-ish.
- timb07 9y agoActually, adding engines increases resilience, or the ability to tolerate failure. The extra complexity of extra engines actually reduces reliability, since there are more components that can fail.
- FabHK 9y agoAs the saying goes: If you have an engine failure in a twin, the remaining engine has enough power to take you to the scene of the accident.
- WalterBright 9y ago> There's no other part of the airplane behind the engines either, so nothing to be hit by debris. The fans spin very fast, and will fly out radially, not just fall back. They'll slice right through anything they contact. The Airbus flight was very, very lucky.
- cialowicz 9y agoThe engines are designed so that a detached fan blade stays contained within the cowling. Here's a video of a fan blade containment test on a Rolls Royce Trent 500: https://youtu.be/RIOWjhjC1jM https://youtu.be/RIOWjhjC1jM
- KGIII 9y agoI guess they use really, really precise timing and explosives to knock one blade loose in order to do the containment tests. They want it to come loose at a specific point in the revolution. The documentary didn't say why they wanted it to be at such a specific place, only that they did. I've long since forgotten the margin of error, but it was very small. You probably noticed that the individual blade is painted a different color and is different colors. My recollection is that they use the multiple colors because they do very high definition recording and the colors are all in different areas of the spectrum, so they can observe it better as the thing tends to be quickly obscured by fire and smoke. I probably do watch too many documentaries.
- dba7dba 9y ago> I probably do watch too many documentaries. You are not alone. I actually watch more and more documentaries than movies or TV series. Reality is even stranger than fiction often.
- KGIII 9y agoIt has been great to see the proliferation of documentaries on the web. Streaming services have been a great thing for me. I watch documentaries pretty much to the exclusion of all other genres, except American football. Even if I'm not actively paying attention, I'll frequently have a documentary playing in the background. It's not a scholastic pursuit. It is purely entertainment. I watch them because I enjoy them. Learning is incidental and not the objective. I like to queue up playlists of documentaries and let them play through. The 'net has been excellent at facilitating this.
- ansible 9y agoAn engine-out situation does get interesting though when the aircraft is low and slow, such as when taking off and landing. That's where good training is needed to recover quickly and successfully.
- jasode 9y agoWhat amazes me more is that the newest twinjets are now considered reliable enough to fly six hours away from the nearest landing strip Yes, there's also a short video about that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSxSgbNQi-g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSxSgbNQi-g It's very interesting since ETOPS[1] affected the financial bets that Boeing made on 787 (point-to-point) vs Airbus with the A380 (hub-and-spoke). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETOPS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETOPS
- SmellTheGlove 9y agoI wasn't really commenting on adding engines - I know that concept has been around a long time. This wasn't just an engine going down, this was catastrophic failure, and my amazement is in that no other part of the aircraft was affected outside of that one engine. > There's no other part of the airplane behind the engines either, so nothing to be hit by debris. No, but there's a wing and the fuselage nearby. Again, I'm not an engineer, but I'm assuming that in this type of failure, the part of the engine that's spinning might want to come laterally (is that the right word?), and that seems like it could be trouble. I'm amazed that it didn't. > What amazes me more is that the newest twinjets are now considered reliable enough to fly six hours away from the nearest landing strip -- that's how far they can coast on the single remaining engine if necessary! Totally amazing. I'm not sure, but is that only the A350XWB for now, or have others been certified past ETOPS-360? It's basically certified to the design limit of the aircraft, so I'm not sure what else has been designed for that. Even 5+ hours is nuts though. Somewhat related, but check out the Chilean regs on flying from the mainland to IPC/PPT. As far as I know, they still have the one aircraft rule.
- rphlx 9y agoThe real concern here is not loss of thrust, but rather, what other parts of the airframe are seriously damaged or destroyed by the debris. In the accident record I believe there is precedent for separated engine parts seriously damaging wing and tail surfaces, causing at least partial loss of control.