11 ms·
Air France A380 over Greenland on Sep 30th: Fan and engine inlet separated
- nabla9 9y agoIt's more than just fan blade failure. Engines are tested against fan blade failures. The surrounding cowling should contain it. In this case the whole fan disk is gone. Uncontained failure like this can down the plane depending on the where the parts fly.
- rwmj 9y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qantas_Flight_32 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qantas_Flight_32 ... although that happened both in a different part of the engine (the hot bit) and that was a Rolls Royce engine whereas this is an Engine Alliance (GE/P&W) GP7270 engine.
- WalterBright 9y agoFor what a failing fan disk can do: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_232 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_232
- hexane360 9y ago*For what a failing fan disk could do to a DC-10 built in 1973. Since this accident, hydraulic fuses and backup electronic actuators have become standard.
- inferiorhuman 9y agoUncontained engine failures can still cause a significant amount of damage: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qantas_Flight_32 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qantas_Flight_32
- nielsbot 9y agoamazing that such a tiny manufacturing error could lead to complete engine failure, associated damage, and near catastrophe.
- hexane360 9y agoI can't help but see those two accidents as completely different. I wasn't suggesting that an uncontained engine explosion is no big deal, but that there is vastly less danger to critical flight controls and therefore vastly less danger to passengers. Let's compare: Qantas 32 lost throttle on one engine, lost one engine completely (obviously), flaps, and ABS. United 232 lost its tail engine, elevator, rudder, aileron, flaps, and had no ABS to begin with. Qantas 32 was able to maintain a holding pattern for an hour while diagnosing the aircraft, and was given enough time to calmly calculate a glide path and put the airplane down safely. United 232 landed at twice the safe speed, with 6x the safe sink rate, on its wing. Qantas 32 had 0 fatalities or injuries, United 232 had 111 fatalities and 172 injuries.
- rjsw 9y agoMaybe the cowling did contain the disk failure, it just didn't stay attached to the rest of the engine afterwards.
- jacquesm 9y agoI'm with you on the cowling containing the failure, there is no other explanation why the cowling would disappear as one piece, the amount of force required to shear that module off the front of the engine is substantial. I really hope they will be able to recover the part but I fear we will never know which is going to make puzzling out how this could have happened extremely hard. Though the people working on these cases never fail to impress with their ability to retrieve the story from a pile of fragments you need to those fragments to begin with and the most important bits are missing here.
- einrealist 9y agoThe fan failure was probably contained by the cowling. But the cowling broke right after because of stresses imposed by the damage and wind. If that's so, the cowling worked. The inner fans look damaged, so I assume the outer fan particles flew through the engine like expected.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- userbinator 9y agoIndeed, you could say that the front fell off. That's not very typical.
- noobermin 9y agoI know we're not supposed to upvote or acknowledge jokes on HN, but this was in such good taste I couldn't resist.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Judgmentality 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html It doesn't say anything about jokes.
- anyfoo 9y agoI think the unspoken agreement is that nobody wants HN discussions to turn into reddit with its overabundant pun threads and "funny" one liners. But this one was on point.
- hrrsn 9y agoFor anyone that didn't get the reference, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3m5qxZm_JqM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3m5qxZm_JqM. Worth a watch!
- mhh__ 9y agoRIP John Clarke :(
- timb07 9y agoIt's rare that the funny response is actually more likely to be the accurate response. One possibility is that the fan shaft failed, and since the fan was no longer attached to the plane that it had been pulling through the sky, it went happily ahead by itself (perhaps still in one piece), taking the cowling with it.
- cyberferret 9y agoSeriously lucky that the disintegration didn't take out vital hydraulics or fuel systems in the wing, or penetrate the pressurised fuselage. I'd like to hope that this wasn't caused by ground crew error, i.e. an improperly secured cowling or access hatch, which snowballed into major component failure...
- bad_alloc 9y agoThe A380 has two hydraulic systems. If the priamry fails, the aircraft is still fully flyable. Some extra things like slats don't work anymore but those aren't critical for flight and landing. If the secondary hydraulics fail, there are still extra electric actuators to move the control surfaces. Source: http://www.roger-wilco.net/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/Untitled-110.jpg http://www.roger-wilco.net/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/Untitl...
- revelation 9y agoI mean, primary and backup hydraulics are hopelessly intertwined on this systems diagram, certainly physically. Not sure how much that is going to help against parts flying into it. Which is of course what happened in that linked incident below: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_232 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_232 The three hydraulic systems were separate, so that failure of any one of them would leave the crew with full control, but lines for all three systems shared the same narrow passage through the tail where the engine debris had penetrated, and thus control surfaces were inoperative.
- anarazel 9y agoIIRC there's valves to contain such failures at regular intervals. And the electrical backup system can then provide some power in the cutoff sections. I'd hope that airplane designers learned a thing or two since the DC-10 (and have some additional tools to play with).
- WalterBright 9y ago
- WalterBright 9y agoSounds like it was over water, meaning they won't be able to retrieve the fan to determine why it failed.
- waqf 9y agoThere's some suggestion that it was over Greenland: https://twitter.com/flightradar24/status/914197103026622464 https://twitter.com/flightradar24/status/914197103026622464.
- ScottBurson 9y agoAlso: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/30/world/plane-engine-explodes.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/30/world/plane-engine-explod...
- ichadade 9y agoThis screams of poor servicing.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt does? How can you conclude that without having inspected the missing parts? It could be a manufacturing defect, it could be all kinds of other things including a design flaw, to conclude that it 'screams of bad servicing' without having any evidence on an incident that is not even a day old is jumping to conclusions.
- ant6n 9y ago"Screams of x" is an educated guess, not a conclusion.
- jacquesm 9y agoAn educated guess is something entirely different than throwing out the first thing that comes to mind in a complex situation. Evidence, not guesses is where it is at.
- ant6n 9y agoI'm merely pointing out that the parent mischaracterized the statement as a conclusion. It's just a guess. (it's also an unnecessarily adversarial post) You are trying to counter my observation about terminology, guess vs conclusion, by saying that evidence is better. Not really relevant.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cycrutchfield 9y agoTypically, fan blades failing are due to metallurgical defects during manufacturing. Not sure where you are getting poor servicing from.
- jacquesm 9y agoLucky break that didn't happen over a city, that's some pretty serious aircraft droppings and if they had fallen onto a market or a highway hear the point of departure (or anywhere else, but typically aircraft are only overflying cities near airports) it would have been very ugly.
- conistonwater 9y ago> The passengers report they are still on board of the aircraft about 2 hours after landing because the airport does not have stairs to accommodate the A380. Does anybody know how this works? Why not just use any old ladder?
- jacquesm 9y agoRisk to the passengers. If there is no imminent risk then it is better to wait for the right device than to risk passengers falling off ladders from 10 meters and higher, the A380 is a huge plane and those doors are pretty high up.
- userbinator 9y agoThe A380 is high enough that the ladders (technically airstairs) available probably couldn't even reach the doors. http://www.tips.si/pdf/Door-Sill-Heights-Passenger-Stairs-2458.pdf http://www.tips.si/pdf/Door-Sill-Heights-Passenger-Stairs-24... Interestingly enough, an A330/340 can be even higher, but only slightly (~30cm).
- rpeden 9y agoMakes sense, but I wonder what they'll end up doing. Nobody's going to be driving a set of A380 compatible air stairs to Goose Bay.
- cybrjoe 9y agoMy guess? Liability.
- userbinator 9y agoA similar thing happened to a Southwest B737 last year: http://avherald.com/h?article=49d2d7e3 http://avherald.com/h?article=49d2d7e3
- lsh123 9y ago“The dreaded three engines approach”
- SmellTheGlove 9y agoIt's amazing to me that modern aircraft engineering is so good that an engine can lose its fan blade entirely at 35000 feet and the plane can still continue on for 2 hours and safely land. An uncontained failure like this is the worst kind, and I know it could have gone worse, but it didn't and that amazes me. I wonder if the cowling contained the initial disintegration but was removed in the process. I'm not an engineer, but from the way that looks and the fact that nothing flew off and did further damage makes me at least wonder if that's what happened.
- CydeWeys 9y agoThe A380 has four engines in total, and can easily tolerate the loss of just one in normal flight. Adding more engines has been a basic way to increase reliability since the beginning of the field; it's not just modern aircraft engineering. There's no other part of the airplane behind the engines either, so nothing to be hit by debris. What amazes me more is that the newest twinjets are now considered reliable enough to fly six hours away from the nearest landing strip -- that's how far they can coast on the single remaining engine if necessary!
- inamberclad 9y agoIt's not really coasting. A transport category aircraft is required to have enough power to continue climbing if it loses an engine, so it must also have enough power to maintain level flight indefinitely (barring fuel consumption, oil leaks, or mechanical damage from an engine failure)
- CydeWeys 9y agoI meant to say "cruise", if that makes more sense.
- KGIII 9y agoIf it is any consolation, I knew what you meant. Otherwise, you'd probably have said something like glide and the glide ratio of the big planes isn't very good. Out of curiosity, I just checked for the A380 and the best guess is 15:1, so it does glide better than I expected, but still not that far. Google tells me that it'd glide ~130 miles if it had a starting altitude of 45,000'. That's better than I expected.
- myth_buster 9y agoAre there any serious dangers of debris falling over settlements in scenarios like these?
- gnarbarian 9y agoWhen you consider the frequency of incidents like this and factor in how sparsely populated most of the world is you'd have far better odds winning the lottery.
- stevenwoo 9y agoColumbia broke up over the continental United States and a large number of the pieces that did not burn up in reentry were recovered and no one was hurt on the ground by being hit by debris AFAIK. Not sure of the direct comparison but it seems less likely than getting hit by lightning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_Columbia_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_Columbia_disaste...
- khuey 9y agoDebris from the Qantas A380 engine failure several years back fell on some buildings in Indonesia. Nobody was hurt though.
- CydeWeys 9y agoThere's thousands of other more dangerous things you should worry about in your daily life. Like lightning or shark attacks. Now on the other hand, you could be taken out by an entire airplane crashing, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Airlines_Flight_587 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Airlines_Flight_587
- ghaff 9y agoPeople on the ground were also killed as a result of the Pan Am Lockerbie bombing.
- FabHK 9y agoAnd quite a few when El Al 1862 crashed into a building near Amsterdam Shiphol airport (both engines on one side of the cargo 747 had come off, plus leading edge of the wing, and when they later slowed down for landing, that side stalled irrecoverably :-/ But that's not debris, that was a whole damn 747. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Al_Flight_1862 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Al_Flight_1862
- maxwer 9y agoSigh. The thing I miss about the internet in 1995 is that not everyone was an "aviation expert".
- magnat 9y agoThat's the most neutral-point-of-view flight incident news article I've seen for quite some time. The whole site is so refreshingly level-headed.
- userbinator 9y agoAVherald is run by a single person who just compiles reports of incidents as they're received, so there's absolutely no editorialising goes on.
- FabHK 9y agoYup, it's an absolutely brilliant resource. Simon sometimes injects some dry humour ("Incident: British Airways A388 near London on Mar 13th 2016, free shower in lower deck" [1]), but it's very level-headed, comprehensive, factual reporting. Well worth supporting, btw! http://avherald.com/h?article=4957cf35&opt=0 http://avherald.com/h?article=4957cf35&opt=0
- yeukhon 9y agoNot exactly the same, but in the summer China Eastern Airlines had to return to Sydney because one of the engines was basically failing apart... http://www.news.com.au/travel/travel-updates/incidents/china-eastern-airlines-airbus-a330-turns-back-to-sydney-after-hole-torn-in-engine-cowling/news-story/d3aefb53f996b9c1ee9d89a34020e757 http://www.news.com.au/travel/travel-updates/incidents/china...
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoThere were questions in the article and one close over here, but no answer AFAIK : how did the move people from one plane to another if they could not desimbark them in the first place? Is the a way to connect two A380s together? (wild guess)
- Narishma 9y agoThey transfered them to two smaller planes, not to another A380.
- cpncrunch 9y agoThe article was incorrect...it was just passenger speculation. Probably the airport just didn't have the facilities to accommodate that number of passengers.
- grkvlt 9y agoThey used stairs for a 747 and disembarked from the lower deck doors only. The main reason for keeping pax on the plane was that it is not a commercial airport, and cannot handle customs/immigration for an A380 sized (anything > 15 pax, actually) aircraft. Only when the two new planes were available did they moved pax to them.
- benmarks 9y agoHere's a GIF of the landing: https://gfycat.com/VastForthrightBarb https://gfycat.com/VastForthrightBarb
- laythea 9y agoI think I will wait until these A380's are "broken in" before getting on one if I have the choice.
- FabHK 9y agoA380: first flight 2005, about 215 built B787: first flight 2009, about 600 built A350: first flight 2013, about 100 built Off the three, I'd mostly avoid the 787. I still find the A380 the most comfortable, due to all the space. Lower cabin altitude in 787 and 350 is nice, but doesn't compensate for cramped conditions. I'm a bit concerned about bleed air. (The high pressure air to maintain cabin pressure comes from the compressor stage of the engines, and could be contaminated with oil/fuel/?, and so far only the 787 has done away with that ("bleedless aircraft").) But, damn, that spacious A380 cabin.
- JshWright 9y agoThe 787 also has a saner UX for primary flight controls (linked yokes, rather than independent sidesticks).
- brohee 9y ago10 years not good enough for you? Do you only fly 727?
- laythea 9y agoIn aviation, that is new and shiny :)
- dominotw 9y agoThis reminds me of aloha 243 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aloha_Airlines_Flight_243 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aloha_Airlines_Flight_243 > As a result of the accident, the airplane was determined to be damaged beyond repair and was dismantled on-site Amazing that one one person lost her life.