4 ms·
> “Both sides are upset about ideas and content they don’t like,” he wrote in a Facebook post. “That’s what running a platform for all ideas looks like.” > Thi
by paulddraper 9y ago
> “Both sides are upset about ideas and content they don’t like,” he wrote in a Facebook post. “That’s what running a platform for all ideas looks like.”
> This doesn’t hold water at all.
It does, almost by definition.
> Are you bothered by fake news, systematic misinformation campaigns and Facebook “dark posts” — micro-targeted ads not visible to the public — aimed at African-Americans to discourage them from voting? You must be one of those people “upset about ideas” you disagree with.
Users can control which ads they see.
> Are you troubled when agents of a foreign power pose online as American Muslims and post incendiary content that right-wing commentators can cite as evidence that all American Muslims are sympathizers of terrorist groups like the Islamic State? Sounds like you can’t handle a healthy debate.
I can debate that.
> Does it bother you that Russian actors bought advertisements aimed at swing states to sow political discord during the 2016 presidential campaign, and that it took eight months after the election to uncover any of this? Well, the marketplace of ideas isn’t for everyone.
I do remember pro-Clinton anti-Trump opinions from leaders in dozens of countries. The influence of the Russian boogeyman is vastly overstated.
> And the unfortunate truth is that by design, business model and algorithm, Facebook has made it easy for it to be weaponized to spread misinformation and fraudulent content.
The best defense against false speech is more speech. An elite centralized few deciding what can and can't be said to we the sheeple is not the future I want.
- squozzer 9y agoWhat remains unclear to me is how Facebook makes misinformation and fraudulent content so powerful, but not factual content. I have yet to hear one person admit they did any of the following: 1) Switch their vote from HRC to DJT; 2) Decide to stay home instead of vote for HRC; 3) Decide to vote for DJT instead of staying home. If we're going to consider whether FB was complicit in a dirty win by DJT, we should at least also consider some of the polls were fabricated in a attempt to make HRC's victory look inevitable and depress R turnout.
- thesagan 9y agoI admit to number 2, as a lot of us in MI did. I just stayed home because I was so disappointed in HRC. Fun fact, in my state the number of ballots with a blank presidential section exceeded the margin of HRC's loss in the state. This was a Bernie state.
- jessaustin 9y agoWe can all regret that DNC wiped their asses with the majority of votes in the primaries. Bernie would have beaten Trump.
- madeofpalk 9y agoBecause misinformation can be as catchy and as (un) appealing as you want, whereas the truth is almost mostly a lot more boring. > If we're going to consider whether FB was complicit in a dirty win by DJT, My observation of the discussion is that no one (well, very few) is trying to claim that FB was complicit, but their inaction and what defines them as a platform implicitly involved themselves in all of this.
- jessaustin 9y ago...the truth is almost mostly a lot more boring. By this metric, which should we believe? That a) one unpopular candidate barely beat some other unpopular candidate, or that b) some heretofore unimagined global conspiracy of crypto-Stalinists overturned what would have been an electoral landslide just by trolling from some sockpuppet accounts?
- madeofpalk 9y agoAs an outsider watching this all play out from Australia, it was always my understanding that it was a bit of both. HRC is extremely unlikeable, an easy target to hate, but I don’t think they expected their opposition to play ‘dirty’ on social the way they did.
- jessaustin 9y ago...bit of both The only reason anyone believes anything untoward happened (other than Bernie getting shafted in the primary by the DNC, because we have actual proof of that) is that they previously believed Clinton was poised for a landslide victory. There is no overlap between that fantasy and the truth that few voters liked either candidate, but the process is set up to pick a winner anyway.
- gamechangr 9y ago"we should at least also consider some of the polls were fabricated in a attempt to make HRC's victory look inevitable and depress R turnout" That rings true to me. I would be curious if anyone would disagree with that?
- JoBrad 9y agoI’m sure that somewhere, a poll was fabricated to make this seem true. Much like the maps showing Facebook shares supporting Trump and thereby “proving” that Trump was really winning, and the polls were rigged. People remember the last example much more than any real examples of actual poll rigging, though.
- madeofpalk 9y ago> Users can control which ads they see. What? How is this, in reality, even remotely true?