11 ms·
Wozniak and Copps: Ending net neutrality will end the Internet as we know it
- koolba 9y agoFrom the article: > If Pai’s majority permits fast lanes for the biggest internet service providers (ISPs like Comcast, Verizon and AT&T), companies could speed up or slow down the sites and services they prefer. Is the slow down part a real thing? I'm familiar with local peering to speed up last mile services (ex: Netflix hubs) but I'm not aware of ISPs targeting specific companies to slow down their bandwidth. Beyond generic packet shaping to slow down or limit your overall connection, is targeted throttling like that for real? IANAL but I'd imagine the latter would get an ISP's ass handed to them in a lawsuit. > Fast lanes or “paid prioritization” create anticompetitive incentives for ISPs to favor their own services over those of their competitors. A better solution is to require that ISPs be only ISPs. If they don't have their own content mills to push then you don't have this problem. While you're at it, split out the physical maintenance of the pipes from the companies providing the ISP services so that the latter can compete as well. Ah fuck it, just let the municipality run it and be done with this. Then we can all go to our local townhall meetings and listen to irate neighbors rail at our local representatives for throttling their porn downloads.
- an_account 9y agoISPs have already been caught throttling services, including Netflix.
- rhino369 9y agoThey've been caught not upgrading peering links that are saturated by Netflix. Net neutrality doesn't really protect against that.
- inetsee 9y agoI agree with one thing you said: if the barriers to municipalities providing broadband internet are removed, then the current monopolies will discover what true competition feels like, and a lot of customers, especially those in underserved rural communities, will discover what true world class broadband internet service feel like. See https://www.thenation.com/article/chattanooga-was-a-typical-post-industrial-city-then-it-began-offering-municipal-broadband/ https://www.thenation.com/article/chattanooga-was-a-typical-... for a description of what I mean.
- vetinari 9y ago> A better solution is to require that ISPs be only ISPs. If they don't have their own content mills to push then you don't have this problem. That train left the station long time ago. Today almost all of them are tripple-play providers, meaning that will want competing TV and phone services to be "worse".
- jbuzbee 9y ago>> Is the slow down part a real thing? They don't necessarily have to slow down competitors. They can just leave them at today's available bandwidth and speed. So ten years from now only companies who pay the toll, or ISP's own content, will stream over multi-gigabit connections. All others will be stuck at 2017 rates.
- timthelion 9y agoSlow down is real. When I was in uni the network admins had the Internet configured so that there was a throttle down for any connection longer than a minute and anything that looked like P2P. Browsing was fast, but when you clicked a download link you'd see the bandwidth go from 250kbs to ~40kbs right at the minute mark. Very frustrating. I used to pause and resume downloads manually to get around it.
- koolba 9y agoThat's not throttling a specific service though. That's generic traffic shaping that would apply regardless of what you're connecting to.
- marak830 9y agoWasn't Netflix being artifically slowed down at one point?
- rsynnott 9y agoSome European mobile ISPs briefly degraded Skype service on their cheaper plans (Skype being the big VOIP thing at the time). Stopped pretty quickly; I assume they got a nasty letter from the EC.
- terravion 9y agoOne use case that I'd like to see that runs contrary to the spirit of net neutrality is the ability to buy a 'data transfer' service tier. I.e. lots of data has to move from somewhere to the public cloud and most telecom infrastructure sits under-utilized especially at night. I would more believe the telcos that net neutrality is innovation stifling if any of them had ever taken our money when we wanted to buy intentionally low priority service, but at huge throughput, for cheap. Anyone know where we can buy said service?
- draugadrotten 9y ago> Anyone know where we can buy said service? That's essentially what most residential internet is all about... all the data is being moved at low priority at lowest cost and no penalties whatsoever for broken service. Business internet is different, with much different SLAs but for the most part without serious penalties. For the critical data stuff, look into banking SLAs etc where penalties are severe.
- sillysaurus3 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vQmTZTq7nw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vQmTZTq7nw "Never underestimate the bandwidth of a station wagon full of tapes barreling down the highway at 70mph."
- Animats 9y agoHave you ever tried to read a thousand tapes? Weeks. I was once involved in a project to copy old Stanford SAIL backup tapes. They just needed people to load tapes on a drive, wait, unload, and go on to the next tape. Reading a tape took 20 minutes. Transfer time over the Internet to a file server took under a minute.
- skj 9y agoI think we can update the story to include a stack of usb-accessed petabyte drives.
- rdiddly 9y agoNo kidding, right, but the problem as usual is, how do we get these assholes (the FCC, an unelected body) to do the will of (77% of) the people? I'm so sick of wheedling and cajoling and writing letters and asking pretty-please...
- notadoc 9y ago> how do we get these assholes (the FCC, an unelected body) to do the will of (77% of) the people? Hire lobbyists. Whoever pays the most wins.
- rsynnott 9y agoVote for a president who’ll appoint a less mad head of the FCC, perhaps? It’s not a directly elected position, but it’s not like it’s totally outside electoral politics.
- qengho 9y agoRiiight.. because when there was no net neutrality there was no Internet as we know it. Oh wait.
- c22 9y agoI don't understand. Net neutrality was the default state of the early internet. The internet wouldn't exist as we know it without this guiding principle. It is only the recent deviations of this principle by providers that has prompted the movement to codify these ideas into laws.
- qengho 9y agoThere were no "net neutrality" regulations in the US till 2015. Nevertheless none of the horror scenarios net neutrslity proponents like to cook up came to pass, and in fact the 'Net grew to "the Internet as we know it" precisely in an era of no net neutrality regulations. That's ample proof (if any were needed) that all the net neutrality FUD is just that. In a free market, if an ISP was to mess with the traffic going through its pipes, that would just encourage anyone who cared about this to switch to a competitor. The real problem is the lack of a free market, which is the direct result of over-proliferation of laws and regulations, which discourage and stifle innovative businesses. Net neutrality regulations are just another layer of these, and will further cripple innovative competition and lead to increased monopolization of Internet infrastructure by big crony-statist corporations. More fundamentally, it is a violation of basic individual rights and property rights for the government to tell any private enterprise how to operate its business. That's the economics of fascism.
- oconnore 9y ago"The internet" or "the web" is already dead, in the sense that most people use a handful of sites run by a handful of large companies. The internet could essentially be a native app run by a corporate governing body and more than 95% of people wouldn't notice. Net neutrality is an irrelevant issue given that situation. And if you want to change that situation, pay-to-play is the least of your worries: convincing people to change their walled garden habits will be far more pricey.
- oliv__ 9y agoNo it's not. Just because most people's use of the Internet can be summed up by visits to X, Y and Z.com doesn't mean I can't create W.com to take them over. You can still compete. Without net neutrality, forget about it.
- harryf 9y ago> Without net neutrality, forget about it. Why? I just don't see it. It makes no sense that telecoms companies are going to go after startups that anyway don't have money. But I can imagine YouTube, for example, is another story, given how much bandwidth must be consumed by it.
- apoorvkumar 9y agoHow about Comcast put a straight up 10% equity cost for their 'start-up bundle' to use their 'non-substandard' channel? Would you be ok with that?
- oconnore 9y agoDo you want an FTC antitrust case? Because this is how you get an FTC antitrust case...
- apoorvkumar 9y agoThe net providers and Ajit Pai's would sell it as a 'premium feature' being made available to poor start-ups at a discount. FTC can't go after Amazon for giving out large AWS servers to start ups for some equity.
- ianai 9y agoThen again, we’re seeing massive amounts of hacking and propaganda on the current internet. Change is probably over due, but not this kind.
- nnfy 9y agoNet neutrality includes a clause that places ISPs into the category of "common carrier," which allows the government to regulate the internet as a telecommunicationa company. This makes me nervous, I'd much rather the government stay out of the internet. Legislation is painfully slow to both make and unmake, and legislators will almost certainly be out of touch with the technology and there is a real risk of a restricted, heavily regulated internet which is far worse than what we have today. Not to mention that such a classification opens up ISPs to equal time laws, where the government decides who is or is not a candidate and forces telecom companies to play equal ad time for all candidates. Here's a great example of how this law would have already broken down: how many Republican candidates were there last election? Would you have wanted your ISP to be responsible for shoving political ads down your throat? How could you even enforce equal time laws on ISPs? Net neutrality is a power grab by the U.S. government, and the propaganda has been well executed IMO; but I really hope that we will leave the internet to the markets. I dont trust our government to make something as enormous and complex as the internet any better, and it's been going quite well so far.
- tomc1985 9y agoYou would instead leave governance of the internet in the hands of business execs that care for little more than extracting as much value as possible for themselves and their companies?
- nnfy 9y agoYes, because when entities compete, consumers typically win. The government in the U.S. has already regulated ISPs to the point that an enormous artificial barrier has arisen to market entry. We need deregulation. Approval for the major carriers in the U.S. is low enough[0] that someone could probably disrupt the entire industry, except it is next to impossible to enter. You're also aware of regulatory capture, right? This regulation was premature, and, as is typical of government, overreaching. Imagine even further expanding the power of the last three administrations, especially with the disaster that is the patriot act. Regulations are bad for business and bad for innovation, outside of monopoly laws, and those give me pause as well. 0. http://www.fiercecable.com/cable/comcast-still-ranks-last-customer-experience-survey-focused-top-pay-tv-companies http://www.fiercecable.com/cable/comcast-still-ranks-last-cu...
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago>This is a core issue for our civil society. Americans of every political persuasion depend on the internet to educate themselves on the issues of the day, speak their minds, and organize for change. Mass mobilizations on all sides of the climate, health care and immigration debates illustrate the point. The authors talk as if the ISPs will suppress political opinion. However, I am not aware of a single case where ISPs suppressed political opinions. However, there are cases where the dominant search monopoly may have suppressed political opinion (https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/09/26/technology/google-search-bias-claims.html?referer=https://www.google.com/ https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/09/26/technology/google-sear...). Also, several registrar services together made it impossible for a website to have a domain. Also, the major consumer DDOS protection company removed the above website from their protection because of content, there making it easy for someone opposed to the website to DDOS them and keep their message from getting out. This is why Net Neutrality is getting limited traction with the public. If we talk about net neutrality from a business perspective, they don't see any real harm. For example, a lot of the cell companies are offering zero rated music and movie streaming from select companies. Net Neutrality would end that. You could argue that net neutrality would prevent competitors from forming. However, my guess is that obtaining music and movie rights would be far more expensive and difficult than signing deals with ISPs to get on the fast lane. And, if you try to bring the political opinion angle, it is far more likely that your speech will get suppressed by search engines, domain registrars, and DDOS companies than the ISPs. I would guess people might be more receptive to Net Neutrality for those companies.
- chowells 9y agoSpeech advocating violence and hate isn't illegal, but no one is required to provide a platform for it, either. That isn't part of net neutrality, and never will be. Net neutrality is about carrying data regardless of origin/destination. That's it. No one is ever required to be the origin or destination of any particular traffic by the rules of net neutrality. If you don't want to host a particular customer, for any reason, no rights of theirs are being violated if you say "I'm sorry, you're going to have to find another host." As for ISPs, there have been a bunch of high profile cases of them violating net neutrality that seem to be constantly ignored by people who choose to attack it. Time Warner cable intentionally degraded traffic to servers owned by Riot Games until they caved in and paid off the ISP in order to get back to average traffic quality. A quote from the NYAG filing [1]: > Data from Riot Games confirmed that from at least September 2013, when Riot Games started to maintain this data, through August 2015, when Riot Games agreed to pay Spectrum-TWC for access, Spectrum-TWC subscribers did not enjoy a “good network experience.” And let's not forget the multiple times Netflix has been shaken down by ISPs. Comcast [2] and Verizon [3] were trivial to find writeups for. They may call those "peering" agreements, but the data is pretty solid. In both cases, the problem was the ISP refusing to allow Netflix to upgrade interchange capacity, despite having plenty of bandwidth available on both sides of the interchange. Netflix only got to improve the situation by paying the ISP for access to their customers. This is a very clear violation of net neutrality. These are a set of events that actually happened. They aren't vague warnings about worse cases, they're violations that already have been observed. I do not believe the practice will magically never happen if it becomes legal again. [1] https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/summons_and_complaint.pdf https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/summons_and_complaint.... [2] https://www.theverge.com/2014/3/24/5541916/netflix-deal-with-the-devil-why-reed-hastings-violated-his-principles https://www.theverge.com/2014/3/24/5541916/netflix-deal-with... [3] http://time.com/80192/netflix-verizon-paid-peering-agreement/ http://time.com/80192/netflix-verizon-paid-peering-agreement...
- timthelion 9y agoI get my Internet through CZFree, a non-profit community mesh network that covers Prague. The legal structure is the same as a non-profit private club. Members can vote for administrators. A membership fee pays for those who put the large expensive multi-directional Ubiquity routers on their roofs and also for a number of symmetric high bandwidth tier 1 fiber-optic connections throughout the city. Anyone can join the network and contribute by putting a multi-directional antenna on their roof. Or they can simply become clients to the network by using a directional antenna pointed at a multi-directional antenna. Overall, the speed is much faster than with commercial Internet, and the bandwidth is symmetrical. In my opinion, this is a good example of the two faces of the left. One person forms a union and tries to bully their employer into giving them better conditions, or petitions the state to create laws which will benefit them. The other face of the left creates co-ops and gives the corporate world the finger. I personally believe that the second approach is superior to the first, and rather than trying to twist Comcast's arm into being nice, Americans should focus on building community networks, at least in the cities where such a thing is possible.
- zerohp 9y agoCorporations have twisted community politics to make such things very difficult. In my community, a municipal fiber optic network was built throughout the area but lobbying and politics made it nearly impossible to finish, so there are very few homes connected.
- timthelion 9y agoWhat laws exist against a 5ghz ubiquity mesh network? I know that such laws can be challenging. Here, there was a proposed law to charge money for the use of that wireless band. The law was very unpopular however, and was not passed. But I can understand that happening.
- danieldk 9y agoWhat laws exist against a 5ghz ubiquity mesh network? That easy: make you liable for what people do on your network. Make it hard to register as an official network provider that would forfeit some of the liability. https://qz.com/694618/why-is-it-impossible-to-find-free-wi-fi-in-germany/ https://qz.com/694618/why-is-it-impossible-to-find-free-wi-f... (AFAIR, in Germany there are some changes now, but it's a good example how Internet sharing is made difficult for anyone without a large legal department.)
- AndrewUnmuted 9y ago> Yet even as our political discourse reaches unprecedented levels of polarization, some 77% of Americans, including overwhelming majorities of both Republicans and Democrats, support maintaining net neutrality. This really says it all. All of the big tech companies, and a majority of Americans, all agree that net neutrality is good. Given this, we should be running away screaming from net neutrality, and should be rushing to implement Pai's plan. How could anything good possibly reach this kind of consensus? Well, because it's not good. The majority of Americans don't understand net neutrality, and the corporations backing net neutrality do understand it - they understand that it will legally solidify their standing as monopolies, and wipe out their competition. The 'fast lanes' concept is a fantasy. Tech companies love net neutrality, because it will allow them to avoid having to sink enormous expenses into maintaining high quality digital video infrastructure. It will create a culture of media viewers who do not expect their ISPs to support greater and greater bandwidths, thereby conditioning them to not expect greater quality than they receive today. Tech firms see the inability of the USA's major telecoms to step up their bandwidth game, and how significantly this is impacting the UX of their online streaming services. These tech firms don't want to put all of the innovation in achieving more efficient video compression on themselves. Net neutrality will remove the business opportunity that would otherwise be there to innovate in shaping traffic across the web to serve the individual needs of each user. This means less costs the tech firms must incur to build video encoding and streaming infrastructure, and less R&D money paid out to great organizations like Xiph. Today, ISPs have taken to limiting the quality of streaming media, sometimes even transcoding it in real-time to the user's device, so that the content falls under a certain bandwidth constraint. See T-Mobile's BingeOn program. This is not any better than a provider offering fast lanes for certain services or streaming protocols. In fact, it is worse. Forget that it significantly stunts the mobile media industry's progression towards higher quality. Worse yet is that it sets the precedent that in order to control bandwidth usage towards following some foolishly egalitarian federal policy, ISPs shall manipulate the content you want to watch. A mobile user who wants to stream a 4K signal, only to have that stream transcoded to 1080p, is being censored, as is the content creator whose work is being sullied by AT&T's edge servers. Net neutrality is a horrible idea, and I really don't think those who support it have thought about the underlying reasons for all the corporate support. There is no altruistic intent on the part of these firms here - they want this policy enacted to maintain their stranglehold over the competition without having to innovate, and while stifling the innovation of their potential competitors.
- gwatch 9y agoNet neutrality is socialism, as in government getting in the way of free enterprise. It stifles innovation as Ajit Pai pointed out. Leftist groupthink of course will not allow you to say this in public
- thelock85 9y agoSeems this move would leave the free-for-your-soul business models to BigIT (bigger target for regulation/politics) and force the NewCos to actually build a different Internet. Unfortunately, "NewCo is changing the world..." is so 2012.
- yellowapple 9y ago"One of us is the inventor of the personal computer" I didn't realize Woz invented the Kenbak-1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenbak-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenbak-1 ;)
- pasbesoin 9y agoIf you care about a free and open Internet, you'll work on the next generation of physical layer. One that is not subject to self-serving corporate and government control. All the rest is just asking for something they've already made clear they don't want to give you. (And won't, using physical force as a last resort.) (I originally wrote "interest and manipulation", but in that regard, how are they any different than the rest of us? But "control"? No, not that.)
- marak830 9y agoOr push for what we have here in Japan? One government company owns all the lines, but isn't allowed to sell bandwidth to customers, but has to allow any changes npany to resell that bandwidth. Competition is pretty damn good here (coming from Aus), and speeds are amazing. My last connection was 2gb/s for around $40 us/month with no cap or throttling.
- Feniks 9y agoWow talk about Americentrism. I will be just fine, the FCC has no authority here.
- danbolt 9y agoThe US's greatest export is culture right now, and I'd hate to see this influence other western democracies. You're right though, in that other places outside the United States won't immediately see issues.
- bo1024 9y agoNet neutrality in the USA affects everyone because it will shape the future of competition on the web in one of the largest and most important markets. Basically, entrenched giants will be much harder to disrupt across the globe, because of their huge incumbent advantage in the USA. A startup trying to disrupt Google, Facebook, Netflix, etc. will have a much harder time succeeding if it doesn't have equal/fair access to the American market. Added to the fact that historically most web startups come from the USA, and you're talking about a potentially huge decrease in total innovation on the web.
- justherefortart 9y agoGood thing you don't use any .com sites, like google, facebook, netflix, or even news.ycombinator.com. Wow, talk about disconnect.
- Feniks 9y ago.com isn't an American domain.
- ionised 9y agoIt is unfortunately; The domain was originally administered by the United States Department of Defense, but is today operated by Verisign, and remains under ultimate jurisdiction of U.S. law. from; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.com
- moretai 9y agoWho are some of the thought leaders that are trying to fight or find a way around this eventual neutering of the internet?
- danjoc 9y ago>Wozniak, Apple co-founder >net neutrality >Apple Siri promotes Google search engine in favor of Bing for billions of dollars. http://www.businessinsider.com/apple-siri-google-bing-2017-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/apple-siri-google-bing-2017-9 lol. Good one Woz. You're a riot.
- ionised 9y agoYou know Wozniak has nothing to do with how Apple is run these days, and hasn't for a long time?
- ozaark 9y agoEverything that we think of as new technology is founded through ground breaking innovation. As citizens, our networks have been subsidized (through tax) for public access. If you're viewing this that innovation has affected you. Having control handed away from the populous that paid for the infrastructure is wrong. Net neutrality maintains continued public innovation.
- evangelista 9y agoIf you are one of the people who wants to end "Fake News," you are also on board with ending Net Neutrality. What do you think ending Fake News involves? The only way to do it is to have the government, Google, Facebook and probably these same ISPs you hate deciding what can and can't be put online. You simply want to replace one giant beaurecratic gatekeeper with another one. Anyone dumb enough to think Fake News resulted in the election results (please, show me the data) while rushing online to scream about Net Neutrality is a pawn in the game.
- telchar 9y agoI'm tempted to make a sarcastic, hyperbolic reply to this hyperbolic and aggressive comment, but in the spirit of hacker news I'll address the content directly. You imply that the only way to mitigate the problem of fake news (no need for scare quotes, we're talking about news that is fake here) is to hand over total control of the internet to some single entity. You have failed to make any case that every other action that could be taken to mitigate fake news would be insufficient. This is far from clear to me. I think there is a great deal that could be done to mitigate fake news aside from that. Note that I say mitigate because I do not think it would need to be eliminated entirely to be effectively made powerless. Further, it's an old propagandist trick to claim that people who disagree with you are "screaming", to make them seem less rational and thus wrong. The language you choose to use in this post undercuts your points. Show me the data that fake news didn't affect the election results in any way. The probability of some effect is much greater than the probability of no effect at all, given the complexity of the system and the obvious mechanism. I think the burden of proof is on you.
- guelo 9y agoThe 4chan poison has been spreading. The poison is when these oh-so-smart culture hackers take advantage of our open systems to constantly act in bad faith "trolling" all of us with fake propaganda across all information channels. It used to be just for the lulz, but the laugh has become organized, funded, and gained much wicked intent behind it. It is a new aggressive societal disease that is taking advantage of our openness and freedom. Similar to external terrorists these internal terrorists are causing society to recoil in horror and become less free as we look for ways to protect ourselves.