3 ms·
An admirable move indeed if it was a physical object, but I'm not sure it's the right one when software is involved. Thanks to Open source licensing, a fork wou
by squarefoot 9y ago
An admirable move indeed if it was a physical object, but I'm not sure it's the right one when software is involved.
Thanks to Open source licensing, a fork would have been trivial: I'd have forked the project, then taken the money and donate half of it to EFF, GNU and other freedom friendly organizations. In a few years the word of mouth that brought VLC as no.1 player would replace it with a new one. Although in different contexts, it already happened with Openoffice->Libreoffice, Owncloud->Nextcloud, MySQL->MariaDB etc.
By doing so I would have helped myself and other people in need while taking money from advertisers.
- fencepost 9y agoNo, because a huge percentage of the user base doesn't follow tech news and is likely not even technical. All of those people would only know that their experience just gradually went to hell.
- fmx 9y agoHow did those users come to learn about VLC Player and what would stop them from learning about the fork the same way?
- jbk 9y agoThat would take years.
- mook 9y agoRemember OpenOffice.org? That is still getting ~100,000 downloads a day in April this year [1]. That's after all the Linux distros moved to LibreOffice for years. Forks work for moving development, but not necessarily for moving users. [1]: https://lwn.net/Articles/729460/ https://lwn.net/Articles/729460/
- sounds 9y agoMySQL and MariaDB are another example, if you need one. :)
- cygx 9y agoHow did those users come to learn about VLC Player A computer-savvy acquaintance installed it for them once upon a time.
- bigbugbag 9y agoIt seems you never had to deal with such users, they talk about that orange thing or the traffic cone. Which should be more than enough to explain why they would not migrate.