9 ms·
Toward a Predictive Theory of Depression
- itschekkers 9y agoChekroud (2015) here - just wanted to say that I think SSC is awesome, and does a terrific job discussing complex problems in psychiatry & philosophy.
- ainar-g 9y agoCould you give any recommendations of great articles on that blog? Or should people just go to the About/Top Posts[1] page and go down the rabbit hole from there? [1] http://slatestarcodex.com/about/ http://slatestarcodex.com/about/
- berberous 9y agoHere’s a reddit survey of people’s favorite posts, which closely matches my own: https://www.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/61qrm2/favorite_post_on_ssc_survey_2017_results/ https://www.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/61qrm2/favo... If your main interest is psychology, though, note that many of the top posts are more in the sociology and politics realm.
- VladimirGolovin 9y agoMeditations on Moloch: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ For me, it was a mind-blowing read. Highly recommended.
- ainar-g 9y agoA book review[1] linked in the article is also very interesting. [1] http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/09/05/book-review-surfing-uncertainty/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/09/05/book-review-surfing-unc...
- interfixus 9y ago> also, there’s one way to end all prediction error forever, and it’s something depressed people think about a lot We believe it will end them forever. I strongly believe so. But that's still a belief, and may itself be a prediction error.
- tetrep 9y agoWhile it's certainly true that we don't have a complete understanding of nature, I think we can safely assert that dead things don't feel, and I'm completely unaware of any evidence to the contrary (and I would think its existence would be quite noteworthy). I don't think we need to call it a "belief" anymore than we need to say Russel's Teapot not existing is a "belief." We certainly could go down that route, but then virtually everything becomes a belief and we're left with a much less meaningful term. I kinda feel like this argument is similar to an nihilist telling a logician that nothing is true.
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoAFAICT, your point basically assumes all Abrahamic religions are false (i.e., there's no afterlife). Debating that is out of scope here, but it would suggest we don't all agree that there's no feeling after death.
- interfixus 9y agoAs I said, I strongly believe the nothingness theory. And I certainly consider all Abrahamic religions (as another poster calls them) to be utter baloney. My downvoters may wish to reconsider. However! As is often bandied about in this forum, we might conceivably be living in a simulation. In which case the Abrahamic stuff wouldn't be all that baloney after all. Or I might be living in one, and being the only character in it. Et cetera blah blah blah. Or, much more to the point, the universe may indeed be far stranger than we know or can ever know. As certain as I am that my year 2100 will be exactly like my year 1900, I could actually have been wrong about the ultimate setup of the world all along.
- Smaug123 9y ago
- Alex3917 9y agoThis doesn’t make sense to me. Pretty much every purported treatment for depression involves either increasing the amount of sensory stimulation you’re getting or else becoming more attuned to sensory stimulation: exercise, acupuncture, aromatherapy, drugs, meditation, float tanks, social interaction, music, intensely flavored foods, cold therapy, saunas, electroshock therapy, etc. Occam’s razor would suggest its more likely that lack of sensory stimulation causes some sort of brain damage, e.g. inflammataion or receptor density changes, and that it just takes a few weeks to reverse. I’m not seeing what evidence there is for this pereptual confidence model beyond what I’m proposing. I wouldn’t doubt if people do get more confident in some aspects of their sensory experience, but it would seem difficult to prove this as an explanatory model.
- Klockan 9y ago> exercise, acupuncture, aromatherapy, drugs, meditation, float tanks, social interaction, music, intensely flavored foods, cold therapy, saunas, electroshock therapy, etc. None of those are guaranteed to work though, a significant number of depressed people never gets over it and it wouldn't be that way if we knew effective treatment methods.
- trapperkeeper74 9y agoThe current answer is we don’t yet have full functional pathologies of types of depression, noninvasive, specific mood disorders classified down to exact neurological dysfunctions, accurate and precise knowledge of how existing antidepressants work and evidenced-based application of particular therapies based on such scientifically-identified presentations. Clinical psychiatry has been mostly a scattergun, guesswork that lacks scientific rigor. For example, I just tapered-off mirtazepene as it stopped working after 9 years and, so far, bupropion isn’t helping. I’d really like to try S32212 if it proves safe enough in human models because it likely lacks the GI and weight-gain issues.
- 123jay7 9y agoIt's probably not even you, it's probably your life.
- tcj_phx 9y ago> Depressed people move more slowly, in a characteristic pattern called “psychomotor retardation”. They display perceptual abnormalities. They’re more likely to get sick. There are lots of results like this. > Depression has to be about something more than just beliefs; it has to be something fundamental to the nervous system. Depression is frequently related to metabolic problems: people are exhausted because their mitochondria aren't putting out enough ATP to run their nervous system. There are various interventions that can help. B-vitamins are important cofactors for burning sugar to make energy. T4 thyroid is activated by the liver to make T3, which is one factor that boosts the metabolism. If the liver is overworked (alcohol, drugs, hormonal imbalance, too much pufa, etc), it can have trouble activating adequate thyroid. Emotional resiliency is a big factor here too. My friend was really just lonely before she met me. She's doing better now because she now has a 'vision' for her future (she originally 'lost her future' when she was expelled from high school, essentially for being depressed and self-medicating with drugs that are now being investigated for treating depression).
- tsomctl 9y agoI find that creatine helps, which weight lifters take to make it easier for your muscles to use ATP.
- jadbox 9y agoI wouldn't recommend taking creatine if you don't work out or get cardio. Without that, creatine can cause weight gain due to water retention. If you do exercise, creatine should an essential be part of your stack.
- trapperkeeper74 9y agoUmm, not sure this is universal but partial. Depression seems evolutionary psych for multiple, overlapping purposes: - Reducing aggression (and hence conflict) in larger groups. - Focusing on existential re/purpose by turning inward (ie find a new job/hobby/outlook/philosophy). Lots of reading, writing and ideation. Hopefully rebuild confidence/positivity with completing something. - Retreating for terminal resource consumption minimization. Leave more for the young. Also, anecdotally, I did everything “right” (ie CBT, frequent vigorous exercise, solid career, friends, sleep hygiene, address sleep apnea) and still couldn’t escape depression’s “mind pain” and depressive state. Only medication worked, like parting the clouds, waking up refreshed and organized thinking instead of a jumble.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eradicatethots 9y agoMedication will stop working, it always does.
- fujiters 9y agoThat's the spirit! In all seriousness, what else is there to do? Take whatever relief you can get while you can get it.
- eradicatethots 9y agoRemove bad habits/ behaviors/people... cure the problem
- defined 9y agoSo you are hoping there will be an ELE for the human species? Because that's the only way your prescription is going to cure the problem on a global basis for the foreseeable future.
- hashberry 9y ago> Depression has to be about something more than just beliefs; it has to be something fundamental to the nervous system. Is he saying thoughts and beliefs aren't fundamental to the nervous system/CNS/brain? What if people get depressed because their lives suck and they had a shitty childhood? Also, why are women twice as likely to get depressed than men?[0] If "happiness is the derivative of neural confidence"... then do men have more neural confidence? [0] http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/depression/in-depth/depression/art-20047725 http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/depression/in-...
- musage 9y ago> Not only became adaption to the given reality the goal of development, but the pathological was seen as a failure to adapt to reality. The validity of that reality was not questioned. The sick carried the blame for being sick. That the pathological could sometimes be the only way to maintain autonomy itself in the face of pseudo-social realities was completely outside the ken of such a mode of thought. -- Arno Gruen, "The Betrayal of the Self" That people get depressed or sick in other ways isn't terribly surprising. Look at the world we're making for ourselves and others to live in. It's like toddlers getting sick when crawling on a floor so dirty you can hardly see the floor, and if our first and only reaction is to ask why would the toddler get sick and what kind of protective clothing could they wear, because we're unwilling to face those shitting on the floor, it does not take a scientist to see what's going on. Putting your head over a microscope like an ostrich is what's required to not see it. Yes, there are actual intricate mechanisms. Just like there are for getting infected in an environment full of pathogens. I'm not even saying they are not interesting or worth studying and quantifying and whatnot. Microscopes are useful, for some things essential. But sometimes the lame, boring answer, like "the world is still too unjust, too many children get abused or neglected in so many ways, often enough because their parents get trampled on, too", is the correct one, that is, it's the correct first part, it requires then acting on that. Until that sentence is no longer true. It's like a spoon to a soup; whoever told you using a fork is more elegant is trapped and trying to trap you.
- theptip 9y ago> What if people get depressed because their lives suck and they had a shitty childhood? But people don't only get depressed because of those things; plenty of people's "lives suck" who aren't depressed, and plenty of people with good lives _are_ depressed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_depressive_disorder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_depressive_disorder says: "The cause is believed to be a combination of genetic, environmental, and psychological factors.... About 40% of the risk appears to be related to genetics." So yes, thoughts and beliefs are part of depression, but they certainly don't explain all of it.
- Klockan 9y agoWhen I was depressed I had perfect trust in my ability to predict events, it was just that no matter how much I tried I couldn't predict a future where I weren't constantly in agony. I got over it by letting go of most things that were hurting me like friends, family, dreams etc. So now I live a fairly unassuming life but I am content. It might sound a bit boring but it is much better than living in agony every day for the rest of your life.
- sleepyandlazy 9y agoHow did you let go? I've tried things like meditation, but it always feels like things keep coming back.
- 123jay7 9y agoOne doesn't "try" meditation. One becomes meditation.
- Klockan 9y agoIt wasn't something I just decided to do, 15 years of hating my life eroded almost everything but my basic needs. Now I can look back at that time and with confidence say 'no' when asked to do something which would cause me to relapse.
- einmaliger 9y ago> it was just that no matter how much I tried I couldn't predict a future where I weren't constantly in agony That's a great way to put it. I had a few depressive episodes in my life, I know that these thoughts and feelings are symptoms. The inability to feel, even the hopelessness are symptoms of the disease. Usually, I can even pinpoint the cause of the episode. But another symptom is the inability to imagine a state of mind without depression. And no matter how rational you are, it is very difficult to believe in something that you cannot imagine.
- seunosewa 9y agoTake the medicines so you can enjoy an even better life.
- kipDynamite 9y agoAnd yet no mention of whether or not anyone is expected to feel fulfilled in life... Just "Hey buddy, what's up with your neurology, dog? Bro, what's with your nerves all being on a downer and shit? The function output you're charting on this graph is WHACK! We gotta fix that. Totally gotta be your attitude, turn that frown upside down!" It's pretty tone deaf to read this article and imagine that they're trying to march along to the beat of depression. ...and then to think about someone like this trying to "fix" someone else. ∗∗∗ shudder ∗∗∗ Nevermind legitimate, permanent lasting memories of suffering the reality of one or more tragedies. Nevermind getting lost in the modern labyrinth of industrialized society, where past a certain age, if you've not stayed ahead of the game, you're left as an isolated ghost, and a stranger to everyone you haven't burned or been burned by. True friends stop appearing after a certain age, and once you drift apart from the peers of your authentic, formative youth, it's extremely rare and difficult to invest honest childhood trust in anyone ever again. This isn't some synaptic chemical thing. Getting old sucks, and lots of people hate the way their lives turn out. I'd hazard a bet that fact is true for the majority of all people, who simply spend the rest of their adulthood coping with the bleakness of existence. But, hey, maybe I'm "mentally ill."
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago>One complicating factor – how do we explain depressed people’s frequent certainty that they’ll fail? A proper Bayesian, barred from having confident beliefs about anything, will be maximally uncertain about whether she’ll fail or succeed – but some depressed people have really strong opinions on this issue. I’m not really sure about this, and admit it’s a point against this theory. I can only appeal to the math class example again – if there was a math class where I just had no confidence about anything I thought or said, I would probably be pretty sure I’d fail there too. I think the model actually fits here better than the author realizes. Predicting failure is much safer than predicting success, it's erring on the side of caution. If you predict that you will fail at something and prepare for the consequences of that failure, but succeed instead, you are better off than if you had predicted success, prepared for success, and failed. To me, it makes sense that, when uncertain, the default would be to predict failure. And later: >One problem with this theory is the time course. Sure, if you’re eternally successful, you should raise your confidence. But eternally successful people are rarely eternally happy. If we’re thinking of happiness-as-felt-emotion,itt seems more like they’re happy for a few hours after they win an award or make their first million or whatever, then go back down to baseline. I’m not sure it makes sense to start lots of new projects in the hour after you win an award. Wouldn't a rise in confidence have a corresponding rise in expectations? New goals mean a return to the state of "haven't succeeded yet". Personally I'm finding this model seems to fit better than any other model I've heard of. Of course, I'm just some idiot on the internet, not a psychiatrist.
- pault 9y agoThis sounds a lot like Martin Seligman's work. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Seligman https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Seligman
- Asooka 9y agoOr rather there is no predicting failure. You only predict success and when you have low confidence in success, you're certain of failure.
- themodelplumber 9y agoIt's a weird coincidence to read this. I was doing basic research on depression and saw that dopamine played a role in helping people feel good. One WikiHow article [0] later, I had an idea: Start reaching goals. I started very small, like taking progressively longer walks. Since that time I have earned something like five different certificates in various areas of interest (ARRL coming up next) and as a very recent development, completed my university degree after 15 years of delay due to, among other things, depression. I find that depression can still affect me, but the episodes don't last as long (around 2h max, lately) and I have a bunch of tools for dealing with them. [0] http://m.wikihow.com/Increase-Dopamine http://m.wikihow.com/Increase-Dopamine
- diminish 9y agoGreat idea. I usually make checklists for small things when I feel lost and achieve them and feel accomplished. Things like "check x", "read about xx", 'backup file", "congratulate people with birthdays on FB" When i mark them as done I feel better.
- 123jay7 9y agoI think we're fucked as a society if this is what it's come to. Grown adults making checklists to make them selves feel better. Jesus Christ....
- davymac 9y agoThis works very well for low-grade depression for sure. There seems to be a threshold where this type of intervention becomes completely ineffective (personal experience).
- themodelplumber 9y agoI agree. From keeping logs over the last few years, severe depression was more likely to occur due to e.g. not enough sleep or just illness, and in those cases accomplishments were impossible. Rest was it, and I felt lucky if I could get good rest before acting on any depressing thoughts or ruminations. So I wouldn't call goal-reaching a standalone cure; far from it. Also there's the fact that people accept/reject potentially helpful information based on different criteria, from very rational (is it in a reputable journal) to irrational (do I like the person who gave the information) to incredibly subjective (did I think of it on my own?). So the idea of "why not try accomplishment" may be doomed from the start, due to factors outside of the advisor's control.
- akeck 9y agoNo mention of sleep? * http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpsy/article/PIIS2215-0366(17)30328-0/fulltext http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpsy/article/PIIS2215-03...
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoI think there's a lot of agreement that sleep is important, but not much consensus around models that are useful for treating it. Right now there's a big push for CBT-I, but the evidence is mostly low-quality and not really focused on anything except reducing subjective insomnia severity (this study is better than most in that respect).
- whiddershins 9y agoIt's great to see this here. For context, this is the model the author is referencing: https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/09/05/book-review-surfing-uncertainty/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/09/05/book-review-surfing-un... Scott Alexander is currently my favorite essayist. I just wasted most of yesterday reading the last 18 months of his "links" posts. I regularly pass his work on to friends and would do so more often if I didn't think it would upset people.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoI’m not sure why none of the studies touch on seasonal variation. I think I will research more of that but does anyone has a reference?
- TheCowboy 9y agoThis? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_affective_disorder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_affective_disorder
- david-cako 9y agoThis particular topic is very much of interest to me; I've spent a good amount of time thinking about how depression relates to ADHD. Depression and ADHD are both related to dopamine and norepinephrine dysfunction, but depression has a strong element of serotonin dysfunction as well. One of the defining characteristics of hyperactive individuals is their addiction to stimulation (work, learning, leisure), which to me seems like it's fed by negative reinforcement. Removal of these things sends them into a depressive state because there simply isn't anything keeping them excited (and perhaps distracted from neuroticism). It seems like depression is kind of the contrapositive. There is the same element of dopamine dysfunction, spawning disinterest and hopelessness, but they lack the positive reinforcement of anything to pull them out of. I think this is where the sprinkling of serotonin dysfunction into the pie comes in. There's a very low level of security or confidence in any sort of endeavor.
- cassowary37 9y agoProfessor of psychiatry here - I've spent the past 20 years trying to help folks with depression, and related illnesses, and trying to study these diseases at a genetic level. I suspect this will get me down-voted as I know the medical/biological perspective is often unwelcome on hn. However: a key error people make here and elsewhere in speculating about depression (and suicide, and ADHD, and...) is either extrapolating only from their own experience, or from a vastly oversimplified psychology 101 perspective. For example: "Depressed people move more slowly, in a characteristic pattern called “psychomotor retardation”. Well, yes - except when they have agitated depression, characterized by psychomotor restlessness. Or, when they have neither of these. Likewise, oversimplifying by claiming it is a disease of dopamine, or serotonin, doesn't much help. When my car stops working, is it a disease of gasoline? Part of the challenge of depression is its very heterogeneity. What we need is not more theorizing, it is more recognition that we need better treatments of all sorts.
- roflc0ptic 9y agoWithout commenting on content, I will point out that the author of the article is a psychiatrist as well.
- cassowary37 9y agoYes. This is one reason I bothered to comment. Psychiatrists who step into the public space bear a particular obligation both to advocate for our patients and to push back against misinformation.
- ferbivore 9y agoI don't think this article was meant to be widely shared, especially not in a public space like Hacker News. Alexander has a number of articles about depression grounded in actual established psychiatry and is, unsurprisingly, a big proponent of treating it - I'm not sure how you're getting "doesn't advocate for his patients" from this article. Also, it literally starts with the words "total wild speculation". It certainly looks like it's supposed to start a discussion rather than be informative.
- Oxitendwe 9y agoWhat I have found through my experiences with depressed people is that the vast majority of them are not insane people in a sane society, but perfectly sane people in an insane society, people who have maladapted to their environment but would otherwise (if they had a better one) be perfectly healthy individuals. Many of them internalize their sadness and helplessness and make it a part of their identity, further reinforcing the common belief among depressed people that they are ill at a biological level (and are not merely healthy people in an unhealthy environment). I don't think the solution to this is ever going to lay in the hands of psychologists, and certainly not psychiatrists (SSRI's and SNRI's work only slightly better than chance in most people, and taking other antidepressant/mood-stabilizing medication is a hellish experience all its own) - it lays in the hands of the people who construct the environment we live in, the people in charge of its development and health, the people who have the most power over society. These are the people who have destroyed it and made the environment we all have to live in such a hellish place, and their successors will certainly be the only people who can fix it.
- defined 9y agoI don't know. Depression has been recorded for thousands of years, so either society has always been insane (quite likely), in which case it's not likely to turn around any time soon, or there are other causes of depression. Some people can also fall into a depression for no identifiable reason (I can vouch for that from experience). SSRIs and SNRIs and other medications have saved my life and some of my sanity, and I have high confidence that it's not a placebo - for me - having tried and failed with probably a dozen of these over the years, before hitting on a workable combination. And after maybe 5 years or so, that combination became ineffective, and I had to try a few more. But that's just me, so this is anecdata.
- Oxitendwe 9y ago>I don't know. Depression has been recorded for thousands of years, so either society has always been insane (quite likely), in which case it's not likely to turn around any time soon, or there are other causes of depression. Some people can also fall into a depression for no identifiable reason (I can vouch for that from experience). Of course there have always been depressed people, but the modern phenomenon where supposedly 10% of the population will have it in their lives, or where entire countries experience skyrocketing suicide rates, is certainly not related - I find it very difficult to believe that they all have a biological problem, instead of a cultural or societal problem. >SSRIs and SNRIs and other medications have saved my life and some of my sanity, and I have high confidence that it's not a placebo - for me - having tried and failed with probably a dozen of these over the years, before hitting on a workable combination. I don't doubt this - I only said that the vast majority of sufferers of depression do not seem to suffer from a biological problem. From my personal experience, I have seen that most of the depressed people I have known have gotten better not through medicine or medical procedure, but by consciously trying to make their lives better and be the best person they can be. Obviously this won't work for everyone - there really is such a thing as biologically-caused mental illness (see: schizophrenia, for example), but I think it is much rarer than people are willing to admit. >But that's just me, so this is anecdata. All data is anecdata. It's not worthless just because it happens to be your actual life and not collated and tallied by some detached scientist, it has meaning and value even without being a part of some anonymous dataset you can take confidence intervals on.
- icc97 9y agoI typically have odd thoughts that are often wrong. But I really like quote from 'The Martian', "let's science the shit out of it". I don't know if it's possible to science your way out of depression. If in some way the curiosity gives a small enough lift to keep you getting one foot in front of the other and learning about what's causing your depression. It at least seems relatively risk free way of tackling depression. Learn about the beast and track what you do and what changes your mood. But is this something you can tell people that are seriously depressed or is it just another useless bit of advice?
- defined 9y ago> But is this something you can tell people that are seriously depressed or is it just another useless bit of advice? From my point of view, it's not useful advice, partly because severe depression utterly saps the motivation to do virtually anything, and partly because depression is highly resistant to rationality. Mandatory references to "Hyperbole and a Half"[1][2]. [1]: http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.com/2011/10/adventures-in-depression.html http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.com/2011/10/adventures-in-... [2]: http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.com/2013/05/depression-part-two.html http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.com/2013/05/depression-par...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- icc97 9y agoYes, this wouldn't work for the most serious cases of depression. It might help for those who are at a stage where they're willing to try something.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]