7 ms·
Would you say the same thing if Chinese or Venezuelan courts banned google apps that give information "considered illegal" there? This is ridiculous. The app
by enriquto 9y ago
Would you say the same thing if Chinese or Venezuelan courts banned google apps that give information "considered illegal" there?
This is ridiculous. The app just gives a list of the schools to vote according to your address. Even if the referendum is "illegal" under spanish law, it is completely bananas to ban such an app.
- ghostly_s 9y agoI think in many first-world nations, distributing info intended to enable others to commit a crime is, itself, a crime. (Which is not to suggest I agree with the state's legal ruling here.) Edit: but of course the referendum itself being illegal does not necessarily imply that voting in it, is illegal. And it seems more reasonable that the state could determine the results of the referendum to be non-binding per their constitution, rather than being justified in preventing it from taking place.
- enriquto 9y agoOK, but voting in this referendum, even under current spanish law, is not actually commiting any crime.
- ghostly_s 9y agoYou're probably right, but I think Google could make an argument that any app which is even adjacent to "illegal activity" may be a violation of their ToS, regardless of the app's actual legal status. And there's much less argument to be made here for Google's obligation to tolerate this use-case because their store does not operate as a monopoly on the platform like Apple's does.
- KekDemaga 9y agoMultiple backpage (a popular escort site) apps are currently in the store so that can't be the reason.
- bmelton 9y agoAs of Backpage v Dart, the activities on Backpage are presumptively lawful. This isn't to say that every action that occurs on Backpage is above board (just as not every transaction on Facebook is). That said, the case was premised on a Sheriff making it his mission to shut them down, so it's probably worth finding out what Google did during that time.
- mseebach 9y agoGoogle aren't making arguments as to what is legal or not, a Spanish court is.
- jorgemf 9y agoYou need a bit of feedback for this. There is a big amount of people in Cataluña that doesn't want the independence. There is people who wants a completely independence and doesn't understand the consecuences. And there is a lot of corrupted politics that wants only a partial independence to be avoid judge by the law. I post a video in my first comment, take a look. It is nothing to be like what happens in China or Venezuela, the comparison is a non-sense. EDIT: I forgot the people who want to use it as distraction to avoid talking about their corruption and other issues.
- enriquto 9y agoThe political video that you posted (only in spanish, and from 2015) is not very helpful, nor related to the current topic (the removal of an app from google due to the pressure of a government in a desperate crisis).
- jorgemf 9y agoIs it form 2015? I though it was from this month. Anyway it was for background of the topic. I just realized you might be Catalan. Don't get me wrong, I think people should have the right to decide by themselves, but you have to tell them the truth of what will happen and have an open dialog. Not what we are doing now on both sides of the problem. Comparing Cataluña with Venezuela or China is a non-sense. Although we might end up as Venezuela (lot of corruption everywhere, poor people, etc), I think we are still far from it. The law has been like this since decades, and no one did nothing to change it, even the catalans.
- jorgemf 9y agoI always wanted to understand what type of independence do you want exactly. Could you give me your opinion? Between a completely independent state as if Cataluña had a cristal bubble around it and nothing can enter or leave it, and the current sittuation, how much independent Cataluña wants to be? I heard some people wants to be an associate State to Spain and others to be a completely separate state (which means things like enter again the european union)
- euyyn 9y ago
- balls187 9y agoI think that's the point of the parent poster--it's politics, not some crazy Google policy. Google complied with the Spanish courts; complying with local laws is something Google does routinely (as does every other global corporation for that matter). ETA: Aware that plenty of companies selectively choose what laws they follow (see Uber). Just generally their stated policy is "We comply with local laws"
- x220 9y agoThis is a moral issue as well as a legal issue.
- balls187 9y agoWhat is the moral issue here?
- robhu 9y agoFrom Wikipedia: The right of people to self-determination is a cardinal principle in modern international law (commonly regarded as a jus cogens rule), binding, as such, on the United Nations as authoritative interpretation of the Charter's norms. It states that a people, based on respect for the principle of equal rights and fair equality of opportunity, have the right to freely choose their sovereignty and international political status with no interference. ... self-determination entails the "moral double helix" of duality (personal right to align with a people, and the people's right to determine their politics) and mutuality (the right is as much the other's as the self’s). Thus, self-determination grants individuals the right to form "a people," which then has the right to establish an independent state, as long as they grant the same to all other individuals and peoples.
- dTal 9y agoHowever you feel about it, it would be incredibly worrying if Google started ignoring local laws because it disagreed with them; it doesn't have any particular moral high ground from which to make such decisions.
- 9y ago
- mseebach 9y agoNo, because neither China or Venezuela are considered to be under the rule of law. Spain is, and it's constitution is pretty unambiguous on the matter: Section 2. The Constitution is based on the indissoluble unity of the Spanish Nation, the common and indivisible homeland of all Spaniards https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Constitution_of_1978 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Constitution_of_1978 Aiding and abetting a crime is also a crime. "Just" giving a list of addresses of, say, brothels is a crime in a jurisdiction where prostitution is illegal. Yes, it's bananas that the central Spanish government has this reaction, but it's a perfectly correct and legal reaction, and this is part and parcel of the idea that Google should abide by the law in the countries where it operates. From a distance it seems that it would have been preferable to let the referendum go ahead with as little fanfare as possible, but make clear that it's outcome has no legal status whatsoever, but then again, I'm not in the hot seat, representing a national constituency that's overwhelmingly against independence.
- throwaway613834 9y ago> No, because neither China or Venezuela are considered to be under the rule of law. Considered... by who? Do their governments view themselves that way?
- x220 9y agoAs considered by reasonable outside observers which are not corrupt. The corruption in these countries and the actions they take which are based on decrees and fiat, rather than actions carried out equally and fairly according to defined law, have been widely documented.
- throwaway613834 9y ago> As considered by reasonable outside observers which are not corrupt. You really don't seem to be willing to consider that two reasonable people can have differing opinions about the same situation. Who appoints these "reasonable outside observers"? And who defines who or what is "corrupt"? It all just boils down to what you yourself view as corrupt or reasonable.